Atlantis Bahamas Review: Good and Bad

I don’t know about where you live, but here in the Northeast we are bombarded with commercials from cruise lines and Atlantis in the Bahamas from November through March.  They make it look so enticing — water slides, pools, dolphin encounters, casinos, restaurants, and “great deals” — so a couple of years ago we decided to take the plunge (literally and figuratively) and escape to the Atlantis for a multi-generational family vacation over President’s Day weekend.

I’ll lay out the good and the bad in this Atlantis Bahamas review below, but let me start by saying that if you are looking for a relaxing, laid-back, authentic Caribbean experience, don’t go to the Atlantis.  If you love cruises, all-inclusives, waterparks and gambling then the Atlantis might be for you.

Atlantis Bahamas Reviews

Let’s start with the Good:

  • The Waterpark: included in a stay at the Atlantis is admission to their massive waterpark, which includes over twenty million gallons of water, Atlantean-themed towers, high-speed water slides, a mile-long river ride with rolling rapids and wave surges, 20 swimming areas, a kids water-play fort and 11 swimming pools.  There is so much to do that you can stay busy all day. You can float down the less-than lazy river, shoot through tubes underwater surrounded by sharks, slide through the dark, or splash down the baby slides. There were quite a few little ones in our group so we staked out chairs near the splash area but close enough to the more thrilling slides to satisfy the older kids (and adults). The downside to the waterpark is the sheer size. It is hard to keep track of the kids, especially with different ages, with so many different attractions.
Atlantis pyramid slide from Atlantis Bahamas Reviews from We3Travel.com

Atlantis Pyramid Slide

  • Marine Habitat: I think one of the reasons why the Atlantis is so expensive is to pay for the upkeep of their marine habitat.  The resort offers 14 lagoons, eight million gallons of salt water and more than 50,000 aquatic animals representing over 250 marine species. These exhibits are spread throughout the grounds with displays like The Dig (a psuedo-underwater archeological discovery featuring giant manta rays and other sealife), the predator tunnel (where you walk surrounded by the sea’s scariest creatures), and a number of different lagoons offering stingray feedings and dolphin encounters.

    Predator tunnel at the Altantis Bahamas -- Atlantis Bahamas Reviews from We3Travel.com

    Predator Tunnel at the Atlantis Bahamas

Sharks at the Atlantis Bahamas from Atlantis Bahamas Reviews from We3Travel.com

Water slide past the sharks

  • Dolphin Cay: If you have ever dreamed of swimming with dolphins or frolicking with sea lions, you can fulfill your dreams at Dolphin Cay. Prepare to pay through the nose, have less time than you hope for, and be totally ripped off if you want to purchase the pictures…but…the smile on your and your child’s face is truly priceless.  Just be sure to book early as this is a very popular cruise-line excursion and fills up early.
Dolphin Cay at The Atlantis Bahamas from Atlantis Bahamas Reviews via We3Travel.com

Kissing Echo at Dolphin Cay

 

  • Something for everyone: The Atlantis is a lot like a cruise ship on land…just much bigger.  You really can find something for everyone…teen dance clubs, cooking classes, swimming, waterpark, gambling, kids clubs, game room, water sports, spa, rock climbing, and more.  Just keep in mind that all this is spread out across multiple towers so it might feel like you have to walk a mile or more from your room to your selected activity.
Rock climbing at the Atlantis Bahamas from Atlantis Bahamas Reviews from We3Travel.com

Rock climbing at the Atlantis

 

Now, let’s take a look at the Bad:

  • Food: theoretically, the Atlantis offers great food options, including restaurants from Bobby Flay, Todd English and Nobu Matsuhisa. However, since you will probably only splurge for one meal at these fine dining establishments (unless you win big at the casino), the rest of the food is overpriced and just mediocre. Since we were going with a large group of 14, we opted to try the meal plan since it seemed like it offered a cost savings.  What we weren’t told was that a lot of the family-friendly dining options like Johnny Rockets and room service were not included in the meal plan and we ended up double paying for certain meals.  The other options, like the chinese restaurant and steakhouse were just average and quite overpriced. The other downside about the food was the lack of Bahamian or Caribbean flair.  Out by the waterpark, all the snack bars offered the same fare.  It was very Disneyworld-esque, hamburgers, hot dogs, veggie wraps.  I left craving conch fritters or something authentic.
  • The crowds: The Atlantis is big, really big.  Looking out my window at night was disconcerting.  I was in the Caribbean right? Why was I looking out and seeing hotel towers lighting up the sky? Was this Vegas? But while the Atlantis can hold thousands of people, what you don’t realize at first is that the Atlantis is packed not just with people staying there, but it is also filled with cruise ship passengers that have bought a day pass to enjoy the Atlantis waterpark and facilities. Scores of cruise ship passengers and visitors from neighboring hotels fill the Atlantis.
  • The rooms: even with the amazing “deals” the Atlantis offers, the rooms were still over $500 per night in the non-centrally located Coral Towers. For that price, we expected something more.  The rooms were very bland and in need of a renovation.  They were spacious but more inline with an old Marriott or Hilton than a Hyatt / Westin or luxury hotel.
  • The beach: there are certainly more pools than you can swim in during your vacation but if you come to the Caribbean, you probably would also like to spend some time at the beach.  If you are a beach-goer, you really might want to look elsewhere.  There is a manufactured lagoon beach but the ocean beach is quite small and under-serviced.
Atlantis beach from Atlantis Bahamas Reviews on We3Travel.com

The beach at the Atlantis

The bottom line: the kids absolutely loved the Atlantis while all the adults generally felt it was overpriced, too big, and too commercial. What about you? Have you been to the Atlantis? Did you love it, hate it or in between? I’d love to hear your Atlantis Bahamas reviews in the comments below.

Plan this trip!

Check current promotions at the Atlantis!

Keep an eye out for cheap airfare with Airfare Watchdog

Get Help Planning This Trip

PIN THIS FOR LATER

Atlantis Bahamas reviews -- I'll show you the pros and the cons, the good and the bad about the Atlantis Resort in the Bahamas.

 

21 Comments on “Atlantis Bahamas Review: Good and Bad

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I visited Atlantis with my family for 5 days and absolutely agree with EVERYTHING you said in your review. Many thanks for that detailed and true review!

      Thanks for coming by and leaving the comment Cleo! It can be a great place for a family vacation with so much to do it just depends on the experience you are looking for and who much you want to pay for it. I think I prefer something more intimate and laid back.

    Thanks for the great review, Tamara. Thinking of going to the Bahamas with my kids but I’ve got some concerns about if the Atlantis is the right place for us, so I was happy to hear both sides for the story. Thanks!

      Glad to help! It definitely depends on what you are looking for.

    Here now, and trying to find a plus about the room in Royal Tower West. I would settle for a comfortable bed! The water parks are great as well as the kids activities.

      Oh no! I’m sorry you are not in a good room. I also found the rooms to be not nearly what I would expect for that price.

    We have been staying at the Cove at the Atlantis for the past five years….with a meal plan and we love it. We have been to many other islands but nothing compares to the beauty and service at the Atlantis, yes it is expensive but you get what you pay for, Cove is the only way to go.

    I only visited as a cruise ship passenger and would not want to stay in the hotel that allows the day passes! (one “plus” if I may (or at least the excitement) was to meet the celebrities. I ran into Halle Barry and Rudy Giuliani on separate day visits)

    If price is the main concern go during non- peak times. Also its not really Advertised but stay at Comfort Suites right next door to Atlantis. you get all the amenities and passes as if you were staying at Atlantis.
    Example: 12/14-12/18 stay with all taxes and fees

    Atlantis Beach Tower – $1197.26
    Comfort Suites – $866.69

    I am curios, and not knocking you in any way. However, were there negative reviews on this place before you decided to make arrangements to go. I was thinking about taking my family, but with more investigation, and your blog confirms everything else that i have heard. I am having a lot of second thoughts in regards to spending the money to go.

      I’ve always heard mixed reviews as I think it depends on what you enjoy and what type of vacation you are looking for. This was booked by my in laws and we were there with extended family so I didn’t have a choice on the destination. The idea was to find something that would make everyone happy, especially the kids.

    Been to Atlantis 3 times and heading back in July. Me and my two daughters absolutely love it and can’t wait to return. We stay in the Royal Towers and yes, it is pricey, but I wouldn’t stay anywhere else. You can find decent food, not too expensive if you look around. Check the cruise ship schedules to find when it’s not so crowded and plan your day accordingly.

    Hands down the best resort for the whole family. I agree with everything you said except for the beaches. If you stay at the Cove or the Reef the beaches are awesome! Very secluded and hardly any waves, which was great for my 2 year old in 2012, that’s the first year we started going there. My kids never wants to come home when we’re there…

    We are at Atlantis now and very disappointed .. We went to olives for dinner and could not get waited on. Server were just standing there waited 10 min so we left. We returned back to the club level and told them what happened. Nothing has been done at this time. We can afford to go anywhere for dinner but someone who can’t has to sit and wait. We also asked to put our names on a cabana for the week. Found out that they didn’t put our name on the list. We are staying at the cove . Our room is 2500 a night. The food is just alright. The pool at the cove is beautiful but I didn’t expect romper room. The sign say 18 and over. I was a bartender for many years and would card have the people and 20 percent would be 15 to 17 years old. One mother even let it slip that here twins were 17. They were there with 6 of there friends. We have been to Atlantis many times and will not return.

    Down at the cove pool and the fighting has already started over chairs.

    Going next week with some doubts. Went to the Rui last year in aruba- amazing and stunning beach/weather
    Went to Cancun earlier this year and weather was not good

    Just left Atlantis today, 5/3/2017. Here is my take, plain and simple. The resort is nice. But they will RIP you off, every chance they get. with unknown charges daily. not to mention winning at the Texas Holdem table and after being paid out by the dealer and 2 managers. the pit boss says ,” THAT’S NOT RIGHT, Take their money back”. And it was a sizeable win ( straight flush) progressive. after talking with management, they said they would credit my account 1oo dollars. a far cry from what I won. they didn’t. long story SHORT…Pun intended. We will never be returning to ATLANTIS again. you ONLY get One chance to impress me when it costs that much to stay there.

      Next time check out renting at HaRBorside! You will love it! Very cost effective! See my comments describing why. We are owners . Our family loves it there. We also rent out, if we are not using it.
      Staff is terrifc!

    Hi! Our family of 3 was one of the many cruise ship passengers that enjoyed the day at the Atlantis. Honestly, I’m glad we did it that way for all the reasons you mentioned. We had a fantastic time at the waterpark (my 6 yr old was in heaven) but I can see how staying there would be costly and probably not worth it. I even commented how irritated I would be with all the cruise people if I was paying the high dollar to stay there. We got best of both worlds… an awesome day at a world class waterpark but not the high price for everything else. It’s definitely something to see… just be ready for everything else 🙂

Get your free Family Vacation Planning Kit

Sign up for our newsletter and receive a Family Vacation Planning Kit with tips, questionnaires, budget templates, checklists and a planning timeline.