Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Some of the best steak dinners in Ohio are not served in Columbus or Cleveland at all. One of them sits in a tiny village in Columbiana County, inside a brick building that went up in 1837.
Presidents have a connection to the place, the walls hold old deeds and newspaper clippings, and the kitchen turns out an 18-ounce Delmonico that regulars talk about for years. It is the kind of spot locals mention quietly, almost like a secret they are not sure they want to share.
Keep reading to learn where it is, what to order, when to go, and how to plan the drive so the trip pays off.
A Brick Landmark on Plymouth Street

Small villages rarely get credit for big dinners, and Hanoverton is out to change that. The Spread Eagle Tavern & Inn stands at 10150 Plymouth St, Hanoverton, OH 44423, in the rolling countryside of eastern Ohio.
The building is an American restaurant and a historic inn rolled into one. It sits just 0.2 miles from US Hwy 30, so the route in is simpler than the rural setting suggests.
Guests come for supper, for an overnight stay, or for both. The dining rooms fill the lower levels, while the guestrooms sit on the second and third floors.
The whole place carries a strong reputation, holding a 4.7-star average across more than a thousand opinions. That is a lot of happy diners for a village most Ohioans could not find on a map.
The setting matters here as much as the menu. Nearby buildings along the street share the same old-fashioned charm, and a short stroll after a meal is encouraged.
Think of it as a steakhouse that comes with a history lesson attached, and a fairly long one at that.
Nearly Two Centuries Behind the Front Door

Construction on this brick building wrapped up in 1837, back when Ohio was still a young state. That date alone puts it among the older working dining spots in the region.
Its proudest claim involves Abraham Lincoln. He gave a speech in one of the rooms, a detail the staff and the decor both celebrate.
Portraits of presidents with ties to the tavern line the walls. Old deeds and newspaper articles hang nearby, giving the halls the feel of a small museum.
Another room is tied to a 19th-century ghost story, which makes for good dinner conversation. Nobody has to believe it to enjoy hearing about it.
The staff encourages guests to wander and look around. Rooms can be explored as long as nothing else is going on and they are not occupied.
That open-door attitude turns a meal into a self-guided tour. Plenty of families spend as much time reading the walls as reading the menu, and nobody seems to mind.
History here is not behind glass, and it is not in a hurry either.
The 18-Ounce Delmonico Everyone Talks About

Eighteen ounces is a serious amount of steak, and the Delmonico here carries that weight with confidence. It is the cut that earns the most loyal fans.
Diners describe it as expertly prepared and unforgettable. Some go further and call it the meal they would pick above all others.
Anniversary couples have ordered matching Delmonicos and called them excellent. The chef gets credit as a true artist for how the steak comes off the grill.
Prime rib also draws plenty of attention, showing up often when regulars list their favorites. Strip steaks, filet mignon and a flat iron round out the beef side of the menu.
Honesty helps here, so here it is. Doneness has not always landed perfectly, and a few tables have received steaks cooked more or less than requested.
Speaking up politely about temperature when ordering can help. Most nights, though, the beef is the reason people make the drive in the first place.
A steakhouse in a town this small has no business being this good, yet here we are, fork in hand.
Wellington, Pot Pie and Other Old-School Favorites

Beef Wellington sounds like something from a fancy hotel in a big city. In Hanoverton, it sits right on the menu and ranks as one of the most mentioned dishes.
The kitchen leans into classic continental cooking. That means dishes that feel at home in an 1837 building, served without trendy twists.
Chicken pot pie is another regular favorite, and Chicken Wellington appears as well. Amish Chicken with homemade mashed potatoes gives the menu a local Ohio touch.
Results on the Wellington can vary from night to night. Some plates have arrived with less pastry than expected, so it pays to keep expectations grounded.
Lobster ravioli with shrimp and salmon add options for anyone skipping red meat. Brussels sprouts have earned real praise as a side when they are in stock.
The menu reads like a greatest hits album of American and continental dining. Not every track is a chart-topper, but the classics usually play well.
Chowder and a Lighter Lunch

Not every trip needs to end with a giant steak. The lunch window offers a calmer way to try the kitchen.
New England clam chowder shows up often among the dishes people remember. It pairs well with the cod and wild rice, which have been called excellent lunch choices.
Lunch runs from 11:30 am to 3 pm most days. That makes it a smart option for road-trippers who want to drive home before dark.
Caesar salad is another easy pick for a lighter plate. Salads in general hold up well, even on busy days with large groups.
Fish lovers should know one detail. The walleye has come with a warning that it may contain bones, so choose accordingly.
Midday also means more light for exploring the rooms and the street outside. A bowl of chowder and a walk through history makes for a pretty good afternoon.
Fireplaces in Nearly Every Corner

Fireplaces come up more than any other feature, and for good reason. They are everywhere in this building.
The main dining room centers on a huge stone fireplace. It sets the tone for a rustic, old-fashioned evening.
Several guestrooms also have their own fireplaces. The neighboring 1820 house offers them too.
Cooler months suit the place especially well. Regular guests who visit in winter, spring and summer often name winter as their favorite season here.
That makes the tavern a strong pick as fall arrives. A drive through the countryside followed by dinner near a hearth is a solid evergreen plan.
Families planning holiday outings may find the setting fits the mood. Just remember that busy holiday weekends can bring slower service.
The fire is not the main course, but it may be the best seat in the house.
Candlelight in the Speakeasy

Hidden inside the tavern is a room called the Speakeasy, and landing a table there feels like winning a small prize. Dining happens by candlelight in a cozy, tucked-away space.
Couples tend to love it for anniversaries and date nights. The room offers a more private feel than the larger dining areas.
Not every reservation ends up there. Asking about it when booking is a reasonable move, though availability is never a sure thing.
The Jefferson Room is another named space that people remember. Each room carries its own personality and decor.
Variety like this means two visits can feel quite different. A family supper in a bright room and a quiet dinner downstairs are not the same outing at all.
Choosing a room is a little like choosing a chapter in the building’s long story.
Rooms Upstairs and a House Next Door

Dinner does not have to end with a long drive home. Guestrooms on the upper floors let diners stay the night.
Each room is individually decorated with antique furniture. Some offer claw-foot tubs, canopy beds and fireplaces.
Staff show guests to their rooms after check-in, which helps since the building can be a bit of a maze. Small touches like bottled water, coffee pods and cookies often wait on a table.
The smallest rooms may skip extras like a fridge or microwave. A courtyard view can make up for it.
A full breakfast is included and served personally rather than as a hotel buffet. Free Wi-Fi and free parking are part of the stay.
Bigger groups can rent a neighboring 1820 house with a kitchen and two bedrooms with canopy beds. It works well for families wanting more space.
The property is also listed as pet-friendly, so the four-legged travelers can come along too.
Who Will Love It Most

Anniversaries seem to find their way to this tavern. Couples marking 39 years together have chosen it for a first visit and left happy.
History fans get the most bang for the drive. The Lincoln connection, presidential portraits and framed documents give them plenty to study.
Families who enjoy old buildings can turn dinner into a walking lesson. Kids may like hunting for the room tied to the ghost story.
Repeat travelers make it part of their routine, returning with parents season after season. That kind of loyalty says a lot.
The vibe is classy but rustic, not stiff. Large parties and birthday dinners happen here regularly.
It is less ideal for anyone in a rush. Meals can run long, so this is a place for lingering rather than grabbing a quick bite.
Patience is the one ingredient guests should bring themselves.
Hours, Costs and the Fine Print

Timing a visit takes a little planning because the kitchen splits its day. Monday through Thursday, hours are 11:30 am to 3 pm, then 5 to 8 pm.
Friday and Saturday follow the same lunch window, with dinner stretching to 9 pm. Sunday runs straight through from 11:30 am to 6 pm.
Dinner sits on the pricier side, and nobody pretends otherwise. One dinner for two came to about $130 before tip.
The Sunday menu is considered reasonably priced, which makes it the value play. Families watching the budget should aim for that day or for lunch.
A 3 percent card fee applies to the bill. Bringing cash can be useful, though the fee has been charged on full totals in the past.
Reservations are strongly recommended, especially for dinner. Booking a meal at the same time as a room is a smart idea.
A little planning keeps the evening about the food and not the logistics.
The Drive and the Neighborhood

Getting here is easier than the countryside setting suggests. US Hwy 30 runs just 0.2 miles away.
The closest town with other food options sits about a 20 to 25 minute drive away. That is one more reason to lock in reservations before leaving home.
Guilford Lake State Park lies 5.6 miles from the inn. It makes a natural add-on for a day trip in mild weather.
The Lisbon Historical Society is 9.5 miles away. History fans can stack a second stop onto the outing with little effort.
Hanoverton itself has a classic American village look. Other buildings close to the tavern share the same charm and are worth a short walk.
Some folks find the drive long, so planning a full day around it helps. A fall road trip with a park stop, a museum visit and dinner turns the miles into part of the fun.
A Verdict Worth the Miles

Perfection is rare, and this tavern does not claim it. Service can slow down on busy nights, and a few dishes have missed the mark.
Still, the big picture is hard to argue with. A 4.7-star average across more than 1,100 opinions points to far more great nights than rough ones.
The Delmonico, the prime rib and the old-school specialties give steak fans a real reason to drive. The building adds a layer no modern steakhouse can copy.
Lincoln’s speech, the fireplaces, the Speakeasy and the antique rooms all make the visit feel bigger than one meal. Staying overnight turns it into a full getaway.
Go on a Sunday for value, or book a weeknight dinner for a quieter pace. Either way, reserve ahead and leave room in the schedule.
For Ohioans hunting places their neighbors have not found yet, this little village steakhouse deserves a spot at the top of the list, right next to the fire.

