This Charming Little Indiana Restaurant Serves A Shepherd’s Pie Locals Talk About Long After Dinner

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Seventy-four mentions. That is how often a single dish comes up when people talk about one pub near the Purdue campus.

West Lafayette has plenty of places to eat, yet this Irish pub keeps pulling in students, parents, alumni, and out-of-town coworkers who plan whole trips around it. The shepherd’s pie is the headliner, but the story reaches well beyond one plate.

Here is what makes the place a local habit, when to go, and what to know before the drive.

A Pub Near Purdue With a Pie Reputation

A Pub Near Purdue With a Pie Reputation
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Nine Irish Brothers sits at 119 Howard Ave, West Lafayette, IN 47906, United States, a short trip from the Purdue campus. It is listed as an Irish restaurant, and it holds a 4.7-star average across more than 2,900 reviews.

The shepherd’s pie is the dish that comes up most. It has 74 mentions in the popular topics, far ahead of anything else on the menu.

Locals who say the name usually follow it with a story. A birthday dinner, a move-in day meal, or a stop before a concert often ends up in the telling.

The pub bills itself as a traditional spot with Irish and American comfort fare, draft brews, and a lively setting. Hours are listed as 11 am to 11 pm most days, with later closing on Friday and Saturday and an earlier close on Sunday, so check before heading out.

Two Decades of Birthdays and Homecomings

Two Decades of Birthdays and Homecomings
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Some restaurants collect customers. This one collects family traditions.

One longtime guest describes twenty years of birthdays, holidays, college meetups, and yearly return trips from ten hours away.

Owners Jan and Jerry are known by name to regulars, and the owners often appear in the dining room. That presence helps explain why guests say they feel like family.

The pub has also grown beyond one door. Guests mention visits to all three pubs, and one remembers a location in Indianapolis from years back.

That kind of loyalty is hard to fake. It builds slowly, one dinner at a time, and it shows in how often people return after a move, a graduation, or a long drive.

The Shepherd’s Pie Everyone Brings Up

The Shepherd's Pie Everyone Brings Up
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Few dishes get named this often. Guests call the shepherd’s pie a highlight, and one visitor with experience in Ireland said the pub felt authentic enough to win over a skeptic.

The kitchen has addressed how it is made. The pub notes that the dish is technically a cottage pie, and says it ranks as the third best-selling item among guests of all ages.

That honesty is part of the charm. A reader checking the menu will find the details spelled out, and servers are happy to explain.

Soda bread from the owner’s family recipe has been mentioned alongside it. Some diners pair the pie with sandwiches or a shared salad, which makes for an easy table spread.

Beyond the Pie: Stew, Bangers, and Pub Chips

Beyond the Pie: Stew, Bangers, and Pub Chips
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Plenty of regulars order something else, and the numbers back that up. Bangers and mash has 30 mentions, fried pickles 15, Guinness stew 14, and pub chips 11.

The fried pickles come with a dipping sauce that guests rave about. Some have asked how it would taste on wings.

Pub chips can be ordered as nachos with added meat, a swap one regular said they did not regret. The Connemara chicken, a tenderloin sandwich, and a Molly Malloy panini round out the list of favorites.

Fish and chips earns praise as well, and some guests say it ranks among their best. With so many options, a second trip is almost part of the plan.

Live Music and a Castle-Like Dining Room

Live Music and a Castle-Like Dining Room
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Music is a regular part of the evening here, with 43 mentions of Irish music and 20 of live music. Guests say live sets start around 8 pm, and some mention Wednesday nights and weekends.

One guest compared the interior to a medieval castle, with plenty of space and seating. The Irish tunes play at a level that still allows conversation.

Different sections suit different moods. One area may host a performer while another shows sports games.

Pub decorations and an electric fireplace add to the cozy look. Schedules can change, so check with the pub before planning around a specific act.

Who Feels at Home Here

Who Feels at Home Here
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Students, parents, alumni, and business travelers all show up in the stories. One regular brings out-of-state coworkers every visit, and says they leave talking about the staff as much as the meal.

Families bring kids, and the pub is described as welcoming for any age. Move-in weekends bring parents looking for a relaxed meal after a long drive.

Some guests have made the trip from South Bend, about two hours away, and called it worth it. Others stop in while passing through.

The patio gets praise from those who prefer to eat outside. Dining out here tends to feel unhurried and friendly.

Breakfast, Late Nights, and Game Day Crowds

Breakfast, Late Nights, and Game Day Crowds
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Hours stretch across the day. The doors open at 11 am daily, and Friday and Saturday service runs until 1 am.

Breakfast gets a nod from one Boilermaker fan, who called it worth a visit on its own. Menu times can change, so confirm before you go.

Purdue game days bring crowds. Football and basketball weekends can make it hard to get a table, though regulars say the wait is worth it.

Seating includes many backless stools, so guests who want a different spot can ask for outdoor seating or another table.

Is the Drive Worth It

Is the Drive Worth It
© Nine Irish Brothers West Lafayette, West Lafayette, IN

Short answer: the record says yes. With a 4.7-star average from thousands of guests, this pub has earned its spot on many day-trip lists.

Not every experience is perfect. One guest found the shepherd’s pie bland and said the corned beef can vary by day, and the pub invited that feedback.

Still, the overall pattern is steady praise for friendly staff, a cozy room, and food that feels like comfort. Visit at 119 Howard Ave in West Lafayette, and check the website for current hours and music nights.

Go hungry, bring friends, and save room for a second visit.

Publish Date: November 16, 2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Brand_Element_1.png

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER &
RECEIVE A FAMILY VACATION PLANNING KIT!

We3Travel.com will use the information you provide on this form to send you newsletters. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting [email protected]. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

fam-book
Scroll to Top