Here Are 4 Small-Town Indiana Pie Counters Where Sugar Cream Slices Come Out Of The Oven Before Lunch

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Sugar cream pie is Indiana’s official state pie, and the best places to get a slice are often small shops that open early. Four pie counters in Winchester, Huntington, and Zionsville start their days well before the lunch crowd shows up.

Some are old-fashioned diners with counter seats and breaded tenderloins. Others are bakeries focused on pie from the moment the doors open.

Each one gives you a different way to enjoy the Hoosier classic, so here is where to point the car on your next weekend day trip.

1. Mrs. Wick’s Restaurant & Pie Shop

Mrs. Wick's Restaurant & Pie Shop
© Mrs. Wick’s Restaurant & Pie Shop

Opening at 6 AM Tuesday through Friday, this Winchester spot is ready for early risers who want pie before most places have unlocked the door. On Saturdays it keeps the same early start and closes at 2 PM.

The shop is known for sugar cream pie, Indiana’s state pie, and the menu also lists chocolate peanut butter, butterscotch, and strawberry rhubarb. It is a classic diner setup with counter service, so you can pair a slice with coffee at the counter or settle into a table.

The savory side is just as hometown. Breaded tenderloin, grilled cheese, biscuits and gravy, and chicken pot pie all show up on the menu, which makes it easy to turn a pie stop into breakfast or lunch.

Most meals fall in the $10 to 20 range per person.

Parking is free in the lot and on the street, and there is usually plenty of room. Kids are welcome, with high chairs and a kids’ menu.

The shop is closed Sunday and Monday, and hours may vary, so check before you go.

2. Nick’s Kitchen

Nick's Kitchen
© Nick’s Kitchen

Huntington’s historic downtown has brick streets, and Nick’s Kitchen sits just north of it on Jefferson Street. The diner opens at 7 AM every day of the week, so Sunday pie is on the table too.

Breaded pork tenderloin sandwiches are the signature order, served with onion rings. Homemade pies share the spotlight, and the sugar cream is the one to ask about.

The menu goes well beyond tenderloins. You will find a Kitchen Sink Omelet, a Tenderloin Biscuit, chicken pot pie, taco salad, and a kids’ mac and cheese.

Counter service is available, and the kitchen closes at 2 PM.

Saturday mornings tend to be the busiest, while weekdays run quieter. Parking is free, but spaces can be tricky to find at peak times.

Hours may vary, so check before heading out.

3. My Sugar Pie

My Sugar Pie
© My Sugar Pie

Zionsville is a walkable village center with brick-paved Main Street, and My Sugar Pie sits a short step away on East Pine Street. Doors open at 8 AM Tuesday through Saturday, which gives you a full morning of pie shopping.

The shop focuses on homemade fruit pies and its Hoosier sugar cream pie, available whole or by the slice. Dutch apple and strawberry rhubarb lattice are on the lineup, along with butterscotch cream, pumpkin praline, and a pie called My Kentucky Pie.

You can eat in, grab something to go, or arrange curbside pickup. Coffee is available, free Wi-Fi is on hand, and parking is free in the lot and on the street.

It is a quick stop rather than a long sit-down meal. The shop is closed Sunday and Monday, and hours may vary, so a quick check helps.

4. Wick’s Pies

Wick's Pies
© Wick’s Pies

Winchester, with fewer than 5,000 residents, is considered the historic heart of Indiana sugar cream pie baking. Wick’s Pies on Southeast Greenville Avenue is the flagship bakery and counter behind its signature pies.

The counter sells fresh pies made daily, and the shop also mentions a pork tenderloin sandwich. Doors open at 8 AM Monday through Friday, so you can pick up pie early in the day.

Unlike the diner stop across town, this one is about the bakery itself. It is a good place to buy a whole pie to take home.

The shop is closed Saturday and Sunday. Hours may vary, so check before you make the drive.

Publish Date: November 21, 2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Brand_Element_1.png

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER &
RECEIVE A FAMILY VACATION PLANNING KIT!

We3Travel.com will use the information you provide on this form to send you newsletters. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting [email protected]. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

fam-book
Scroll to Top