Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Most of New Baden is still asleep when the lights come on at one small bakery on the edge of downtown. By 4:30 in the morning, trays of donuts are already lined up and ready for the first customers of the day.
There is no card reader at the counter, so the regulars show up with cash in hand and a plan for their dozen. This little Illinois town is just a short hop off I-64, and plenty of families make the detour on purpose.
The prices are low enough to raise eyebrows, and the shop has the old-school feel that many grandparents remember from their own childhood bakeries. Keep reading to learn where it is, what to order, how the cash rule works, and a recent name change every fan should know about before heading over.
A Hometown Bakery on Hanover Street

Some of the best things in Illinois hide in towns that most drivers zip past on the interstate. Berkemann’s Baker’s Dozen sits at 115 W Hanover St, New Baden, IL 62265, in the southwestern part of the state.
It is a classic bakery in every sense of the word. The shop is small, family-style, and built around donuts, breads, cookies, and pastries made for the neighborhood.
New Baden lies just a short distance from I-64. That makes the bakery an easy detour for families heading to or from the St. Louis area.
Plenty of people treat it as a planned stop rather than a happy accident. Folks drive in from O’Fallon and Belleville, and travelers on their way home from St. Louis pull off the highway to grab a box.
The building is not flashy, and it does not try to be. It is the kind of place locals lovingly call a hole in the wall.
With a 4.9-star average from more than 460 Google ratings, this tiny shop clearly punches above its weight. The next question is how a town this size ended up with a bakery people cross county lines for.
The Old-Fashioned Bakery Most Towns Lost

Decades ago, nearly every small Illinois town had its own bakery on the main drag. Many of those shops have faded away, which is exactly why this one stands out.
Berkemann’s carries that old hometown bakery spirit. Longtime fans describe it as a throwback to the local bakeries they knew years ago.
That nostalgia is a big part of the appeal. Grown-ups say the donuts remind them of the donut shop from their own childhood.
It is also the kind of stop that families pass down. Parents and grandparents bring the kids here so a new generation can pick out treats from the same cases.
Nothing about the setup feels trendy. There are display cases, a friendly person behind the counter, and a long list of baked goods that rotates with the seasons.
Regulars mention they have been coming for years, and some have relied on the shop for every family celebration. Loyalty like that does not happen overnight.
For grandparents looking to share a piece of their own past, few outings are this simple. A short drive, a paper box, and a few dollars are about all it takes to start a new tradition.
Donuts Ready Before Sunrise

Early birds get first pick here. The doors open at 4:30 a.m., Tuesday through Saturday, so the donut cases are stocked long before most people reach for an alarm clock.
Donuts are the star of the show. They come up far more than anything else when people talk about this bakery.
The lineup covers plenty of ground. Original glazed donuts, original twists, sugar and cinnamon twists, cinnamon sugar donuts, and cake donuts like blueberry have all made appearances in the cases.
Fans describe the donuts as fluffy and light. Many like that they are not overly sweet, which makes it easier to justify a second one.
Fresh is the key word. Some people say these were their office’s favorite donuts, which says a lot about how far a box from New Baden can travel.
Selection can vary by day, so a favorite flavor may not always be waiting. One customer arrived to find no glazed in the case, a good reason to show up earlier rather than later.
The baker’s dozen in the name is not just a cute pun either. Fans point to it as one of the best deals in town.
Cream Horns, Cream Puffs and Other Counter Favorites

Donuts may get top billing, but the rest of the case has its own loyal following. Cream horns and cream puffs come up again and again among regulars.
The cream horns earn especially strong praise. More than one person has called them the best they have ever had.
Cream puffs sometimes come out fresh on a tray right while customers are at the counter. Timing like that can turn a quick stop into a lucky one.
Turnovers are another popular pick, with cherry and apple both showing up. The apple version is described as flaky and not too sweet.
Elephant ears with pecans, lemon bars, oatmeal cookies, and cinnamon roll cake round out the possibilities. Sugar cookies get plenty of love as well.
Not every item wins every heart. A few customers have been less impressed with things like the gooey butter cake or the crust on the lemon bars, while the cherry pie still came out ahead.
The best strategy for a family is simple. Let each person pick one treat, then share bites at the table at home.
Bread, Bagels and That Famous Pizza Dough

Here is a twist many first-timers do not see coming. A good share of fans leave with pizza dough tucked under their arm.
The pizza dough has its own fan club. It ranks among the items people mention most, right behind the donuts and the cash rule.
That makes it a fun option for a family pizza night. Kids can help roll out the dough and pile on their own toppings at home.
The bread draws praise too. Regulars say it works great for sandwiches, which makes it a practical pick for school lunches during the week.
Bagels are on the list for some shoppers. Families from O’Fallon have made the drive specifically for bread and bagels.
The shop also keeps some frozen items that are already prepared. That can be handy for anyone stocking up for a busy week.
A bakery that feeds both breakfast and dinner plans is a rare find. Shoppers come for a sweet treat and leave with half the week’s meals sorted.
Cash Only, With a Backup Plan

Leave the credit card in the wallet, because it will not help at this counter. The bakery is cash only, and that rule is one of the most talked-about things about it.
Checks are also accepted, according to some customers. Cards, however, are not.
Forgetting cash is not a disaster. There is an ATM inside the shop, so nobody has to leave empty-handed.
Still, bringing cash ahead of time is the smoother plan. ATM fees can eat into the savings that make this place worth the trip.
Some fans believe the cash-only setup helps keep prices low. Whatever the reason, the system has stuck around and regulars have learned to work with it.
For families, cash can be a nice teaching moment too. Handing a child a few dollars and letting them choose their own treat makes the visit feel like a small adventure.
A quick stop at the bank before the drive is the only homework required. After that, the hardest decision is what goes in the box.
Prices That Feel Like a Throwback

Sticker shock goes the other direction here. Plenty of shoppers describe the prices as confusingly cheap.
Many say it is the best price they have paid for donuts anywhere. Words like reasonable and awesome come up again and again.
One recent figure puts a half dozen assorted donuts at about $8. Prices can change, so it is smart to expect some variation.
Not everyone agrees on value. At least one customer felt the donuts were on the small side for the cost.
Even so, the overall picture is of a bakery where a small budget can go a long way. A family treat run here may cost less than a single round of fancy coffee drinks at a chain shop.
That baker’s dozen deal helps stretch things further. An extra donut in the box is a classic bonus that never gets old.
Veterans may want to note the calendar. On Veterans Day, the bakery has offered a military deal with a free donut or two, a kind gesture that fits the hometown feel.
Cakes and Pies for the Big Days

Behind the daily donuts is a busy celebration business. Families turn to this shop for birthdays, events, and even weddings.
Custom cakes earn high marks for design and flavor. A beach-themed birthday cake and event cakes with last-minute design changes have both turned out well.
Short notice is not always a deal-breaker. One customer was turned away by five bakeries for a cake needed in under three days, and this shop said yes right away.
Delivery is part of the package for some orders. The team has coordinated with building managers to get cakes where they need to go on time.
Wedding cakes are on the menu, but so are creative alternatives. One couple skipped cake entirely and served individual pies in many flavors, restocking the table all night.
Some regulars use the bakery for every event cake and sweet tooth craving. That kind of trust is built one party at a time.
Anyone planning a birthday or reunion should call ahead to talk through options. Local bakeries often have more flexibility than big chains.
Seasonal Treats Worth Timing a Trip Around

Summer brings a limited-time favorite with a name that sounds like a family secret. Paul’s Delight shows up only from Memorial Day to Labor Day.
It is a hand-held chocolate cake topped with a star-piped dollop of marshmallow cream, then covered in chocolate. Fans count down to its return each year.
Cookies also follow the calendar. Decorations change with each season, and sometimes just for fun.
Pumpkin cookies have won praise for being soft and sweet. Bat-shaped cookies have appeared around Halloween as well.
Seasonal flavors are not guaranteed, though. One fall shopper looked for pumpkin options in November and did not find what they hoped for.
The rotating lineup gives families a reason to return. A summer road trip can include a Paul’s Delight stop, while a fall drive might focus on cookies.
Calling ahead is a good idea for anyone chasing one specific item. Small bakeries make what they can each day, and the cases change.
Friendly Faces and a Tiny Table

Ask almost anyone about this bakery, and the staff comes up fast. The people behind the counter are often described as outgoing and as friendly as could be.
They are also known to help customers choose. That is handy for first-timers staring at a full case with no idea where to start.
The space is small, so plan accordingly. There is just one little table by the door, which makes this more of a grab-and-go stop.
Busy days can slow things down. Weekends can be packed, and a few customers have waited a bit longer than expected.
Parking is limited too. A small lot right next door usually has enough room.
A smart move is to pair the bakery with lunch nearby. Many families make a habit of eating at Good Ol’ Days restaurant and then walking over for dessert.
Kids will love picking out treats, and grandparents will appreciate the easy pace. Just bring patience on a Saturday, along with that cash.
Hours, a New Name, and a Sweet Verdict

Before heading out, there is one important update. The bakery is now operating as The Worn Whisk, under new owners.
The good news is that the recipes are said to be the same ones Berkemann’s used. Its Facebook page now goes by The Worn Whisk Bakery, which is the best place to check for updates.
Hours listed for the shop run from 4:30 a.m. to 7 p.m., Tuesday through Saturday. It is closed on Sunday and Monday, so plan weekend trips for Saturday.
Hours can shift with new ownership, so a quick check before driving is wise. Bring cash, arrive early for the best selection, and leave room in the car for a box or two.
So is it worth the trip? For families who love a classic hometown bakery, low prices, and a little nostalgia, the answer is likely yes.
Not every pastry wins over every customer, and the space is small. Still, the mix of fresh donuts, friendly service, and baker’s dozen value makes it an easy Illinois day trip to recommend.
Tag the donut lover in the family and start planning. The glaze will be ready before sunrise.

