Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Saturday is the best day to hunt for secondhand treasure, and Indiana has some thrift stores big enough to fill the whole day. These eight spots stretch from Evansville to Crown Point, with warehouse-style bins, furniture floors, and rooms sorted by shoes, shirts, and housewares.
Some are run by nonprofits, and some put their proceeds toward schools, ministries, or community programs. Each one is open on Saturdays, though hours differ from store to store.
Read on to find out which one fits your style of bargain hunting, from careful rack browsing to sleeves-up bin digging. Hours can change, so check before you head out.
1. World Wide Missions Consignment Store, Evansville, IN

Saturday morning is the busiest stretch here, and that makes sense once you see the size of the place. World Wide Missions Consignment Store at 301 N Congress Ave in Evansville is a massive thrift and consignment shop with clothing, furniture, and home goods spread across a big floor.
The mix goes well beyond racks of shirts. Shoes, household items, gadgets, and both used and new goods all share the space, and brand names and vintage finds turn up at prices well under retail.
Pricing is a big part of the appeal. The store has a reputation for keeping tags reasonable instead of chasing the higher prices some consignment shops have moved toward.
Doors open at 9 AM Monday through Saturday and close at 4:50 PM, and the store is closed on Sunday. A free parking lot makes loading furniture easier, so bring a tape measure if a big piece catches your eye.
2. Millie’s Thrift Store, Lafayette, IN

A shopping list for Millie’s could include quilting fabric, a wicker chair, and a set of dishes, and you might find all three on one trip. The store at 101 Plaza Ln in Lafayette is spacious and stocked with furniture, clothing, and housewares.
Linens, children’s and adult clothing, shoes, toys, tools, and appliances share the floor. Vintage pieces such as doilies and glassware show up, and sewing machines and antiques appear from time to time.
Prices stay on the reasonable side, and the best items get put out on the floor where shoppers can see them. That keeps the selection feeling fresh from one visit to the next.
Saturday hours run 9 AM to 5 PM, and the store is closed on Sundays. Weekday hours are 10 AM to 6:30 PM.
3. Second Life Resale Shoppe, Crown Point, IN

Every purchase at Second Life Resale Shoppe goes toward tuition at Crown Point Christian School. The proceeds from this resale store at 1800 N Main St have helped thousands of local students over the last decade.
The shop describes itself as big and beautiful, and the floor backs that up. Seasonal decor, clothing, furniture, and household items fill the departments, often at deep discounts.
Prices are friendlier than at some larger secondhand chains, and the shop has built a clean, community-favorite reputation. The staff are known for being helpful.
Plan around the schedule, since the shop is closed Monday and Sunday. Saturday hours are 9 AM to 3 PM, and Thursday stays open until 7 PM for a later shift.
4. Backyard Bargains, Anderson, IN

Getting lost is part of the fun at Backyard Bargains. The community-focused thrift store at 912 E 53rd St in Anderson has aisles of furniture, appliances, shoes, and clothing, with plenty of items in between.
The store is linked to Man for Man Ministries, and it stocks diverse household goods at affordable prices. Shoppers describe the inventory as large enough to keep you browsing, with fun treasures mixed in.
Services go beyond walking the aisles. The store lists curbside pickup, in-store pickup, and delivery, and there is on-site parking.
Hours are 10 AM to 5 PM Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday through Saturday. The store is closed on Wednesday and Sunday, so Saturday is a good fit for a full browse.
5. Wabash Valley Goodwill Industries, Inc., Terre Haute, IN

If you like a Saturday that stretches into the evening, this Terre Haute stop gives you the longest window on the list. Wabash Valley Goodwill at 2702 S 3rd St is open 9 AM to 8 PM Monday through Saturday, and noon to 6 PM on Sunday.
The store is organized, with a large selection of clothing, furniture, and household items. A back area carries electronics, hardware, and luggage, so it pays to look beyond the front racks.
Blankets, craft supplies, and purses turn up regularly, and the donated goods tend to be good quality. As a nonprofit outlet, it takes in apparel and home goods from the community.
Leave some trunk space. Shoppers have been known to fill a car faster than expected.
6. Goodwill Outlet Store, Greenwood, IN

Bring patience and maybe gloves, because this one is sold by the pound. The Goodwill Outlet Store at 927 N Emerson Ave in Greenwood is a warehouse-style clearance center with oversized rolling blue bins that get refreshed through the day.
Secondhand goods and apparel are priced at under $2 per pound, and certain heavy items in the bins sell at discounted prices. The bins hold a wide range of sizes, but finding the bargains means digging.
The payoff can be big. A cart full of merchandise has been known to cost less than $50.
The outlet is open 9 AM to 7 PM Monday through Saturday and noon to 7 PM on Sunday. Saturday is a good day to go, since it stays open late.
7. Mission 27 Resale, Indianapolis, IN

Rooms are the organizing idea at Mission 27 Resale. The shop at 132 Leota St in Indianapolis is run by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, and its proceeds support community programs.
One room is full of shoes, another holds sorted shirts and pants, and there are new beds in boxes. Furniture, housewares, and books fill other areas, along with clothing for kids and adults.
The layout makes a large store easy to move through. Prices are fair, so a tight budget can still bring home a real haul.
Saturday hours are 9 AM to 5 PM. The shop also opens Sunday from 10 AM to 5 PM and weekdays from 10 AM to 6 PM.
8. Audrey’s Place Thrift Store, Indianapolis, IN

Antiques and architectural salvage sit next to everyday thrift bargains at Audrey’s Place. The big store at 3228 E 10th St in Indianapolis stretches across multiple rooms, with items from the kitchen to the barn.
Vintage pieces, eclectic collections, and some higher-end antiques are mixed in with affordable household goods. It is a furniture shop first, so large pieces are the specialty.
Services make bigger purchases easier. The store offers delivery, same-day delivery, in-store pickup, and assembly, and it buys used goods too.
Parking is free in the lot and on the street.
Saturday hours are 9 AM to 5 PM, and the afternoon is the busiest time. The store is closed Sunday.

