Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Some of the best food in Arizona hides behind the smallest doors. Tucked into a downtown alley in Flagstaff sits a tiny walk-up counter serving authentic British fish and chips that people drive across the state to reach.
Folks from Phoenix, Rimrock, and Texas make the trip and leave already planning their return. The batter is light, the chips are cut in house, and the sticky toffee pudding has a fan club of its own.
There is barely room for two people inside, so most guests eat in the alley or head back to their vehicles happily. What makes this humble spot worth a full tank of gas and a mountain drive?
Keep reading, because this little counter has earned every one of its stars.
A Little Counter on San Francisco Street
Downtown Flagstaff holds plenty of surprises, and one of the most beloved sits at 113 S San Francisco St, Flagstaff, AZ 86001. Evans Fish and Chips runs out of a compact walk-up spot near Heritage Square, right in the heart of the city.
It is not flashy and it does not try to be. The whole operation focuses on one thing, and that is turning out proper British fish and chips made to order.
Regulars describe it as a classic that is perfect for what it is and where it is. That kind of praise is rare, and it says a lot about a place that keeps things simple.
You will find it a short stroll from the shops and streets of downtown, which makes it an easy stop after wandering around. The location earns loyalty from locals who first heard about it by word of mouth.
British Roots in the High Country
Finding true English fish and chips in a mountain town nearly 7,000 feet above sea level feels unexpected, yet that is exactly what this counter delivers. People who recently traveled through England mention the food here holds its own against coastal shops overseas.
The style leans into the authentic take-away tradition, where fish and chips started as grab-and-go food. That heritage stays intact here, and it gives the whole experience its charm.
Malt vinegar and salt come with the order, just as they should. English mustard sauce also makes an appearance, and it earns steady applause from those who try it.
Comfort food done right travels well, even to landlocked Arizona. This spot proves the point one crispy filet at a time.
Fish So Fresh the Menu Keeps Changing
The seafood selection here shifts with what is available, so no two visits feel quite the same. Cod is the classic pick, but trout, hoki, mahi, and flounder rotate through depending on the day.
Cooking happens after you order, which keeps everything fresh and hot. The batter earns praise for being light and airy rather than heavy or greasy.
Many people note the generous ratio of fish to batter, so the seafood shines instead of getting buried. Portions run large enough that two people can easily share one big combo.
Shrimp also draws a loyal following, and even folks who are not big on fish rave about the crispy result. With options changing often, there is always a reason to come back and try something new.
Chips Cut in House and Fried Right
No proper fish and chips shop skimps on the chips, and this one takes them seriously. The fries are cut in house and made fresh, which regulars quickly notice.
Thick and hearty, they turn out fluffy on the inside with a crisp edge. Many say the chips alone are worth the stop, calling them magnificent more than once.
A little seasoning gives them just enough character without overpowering the plate. Paired with the house sauces, they hold their own as a highlight rather than a side note.
Getting the potato right is harder than it looks, and this counter nails it batch after batch. That consistency keeps people loyal for the long haul.
The Sauce Lineup Locals Rave About
Homemade sauces set this place apart, and the tartar sauce gets nearly as much love as the fish itself. It is made in house, and some fans joke they would happily drink it.
For those who like heat, the White Dragon jalapeno tartar sauce adds a spicy kick that lifts the whole meal. A dragon cocktail sauce brings a similar fiery edge for the adventurous.
Curry sauce and gravy round out the options, giving each visit room to mix things up. The English mustard sauce also earns steady shout-outs from those in the know.
Sauce might seem like a small detail, but here it becomes a reason to return. Trying a new one each visit is half the fun.
Pies, Rolls, and British Classics
Beyond the fryer, the menu carries a full spread of British comfort classics. Steak and ale pie draws steady praise, and the pies in general earn the word amazing more than once.
The sausage roll wraps meaty filling in light, flaky pastry that seems to melt rather than chew. Portions run large, so it doubles as a meal on its own.
Scotch eggs here rank near the top for people who have tried plenty elsewhere. Loads of sausage meat, a soft runny center, and a crisp coating make each one memorable.
A cheesy onion roll shows up too, adding one more savory option to the lineup. These extras make it easy to build a spread worth lingering over.
The Sticky Toffee Pudding Everyone Talks About
Save room, because the dessert here has become the stuff of legend. Sticky toffee pudding shows up in conversation after conversation, and for good reason.
Warm, rich, and full of flavor, it makes a perfect finish after a plate of fish and chips. Some people order extra to take home, unable to resist the pull.
Calling it a show stopper is common, and a few admit to coming back just for this one dish. It ranks among the most mentioned items on the whole menu.
Cravings for it tend to linger long after the visit ends. If you try only one dessert in Flagstaff, this is a strong contender.
Tiny Space, Big Charm
Space is famously tight here, with barely room for two people to stand inside. That snug footprint is part of the appeal, keeping the focus squarely on the food.
Limited outdoor seating sits in the alleyway, where a few tables let you eat close to where it was made. Some folks embrace the alley meal, while others carry their order back to a hotel or vehicle.
Because there is no dine-in setup, this feels like a real take-away shop in the traditional sense. Fans say that grab-and-go spirit keeps the whole experience charming.
The food travels well too, staying crisp even after a short drive. Newcomers should plan for the seating situation so it does not catch them off guard.
Fast, Friendly, and Made to Order
Warm service comes up again and again as one of the best parts of the stop. The crew earns words like professional, chill, and downright cool from those who come through.
Even when a line forms, it tends to move quickly, and the food still comes out fast. Everything is cooked to order, so freshness never gets sacrificed for speed.
People traveling from out of state single out how kind and patient the team is at the register. That friendliness turns first-timers into repeat guests.
An information board inside adds a fun touch for those waiting on their order. Good food and good people make a hard combination to beat.
Hours, Prices, and Planning Your Trip
Getting here rewards a little planning, and the good news is the hours run long. The counter opens at 11 AM daily, closing at midnight most nights and stretching all the way to 3 AM on Friday and Saturday.
Prices land in the friendly range of about 10 to 20 dollars, with large plates around 17 dollars. Many say the quality and portion sizes make that a genuine value.
Sodas and drinks are also priced reasonably, which adds to the appeal. Late-night visits work well here, since the kitchen keeps cooking well past dinner.
Holding a 4.7 star average across hundreds of ratings, this counter has earned deep local trust. Folks driving up from Phoenix or Rimrock plan the trip around it, and downtown parking puts you steps from the door.
