Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Every fall, a certain kind of South Florida diner starts counting down the days until stone crab season opens. When it does, many of them skip the fancy waterfront spots and head inland to a modest fish house on a busy stretch of road near Oakland Park.
There are no white tablecloths here, just baskets of hush puppies, cracked claws, and servers who often remember your order. Keep reading to learn why this old-school spot draws crab fans from down the street and from as far away as New York, plus the best times to go, what it costs, and a few tips that can make your visit easier.
A Fish House on North Andrews Avenue
Some of the best seafood in Broward County is served far from the beach. Catfish Deweys sits at 4003 N Andrews Ave, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309, right along the Oakland Park area line in South Florida.
The spot is a seafood restaurant with a down-home, homey style. Its menu covers seafood, ribs, and steak, plus daily all-you-can-eat specials that keep regulars coming back.
The location is easy to reach from much of Fort Lauderdale. It sits inland on a main road, so there is no beach traffic to fight on the way in.
That inland address is part of the charm. Plenty of locals treat it as their neighborhood fish house rather than a tourist stop.
Out-of-towners find it too. Business travelers looking to skip the chain restaurants have landed here and called it the real deal.
With more than 6,000 people weighing in online and an overall score of 4.4 stars, the place clearly has a following. The next question is what all those people keep ordering.
Three Generations Behind the Counter
Family restaurants come and go, but this one has stayed in the family long enough to reach a third generation. Chris now carries on the tradition, and the name Dewey still shows up when the restaurant responds to guests online.
That kind of continuity matters to longtime fans. One couple has been flying in from New York for nearly 20 years, and on a single trip they came back four days in a row.
The food is described as home cooked and plentiful. Portions run generous enough that many diners leave with takeout boxes full of catfish and hush puppies for later.
The owners also pay attention to their staff. When guests praise a server by name, the reply often promises to pass the compliment along.
It is a small detail, but it says something about the culture inside. People here are treated a bit like extended family, and many guests return the favor by asking for the same server every time.
That loyalty becomes especially clear once the calendar flips to crab season.
Stone Crab Season, the Main Event
Stone crabs are the reason some families plan their Saturdays around this restaurant. Stone crabs come up more than 200 times in online comments, and many diners call them the best in town.
The claws are served cold and arrive already cracked by machine, so there is no wrestling with shells at the table. They come with a creamy house mustard sauce that does not overpower the crab.
Servers are happy to help newcomers. First-timers have been given a friendly crash course on how the claws are sourced fresh daily and why they are served cold.
One popular order is the Large Claws, two pounds with eight claws and fries. Many diners say the crab holds up just fine without any sauce at all.
Price is another reason fans pick this spot. Regulars point out that the claws are fresh and still affordable, which is not always the case with this South Florida favorite.
For folks who have lived in Florida for years without trying stone crabs, this low-key room makes a gentle place to start.
Hush Puppies Instead of a Bread Basket
Forget the usual dinner rolls. At this table, the meal starts with complimentary hush puppies and coleslaw.
Those hush puppies might be the most talked-about item in the whole building. They get mentioned nearly 300 times online, even more than the stone crabs.
Some servers bring them out as soon as regulars sit down. A few even know the order by heart before the menu is opened.
The Southern touches keep going from there. Grits and collard greens show up often as favorite sides, and cheese grits pair well with the grilled catfish po boy.
Other starters earn attention too. Conch fritters, fried mushrooms, and shrimp cocktail all have their fans.
Frog legs are on the menu for the curious eater, and many say the sauce that comes with them is tasty.
It is the kind of menu where a side dish can steal the show. Plenty of diners admit they came for crab and left talking about the hush puppies.
Bottomless Plates and Daily Deals
Hungry crowds have a reason to love the daily specials. The restaurant runs all-you-can-eat deals that rotate through the week.
All-you-can-eat crab legs are a major draw, and snow crabs come up well over 100 times in online chatter. Many diners say the staff keeps the crab coming quickly without anyone needing to ask.
The catfish special has its own loyal fans. Some groups split up, with one person on crab legs and another working through plate after plate of catfish.
Shrimp gets its turn too. An all-you-can-eat shrimp special has been offered with one side included.
Value is the word that keeps popping up. Diners regularly mention big portions and very reasonable prices for the amount of food.
Not every plate wins everyone over, though. A few guests have found crab legs undercooked or hard to crack, so speak up if something seems off.
Still, most people leave full and happy, which is the whole point of a bottomless deal.
Old-School Charm and the Servers Everyone Knows
Nobody comes here for trendy decor. The atmosphere is classic old school, and many guests call it a real South Florida experience.
The staff gets a lot of the credit. Servers are often named and praised for being attentive, quick, and one step ahead.
Large groups seem to be handled well. Big parties have been served smoothly, with everyone getting what they need.
Even the parking lot has a friendly helper who finds spots for regular guests. Small touches like that make the place feel personal.
To be fair, the interior is dated, and some guests have raised concerns about cleanliness and wear in the dining room. A few have also had slow service on busy nights.
Families, couples, coworkers on business trips, and longtime snowbirds all fit in here. The crowd is mixed, casual, and focused on the food.
Think of it as a neighborhood hangout that happens to serve some of the area’s most popular claws.
Hours, Busy Times, and Smart Timing
Good news for flexible schedules: the doors open every day of the week. Service starts at 11:30 AM daily.
Closing time is 8:30 PM from Sunday through Thursday. On Friday and Saturday, the kitchen stays open later, until 9:30 PM.
Saturday is a favorite day for crab fans during stone crab season. That also means midday Saturday can get crowded, and some guests have noticed the staff stretched thin.
A weekday lunch may be a calmer option. Lunch crowds have reported prompt and friendly service.
There is also a happy hour, according to longtime fans, so ask your server about current specials when you arrive.
Hours can change, especially around holidays. Checking the official website, catfishdeweys.com, before heading over is a smart move.
Plan around the crowds, and the wait can be short and painless.
Worth the Trip When the Claws Return
Stone crab season does not last all year, and that is exactly why timing matters. When it opens, this fish house becomes a go-to stop for locals who want fresh claws without waterfront prices.
The mix is hard to beat for value-minded diners. Free hush puppies, generous portions, and all-you-can-eat specials stretch a budget further than many seafood spots in South Florida.
It is not perfect. The building shows its age, and busy nights can test the staff.
Even so, thousands of happy guests keep returning, some for decades. Many say they wish they had found it sooner.
For anyone new to stone crabs, it offers an easy and friendly first taste. For longtime fans, it is a familiar seat at a familiar table.
Grab a few friends, bring an appetite, and save room for an extra round of hush puppies on the way out.
