Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Racks of dresses, a wall of shoes, and a trade-in counter that pays out the same day. A secondhand shop on the northeast side of Indianapolis packs all of that under one roof, and shoppers keep coming back to see what changed since last week.
The stock rotates often, so no two trips look alike. Here is a closer look at where the finds come from, how selling works, and when to go so the afternoon does not run out before the aisles do.
Finding the Shop in Castleton
Uptown Cheapskate NE Indianapolis sits at 5151 E 82nd St Ste 500 600, Indianapolis, IN 46250, in the Castleton area on the city’s northeast side. It is a resale clothing store that buys and sells brand-name, pre-owned fashion.
The shop is listed as a thrift store, and its focus is apparel and accessories aimed at young adults. That includes everyday pieces as well as higher-end labels.
Indiana day-trippers who think of thrifting as a dusty church basement may be surprised here. The setup is closer to a boutique, with items sorted and displayed so shoppers can find a size or style without digging.
Shoppers in the neighborhood have noted how handy it is to have a sustainable clothing option close to home. That local convenience is a big part of why the store has built a loyal following in a fairly short time.
Parking and the entrance are part of a shopping center, so the stop fits easily into an errand run along 82nd Street.
A Resale Chain With a Fresh Local Branch
The brand behind the store is known for buying and selling secondhand designer apparel and accessories. The northeast Indianapolis location carries that model into a neighborhood where many shoppers want quality clothes without full retail tags.
One regular described it as a newer store that is already doing things right. Others have said it beats the competition they had tried before, citing the way items are organized and priced.
The idea is simple. Shoppers bring in clothes they no longer wear, the store picks what fits its needs, and those pieces go back on the racks for the next person.
That loop keeps the inventory moving, which explains why the selection feels different from one visit to the next. A shop built on trade-ins never stands still for long.
For Hoosiers who like knowing where their money goes, the model has an easy appeal. Clothes get a second life, and the price tags stay friendlier than what a mall would ask.
Racks That Keep You Browsing
Clothing selection is one of the most talked-about strengths here. Shoppers mention dresses, tops, and a wide range of brands, and many say they leave with exactly what they came for.
One shopper found two black and gold jackets for a graduation, and could not choose between them. Another grabbed a red dress, wedges, and a pair of earrings in a single trip.
Prom season gets a nod too. A parent found a prom dress for under twenty dollars, which is the kind of story that gets passed around the group chat.
The store carries a larger run of women’s pieces than men’s. Men’s choices are smaller, though still present, so it helps to set expectations before heading in.
With enough racks to fill an afternoon, the best approach is to start with one category and let curiosity pull you along. Closing time tends to arrive sooner than planned.
Shoes, Purses, and Other Extras
Footwear draws plenty of attention. Shoe selection is among the most frequently mentioned topics, and one shopper walked out with comfortable pairs for fourteen dollars.
Purses also come up often, along with accessories such as earrings. Together they give the store a finishing-touch corner that rounds out an outfit.
Condition seems to be a point of pride. Shoppers say shoes, clothing, and accessories arrive in great shape, though one critic felt some items on the racks looked worn, so a quick inspection never hurts.
Brands are the single most mentioned topic in feedback about the shop. Shoppers say the mix runs from affordable names to higher-end labels, which leaves room for every budget.
A smart move is to check the shoe wall early. Sizes that suit you may be gone by the next visit, since the stock turns over regularly.
Bargains Worth the Drive
Prices are where this store wins over a lot of regulars. Shoppers describe them as reasonable for the quality, with no sense of price gouging.
One shopper bought three dresses from well-known labels for fifteen dollars each. Another said the clearance prices beat Goodwill by a wide margin.
Clearance sales get mentioned too. During one stretch, stamped items were just one dollar, which turned a casual visit into a bargain hunt.
Not everyone agrees on every price, and one shopper felt some in-store items were marked higher than expected. Still, most feedback leans toward fair and affordable.
Since sales and tags change, the safest plan is to ask at the counter about current clearance deals. A few dollars can stretch a long way when the right rack is waiting.
Selling Your Own Closet
Trade-ins are half the story here. Several sellers say the payout felt fair, and one compared it favorably to another well-known resale chain.
Choices come in two forms. Sellers can take cash, or they can take about 25 percent more in store credit, which makes the exchange feel like a swap.
One first-time seller walked away with forty-one dollars after bringing in a large bag and a smaller one. Another dropped off clothes, ran errands, and returned to pick up the offer.
The shop is selective about what it takes. Some sellers praise that standard, while one unhappy customer felt their items were not given a close look.
For best results, bring clean, current, brand-name pieces. Call or check the website first for the latest buying guidelines.
Fitting Rooms and Friendly Faces
Details like fitting rooms can make or break a shopping trip. Here, shoppers describe them as clean, well lit, and roomy.
One shopper suggested adding a real chair, which is a small wish in an otherwise happy review of the space.
The staff earns steady praise. Regulars say employees greet shoppers at the door, stay attentive, and help find what is needed.
One shopper described a visit just before closing where nobody rushed them. No countdown announcements played, and checkout stayed friendly.
Organization also gets a mention. Items are easy to find, which keeps a large store from feeling overwhelming.
Sizes, Styles, and Who It Suits
The shop is aimed at young adults, but its racks draw a wider crowd. Teens hunting for formal wear, parents shopping for events, and bargain lovers all show up.
Plus size clothing and men’s selection each show up in feedback, though both in smaller numbers. One shopper hoped for more in the larger sizes, noting those are often the hardest to find anywhere.
Style hunters will find room to play. One regular looks for unique hoodies, while others chase dresses or event outfits.
The store works well for people who like the thrill of discovery. Shoppers call each visit a treasure hunt because the lineup shifts so often.
For anyone needing an outfit with a deadline, it pays to start early. The right piece may or may not be there tomorrow.
Hours and Planning Your Trip
The store is open Monday through Saturday from 10 AM to 8 PM. Sunday hours run from 12 PM to 5 PM.
Those long weekday hours leave room for an after-work stop. A Saturday trip gives you a full day, though Sundays are shorter, so plan accordingly.
Hours may vary around holidays, so check before you go. The website at uptowncheapskate.com lists details for the northeast Indianapolis location.
The store holds a 4.7 star rating across 249 reviews, which suggests most shoppers leave satisfied. A small number of critics have had a different experience, mostly around trade-ins.
Plan on an hour or more if you are both shopping and selling. With rows this long, a quick stop rarely stays quick.
For Hoosiers who enjoy a bargain, this northeast side shop is an easy yes. Bring a bag of clothes, leave with a few new finds, and let the aisles do the rest.
