Costco is famous for its bulk deals, but some items might not be as cost-effective as they seem. Here are 17 Costco foods that are secretly overpriced, and you might want to skip them next time you’re shopping.
1. Milk (especially organic)
When it comes to buying milk in bulk, especially organic, Costco might not be your best bet. Large containers can be pricier than weekly deals at competing chains like Lidl, Aldi, or Target. It’s also a gamble whether you’ll finish it before spoilage sets in. Imagine pouring money down the drain along with the expired milk. Opting for smaller quantities elsewhere might save you both money and waste. Ultimately, milk might be one of those items better bought in moderation.
2. Fresh produce (berries, avocados, leafy greens)
Fresh produce like berries, avocados, and leafy greens can be deceivingly costly at Costco. While buying in bulk seems appealing, the per-pound price can often be high. Not to mention, the portions are usually far too large for the average household, leading to waste. Unless you’re planning a big gathering, those strawberries might just end up as compost. The bottom line? Unless you can consume in large volumes, it might be overpriced and wasteful.
3. Avocados
Avocados, the beloved superfood, often seem like a bargain in bulk but don’t be fooled. At Costco, the per-unit cost can actually be more than purchasing them individually at other grocery stores. Furthermore, the likelihood of them ripening all at once can lead to waste. Many shoppers have found it’s better to buy smaller quantities elsewhere. By doing so, you avoid the heartache of throwing away perfectly good avocados that were simply bought in excess.
4. Ready-made rotisserie chicken salad
Convenience comes at a price, especially with Costco’s ready-made rotisserie chicken salad. While it saves on prep time, the cost nearly doubles that of buying a plain rotisserie chicken and assembling a salad yourself. With basic salad ingredients and a little effort, you can have a fresher, cheaper option at home. It highlights the premium you pay for having things pre-made. So, for those willing to spend a few extra minutes in the kitchen, the savings might be substantial.
5. Toilet paper
The allure of buying toilet paper in bulk at Costco can be misleading. Despite the bulk appeal, the per-roll cost often surpasses sale prices at pharmacies or other big-box stores. Quality can also vary, leaving some shoppers disappointed with what they thought was a good deal. It’s worth comparing unit prices elsewhere to ensure you’re getting true value. Ultimately, toilet paper might be one of those items where bulk doesn’t equal savings.
6. Soda (name brands)
Name-brand sodas often come at a steep price at Costco. Though buying in bulk seems convenient, the unit price on cans often loses out to promotions and sales elsewhere. One savvy shopper even found Costco’s price higher than that of Target’s during a sale. If you’re a soda enthusiast, it’s crucial to compare prices, especially when deals are just around the corner. You might find your wallet faring better by skipping the bulk buy.
7. Name-brand cereals
You might think buying cereal in bulk at Costco is a no-brainer, but think again. While the sheer size of the boxes may seem like a good deal, the unit price often doesn’t beat what you’d find during grocery store sales. Plus, there’s a risk of staleness if it sits too long in your pantry. In essence, you might end up paying more per ounce for cereal that loses its crunch. Why not just grab smaller boxes on sale at your local store? That way, you enjoy fresh cereal without the inflated cost.
8. Bagged salad kits
Bagged salad kits from Costco might not be as cost-effective as they appear. While they offer convenience, the per-ounce cost can be higher compared to smaller bags elsewhere. Additionally, freshness declines much faster when buying in bulk, which can lead to wasted greens. For those who enjoy their greens crisp and fresh, buying smaller quantities might be the way to go. In essence, paying extra for bulk might not be the smartest choice here.
9. Raw chicken breast
Buying raw chicken breast in bulk at Costco may seem like a culinary win, but regional supermarket prices can often beat it. The cost savings might not justify the membership fee when local stores offer better deals. Plus, there’s the question of storage and potential freezer burn. For many households, smaller, fresher purchases might be more practical. It’s one of those items where the savings aren’t always clear-cut.
10. Herbs & spices (certain kinds)
Herbs and spices in large containers at Costco might lose their potency before you get through them. While buying in bulk is tempting, freshness can dissipate over time. For those who don’t season heavily, smaller, fresher packs from local stores might be more sensible. It’s a classic case of bigger not necessarily being better. Savvy cooks know where freshness counts, and this might be one area to reconsider your bulk buy strategy.
11. Canned soups & tomatoes
Canned soups and tomatoes from Costco might not be the budget-friendly choice they seem. Promotions at other supermarkets can often beat Costco’s price-per-can. Additionally, buying in bulk means committing to a large quantity, which might not always fit your needs. For those who value flexibility in their pantry, purchasing as needed might be more economical. It’s one of those items where bulk buying doesn’t always translate to savings.
12. Kirkland bacon, shrimp, mozzarella, cookie packs
The prices of Kirkland bacon, shrimp, mozzarella, and cookie packs have soared significantly since 2020. Customers have noted smaller quantities or higher prices, making these once-loved items less of a bargain. If you’re a fan of these staples, it might be worthwhile to check local grocery prices. The shrinkflation factor makes it clear that bulk isn’t always the best value. Sometimes, smaller purchases offer bigger savings.
13. Motor City pizza & bakery items
Motor City pizza and bakery items at Costco have seen either declining quality or higher prices over the years. Many shoppers have expressed disappointment, finding that other retailers now offer better value. It’s essential to weigh the cost against quality, and in this case, some might find it lacking. For pizza and bakery lovers, exploring alternatives might lead to more satisfying and budget-friendly choices.
14. Large frozen shrimp
Frozen shrimp at Costco, despite their size, have seen a price jump from $17.99 to $22.80 over a few years. The question is whether the volume justifies the cost, particularly if you don’t consume shrimp frequently. For seafood lovers who savor quality over quantity, it might be better to explore other options. This significant markup makes it less appealing to the budget-conscious shopper. Sometimes, less is truly more.
15. Mini chocolate chip cookies
Mini chocolate chip cookies at Costco have jumped in price, rising from $8.99 in 2020 to $11.69 in recent years. This price hike has left many feeling it’s no longer a bargain. For those with a sweet tooth, shopping around might yield better deals. With rising costs for the same pack size, it’s essential to consider alternatives that offer true value. Indulgence shouldn’t come at such a cost when better options exist.
16. Kirkland sliced mozzarella
Kirkland sliced mozzarella has seen a significant price increase, climbing from $6.99 to approximately $10.31. For a pantry staple, this markup might deter cheese lovers looking for a good deal. Exploring other brands might provide similar quality without the inflated price. When it comes to something as commonly used as mozzarella, getting the best value is key. It’s worth examining other options to avoid overpaying.
17. Costco food-court sandwiches & croissants
Costco’s food-court sandwiches and croissants have experienced notable price hikes, with the Hot Turkey & Provolone sandwich jumping from $3.99 to $6.99. Such increases have frustrated many loyal shoppers. While the food court was once synonymous with value, these changes suggest otherwise. For those who savor a bargain, it might be time to explore local bakeries for alternatives. The nostalgia of Costco’s food court is now tinged with higher costs.
