Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Most people in New Jersey expect cows on a dairy farm, not water buffalo. Yet in the rolling countryside of Warren County, a herd of these sturdy animals supplies the milk for mozzarella, yogurt, lassi and more.
Buffalo milk is so hard to find in the United States that some shoppers have searched big chain stores for years without luck. This small family farm has quietly filled that gap, and its products have even found fans at busy farmers markets in New York City.
Keep reading to learn where the farm is, who runs it, what it makes, and how to plan a stop that fits its weekday schedule.
A Buffalo Farm Hiding in Warren County
Few road trips end with a herd of water buffalo, but this one does. Riverine Ranch sits at 247 Cemetery Hill Rd, Washington, NJ 07882, in the United States.
The farm is tucked into rural New Jersey, far from the highways most people associate with the Garden State. It operates as a working farm rather than a tourist attraction.
That distinction matters. The ranch exists to raise animals and turn their milk and meat into food, and the on-site shop is where locals and curious travelers can buy those goods directly.
Its reputation is strong for such a small operation. The farm holds a 4.7-star standing on Google from a few dozen people, which says a lot about how it treats customers.
Many fans first discover the ranch somewhere else entirely, at a farmers market booth in Manhattan. Then they learn the farm itself welcomes shoppers on weekdays.
For a place that keeps such a low profile, it has built a surprisingly loyal following. The question is what keeps people coming back, and the answer starts with the animals themselves.
Why Water Buffalo Instead of Cows
Here is a fun fact to share at the dinner table. The classic mozzarella of southern Italy, mozzarella di bufala, is traditionally made from water buffalo milk, not cow milk.
That tradition is the spark behind farms like this one. Raising water buffalo in New Jersey is unusual, which makes the ranch stand out right away.
Buffalo milk is also a staple in other parts of the world. Families from South Asia, for example, often grew up with it at home.
Finding it in the United States is another story. Shoppers say they could not locate buffalo milk at Walmart, ShopRite, Target, Costco or BJ’s.
The ranch fills that gap directly. It sells fresh buffalo milk along with a range of products made from it.
Indian families in particular have called the farm the place to go when they miss buffalo milk. That kind of word of mouth turns a niche farm into a community resource.
So the herd is not a gimmick. It is the whole foundation of what happens here, and it shapes every product on the shelf.
Brian and Courtney, the Faces Behind the Farm
Ask around about this ranch and two names keep coming up. Brian and Courtney are known as the couple behind the operation.
Brian especially earns warm words. People describe him as knowledgeable, friendly, welcoming and a true gentleman.
He is also known for his grasp of business and animal husbandry. One longtime admirer even suggested he should mentor anyone hoping to turn farming dreams into reality.
That is high praise in a field where small farms often struggle. It suggests the ranch is run with real skill, not just enthusiasm.
Courtney has her own fans as well. Over the years, customers have described the pair simply as good people and a very nice couple.
Conversation seems to be part of the experience. Shoppers mention long, pleasant chats about the farm and its products.
For a small farm, that personal touch is a big part of the appeal. Buying food from the people who raise the animals still feels a little special, and here it clearly does.
The Mozzarella at the Heart of It All
Mozzarella is the headline act, and it carries some big expectations. Anyone who knows Italian mozzarella di bufala arrives with a clear idea of what it should be.
Plenty of shoppers leave happy. Some call the buffalo mozzarella amazing and say it sits on the same level as the farm’s other goods.
Others have had a different experience. One longtime fan of the imported version found a batch firmer and milder than expected.
That same shopper still admired the idea of a local water buffalo farm. They also allowed that it may have been an unusual batch.
The honest takeaway is simple. Locally made buffalo mozzarella is a different product from one shipped across an ocean, and personal taste plays a role.
Still, the cheese shows up again and again among the products people mention most. Mozzarella ranks among the farm’s most talked-about items.
The best approach is to try it fresh and judge for yourself. A small container is an easy way to start without overcommitting.
Yogurt That Steals the Spotlight
The mozzarella may be in the title, but the yogurt might be the true star. It is the product people bring up most often.
Fans call it outstanding. Some go further and say it is the best yogurt they have ever eaten.
Words like creamy and nutritious come up frequently. That richness is part of what makes buffalo milk dairy unique.
Some shoppers have built routines around it. One regular picks up a weekly supply at a Wednesday market in Manhattan.
That kind of habit says plenty. People do not plan their week around something ordinary.
Early fans also praised the yogurt alongside the cheese. Years later, it still earns the same level of excitement.
For first-timers, the yogurt is an easy entry point into buffalo dairy. It is familiar enough to feel safe, yet distinctive enough to show why this farm has such loyal supporters.
Grab a container early. Popular items like this are the ones regulars reach for first.
Lassi, Labneh and Paneer
Not every product here comes from the Italian playbook. Several reflect dairy traditions from South Asia and the Middle East.
Lassi is a big hit. The buffalo milk mango lassi earns real affection from market shoppers.
One regular says nothing beats it on a hot summer day. It is the kind of item people buy once and then look for every visit.
Labneh is another favorite. A loyal customer even swapped out sour cream for it at home.
Paneer also appears in the lineup. For families who cook South Asian dishes, buffalo milk paneer is hard to find elsewhere.
This range shows the farm understands its audience. It serves Italian cheese lovers and families seeking familiar dairy from home.
That mix is part of what makes the ranch interesting. A single shop covers several food cultures, all built on the same milk.
Ricotta, Taleggio and Other Cheeses
Cheese lovers will find more than one reason to linger. The lineup extends well beyond mozzarella.
Ricotta is among the items people praise. It often appears in the same breath as the labneh and yogurt.
Taleggio is another standout. Market shoppers have singled it out as a great buy at the farm’s stand.
Having a washed-rind style cheese made from buffalo milk is unusual in this region. It shows real ambition from a small producer.
Early supporters praised the cheeses in general terms too. Words like delicious come up often.
The variety lets shoppers build a small tasting board from one source. That is a fun project for anyone curious about buffalo dairy.
Offerings may change over time, so it helps to ask what is available. The owners are happy to talk through options, and that conversation often leads to a new favorite.
Fresh Milk by the Bottle
Sometimes the simplest product is the hardest to find. That is certainly true of fresh buffalo milk in the United States.
The ranch sells it plain, straight from its herd. Buffalo milk is one of the most frequently mentioned products here.
Fans describe it as pure and fresh. One devoted customer says they do not go a day without a glass.
For some households, this milk is about more than taste. It connects them to food they grew up with.
That is why the farm has earned gratitude from families who had searched store after store. A local source makes everyday cooking easier.
The milk also serves as the base for nearly everything else. Yogurt, cheese, lassi and more all start here.
Buying a bottle is a smart move for curious first-timers. It is the clearest way to understand what sets this farm apart from a typical dairy.
Pasture-Raised Meat on the Menu
Dairy gets the attention, yet the farm also sells meat. That surprises some first-time shoppers.
Ground water buffalo is a popular pick. Customers have used it for burgers and called them some of the best they have tasted.
The meat comes from a pasture-raised farm. Shoppers see that as part of its appeal.
Italian sausages also earn praise at the market stand. Steaks, including a porterhouse, have been available as well.
One helpful tip stands out. Since the meat is water buffalo, it is wise to read labels and ask questions before buying.
A past shopper did not realize a steak was buffalo until getting home. Asking upfront avoids that kind of surprise.
Even pet owners have found a use for it. One customer bought ground buffalo for their dog and found it lean and healthy.
The meat counter rounds out the farm in a practical way, and it rewards a little curiosity.
Pasta and Ice Cream Surprises
Just when the product list seems complete, it keeps going. The farm has offered pasta made with water buffalo milk.
That is not something most shoppers have ever seen. It shows how creative the ranch can be with its main ingredient.
Ice cream is part of the story too. Customers mention buffalo milk ice cream among the goods they enjoy.
The farm has also collaborated with The Bent Spoon on creatively flavored ice cream. Partnerships like that help introduce buffalo dairy to new audiences.
These items may not always be on hand. Availability can vary, so it is worth asking.
Still, they reveal the spirit of the place. The owners clearly enjoy experimenting.
For shoppers, that means a visit can hold a few unexpected finds. Keep an eye out for specialty items, since they tend to be the ones people talk about later.
From Washington to Union Square
Plenty of city dwellers know this farm without ever visiting New Jersey. Its booth has been a fixture at New York City markets.
Shoppers have found the stand at the Union Square Greenmarket. It has been listed there on Wednesdays and Saturdays.
Another regular mentions a Wednesday market at East 47th Street and 2nd Avenue. That is where they pick up their weekly yogurt.
The mango lassi has won over Union Square crowds too. So have the taleggio and Italian sausages.
Market schedules can change over time. Checking the farm’s website before heading out is the safest bet.
The markets also extend the friendly conversations the owners are known for. Many customers met Brian at the stand first.
For New Yorkers, the market is the easiest entry point. For New Jersey residents, a trip to the farm itself offers a closer look at where it all begins.
Who Will Love This Stop
Some places appeal to everyone. This one has a few groups who will especially appreciate it.
Families missing buffalo milk top the list. The farm offers a local source for milk, paneer, yogurt and lassi.
Cheese enthusiasts are another natural fit. Comparing local buffalo mozzarella with imported versions makes for an interesting experiment.
Home cooks will enjoy the range of ingredients. Ground meat, sausages and labneh all invite kitchen projects.
Aspiring farmers may find inspiration too. Brian’s knowledge of animal husbandry and business earns real respect.
Anyone who likes buying directly from producers will feel at home. The relaxed, personal setting suits shoppers who enjoy a chat.
Travelers exploring rural Warren County can add it as a unique stop. Few people can say they bought dairy from a New Jersey water buffalo farm, and that story alone is worth the detour.
Hours and Planning Tips
Timing matters here more than at most shops. The farm keeps a weekday schedule.
Hours run from 10 AM to 5 PM, Monday through Friday. The farm is closed on Saturday and Sunday.
That means weekend road trippers need a different plan. The New York market booth may be the better option on weekends.
Arriving well before closing is a smart move. It leaves time to browse, ask questions and chat with the owners.
The farm’s website, riverineranch.com, is a useful resource before visiting. Checking ahead can confirm product availability.
Bring a cooler for the drive home. Dairy and meat travel best when kept cold, especially in summer.
Read labels carefully when buying meat. Since much of it is water buffalo, a quick question avoids mix-ups.
A little planning goes a long way. With the right timing, the visit becomes an easy and rewarding outing.
A Farm Worth the Detour
Small farms rarely make headlines, yet this one keeps earning devoted fans. Its formula is refreshingly simple.
Raise water buffalo, make honest food from their milk and meat, and treat people kindly. That approach has built a loyal following over many years.
The products cover a wide range. Mozzarella, yogurt, lassi, labneh, ricotta, milk and meat all have their champions.
Not every item will match every taste. The mozzarella, in particular, has drawn mixed opinions from those raised on imported versions.
Even so, the overall picture is strongly positive. Shoppers praise the quality, the variety and especially the owners.
For families seeking buffalo milk, the farm is a rare local answer. For curious food lovers, it is a chance to try something different.
Plan a weekday trip to Washington, or catch the booth at a city market. Either way, the herd behind that creamy mozzarella has a story worth tasting firsthand.
