The Finger Lakes region is known for its world-class wineries, stunning lake views, and historic small towns — but what about seafood? While it may not be the first thing visitors crave inland, Finger Lakes locals know exactly where to go for the freshest fish fries, lobster rolls, and hidden clam shacks. These under-the-radar seafood spots serve up waterfront charm without the crowds — and some are so tucked away, you might drive right past. Here are 10 must-visit seafood shacks and joints in the Finger Lakes region that tourists often overlook — but locals swear by.
1. Mac’s Drive-In – Waterloo
Step back in time at Mac’s Drive-In, where old-school carhop service meets surprisingly good fried seafood. This retro gem in Waterloo transports you to a bygone era with its nostalgic vibe and classic car service.
Known for its fish fry platters and crisp clam strips, Mac’s serves up fresh and delicious seafood in a fun, relaxed setting. Whether you’re dining in your car or at a picnic table, the experience is delightfully unique.
Open seasonally, it’s a favorite summer spot; locals know to call ahead for hours. With a focus on quality ingredients and a touch of nostalgia, Mac’s Drive-In is a charming reminder of simpler times, where a good meal and friendly service go hand in hand.
2. Village Tavern – Hammondsport (Keuka Lake)
Nestled by Keuka Lake, the Village Tavern offers not just meals but memorable experiences. Step inside to find a cozy setting where the emphasis is on warmth and hospitality.
Their seafood-heavy menu is sourced from the Northeast coast, featuring dishes like crab cakes and seafood risotto. On warm evenings, the outdoor seating becomes a haven for those hoping to catch a stunning lake sunset while enjoying their meal.
The tavern’s charm lies in its ability to blend great food with breathtaking views. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the Village Tavern invites you to unwind, enjoy, and savor the flavors of the Finger Lakes in an atmosphere that feels like home away from home.
3. Rudy’s Lakeside Drive-In – Oswego
Just outside the Finger Lakes lies Rudy’s Lakeside Drive-In, a cherished locale for Cayuga residents and beyond. This lakeside spot delivers not only on taste but also on authentic, casual dining experiences.
Known for its Texas hot fish sandwich and perfectly fried scallops, Rudy’s offers a menu that satisfies seafood lovers. The setting, complete with picnic tables on the shore of Lake Ontario, provides classic lakeside vibes and a chance to enjoy the natural beauty around.
Despite its proximity to the Finger Lakes, Rudy’s is a destination in its own right, marking a must-visit for those in the know. A meal here is not just about the food, but the experience of dining with a lakeside view.
4. Pat’s Pizzeria & Fish Fry – Canandaigua
In Canandaigua, Pat’s Pizzeria surprises with its high-quality seafood offerings alongside traditional pizzeria fare. This takeout-style spot is a favorite for those seeking something different yet delightful.
The Friday fish fry is a standout, as are the crab-stuffed mushrooms and seafood pizza, each prepared with freshness and flair. It’s the kind of place where locals drop by for a quick meal to enjoy at nearby Kershaw Park.
The joy of dining here comes not just from the flavors, but the convenience and charm of taking your meal lakeside. Pat’s blends unexpected seafood delights with classic comfort, offering a taste of the Finger Lakes that’s both satisfying and surprising.
5. Tom Wahl’s – Avon & Geneva
While Tom Wahl’s is renowned for its burgers, its beer-battered haddock has become a Finger Lakes favorite. This classic diner, with locations in Avon and Geneva, offers a taste of Americana with a seafood twist.
The fish fry combo, complete with fries and root beer on tap, is a must-try. The lively, family-friendly atmosphere makes it a great spot for casual dining where everyone feels welcome and satisfied.
In Geneva, it’s conveniently near Seneca Lake, making it an easy detour for those craving a quick, tasty meal. Tom Wahl’s blends tradition with taste, proving that seafood can shine even in a diner setting. It’s a testament to the region’s diverse culinary scene and commitment to quality.
6. Hazlitt Red Cat Cellars Bistro – Naples
Tucked within a winery, Hazlitt Red Cat Cellars Bistro offers a unique dining experience in Naples. Here, seafood small plates are paired with local wines, creating a symphony of flavors that delight the palate.
With offerings like shrimp tacos and smoked salmon flatbread, the bistro presents a refreshing take on seafood dining. The setting is picturesque, with vineyards providing a scenic backdrop and live music adding to the ambiance.
This hidden gem invites guests to savor every bite, making it a must-visit for those exploring the Finger Lakes. Pair your meal with a glass of Red Cat wine and let the evening unfold in a celebration of great taste and local charm.
7. Doug’s Fish Fry – Skaneateles & Cortland
An institution since 1982, Doug’s Fish Fry is beloved locally for its fast, fresh fish and casual, welcoming vibe. Picture a cozy, nautical-themed setting where the aroma of crispy fish sandwiches and buttery lobster rolls fills the air. Despite its popularity, the service remains speedy, and the portions generous.
Doug’s success lies in its simplicity and commitment to quality. Located just a block from the lake in Skaneateles, it offers the perfect opportunity for a leisurely post-meal stroll by the water.
Whether it’s the classic fish sandwich or the seasonal lobster roll, each dish is crafted with care and served with a smile. Locals swear by it, and it’s no wonder Doug’s has stood the test of time.
