New York City is renowned for its diverse and delicious pizza offerings, but some gems remain hidden even from seasoned locals. These under-the-radar pizzerias are the kind locals whisper about—places that deserve way more recognition. Discover 10 hidden pizza places in New York that are somehow still undiscovered, offering unique flavors and experiences you won’t find anywhere else.
1. New York Pizza Suprema
Tucked away near Penn Station, New York Pizza Suprema offers a slice of heaven often overlooked by tourists. Known as “the only good slice near Penn Station” on Reddit, it has captured the hearts of locals seeking quality amidst the hustle and bustle. The cozy interior invites you in, offering respite from the Midtown chaos. With each bite, the perfectly crisp crust and tangy sauce reveal why it’s a favorite among those in the know. The unassuming façade hides a true pizza treasure cherished by regulars.
2. Sacco Pizza
Sacco Pizza in Manhattan is a time capsule of pizza perfection, having served loyal customers for over 50 years. This no-frills spot is beloved in discussions like r/FoodNYC for its consistent quality and minimal fanfare. The simplicity of the place allows the pizza to shine, with its chewy crust and robust tomato sauce. As you enter, the aroma of fresh pizza evokes nostalgia, reminding you of pizzerias from a bygone era. Sacco Pizza remains a steadfast favorite for those who value tradition over trends.
3. L’Industrie Pizzeria
L’Industrie Pizzeria has achieved cult status among locals, yet it remains a hidden gem for many visitors to Brooklyn. Famed for its ultra-thin, crisp slices adorned with inventive toppings, this place is a testament to pizza artistry. Each slice offers a dance of flavors, from the perfectly cooked crust to the vibrant toppings that change with the season. Despite its reputation, it maintains an air of quiet fame, attracting those who seek culinary creativity over conventional choices. L’Industrie is where pizza meets innovation.
4. Lucali
In Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, Lucali offers an intimate pizza experience that feels like a well-kept secret. The candlelit setting and cash-only policy add to its charm, appealing to those who cherish exclusivity. Reservations are a must to enjoy the handcrafted pies that have garnered a dedicated following. Each bite reveals a harmony of fresh ingredients, with the thin crust acting as the perfect canvas. Lucali’s allure lies in its understated elegance, making it a cherished spot for insiders who crave something special.
5. See No Evil Pizza
Nestled inside the 50th Street subway station, See No Evil Pizza is an unexpected delight that surprises even seasoned New Yorkers. This chef-driven pizzeria, known for its hybrid Neapolitan/New York-style creations, offers a unique twist on traditional pizza. The bustling surroundings of the subway contrast with the artisanal care put into each pie. Despite its location, the quality of ingredients and creativity in toppings make it a destination worth seeking out. See No Evil Pizza is a culinary secret waiting to be discovered.
6. Joe & Pat’s
Joe & Pat’s on Staten Island offers a classic pizza experience that remains largely overlooked outside the borough. Known for its thin-crust pizza with vodka sauce, this old-school destination brings authentic flavor to every slice. The friendly atmosphere and nostalgic decor create a welcoming environment for families and pizza aficionados alike. Despite its rich history, Joe & Pat’s is a hidden treasure that continues to delight those who venture beyond the usual tourist paths. It’s a taste of Staten Island’s vibrant pizza culture.
7. L&B Spumoni Gardens
L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn is legendary for its iconic sauce-on-top Sicilian squares, yet it often remains under the radar for first-time NYC visitors. The bustling atmosphere and lively outdoor seating offer a quintessential New York pizza experience. Each Sicilian square delivers a perfect balance of thick crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese that locals have cherished for decades. It’s a place where tradition meets flavor, making it a must-visit spot for anyone seeking authentic Sicilian-style pizza in the city.
8. Scarr’s Pizza
In the heart of Manhattan, Scarr’s Pizza stands as a foodie secret with its commitment to quality. The house-milled flour dough and nutty crust offer a distinct taste that even Manhattan locals celebrate. The modern interior and vibrant clientele create an inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a slice or two. Scarr’s dedication to using high-quality ingredients is evident in every bite, making it a standout in a city known for its pizza. It’s a hidden gem that continues to impress those in search of excellence.
9. Cuts & Slices
Cuts & Slices in Queens is an inventive pizza spot offering bold flavors with globally influenced toppings. From oxtail to curry shrimp, each slice is a culinary journey that surprises the palate. The cozy interior and artistic decor make it a welcoming space for adventurous eaters. Despite its low-key presence, Cuts & Slices has earned a loyal following for its daring approach to pizza. It’s a place where tradition meets innovation, offering a unique taste of Queens’ diverse culinary landscape.
10. Screamer’s Pizzeria
Screamer’s Pizzeria in Brooklyn is a fully vegan haven that redefines what pizza can be. Known for standout pies like Buffalo Cauliflower, it’s beloved by plant-based fans who appreciate its creativity. The colorful interior and eco-friendly vibe contribute to its unique charm, making it a destination for those seeking something different. Despite its niche appeal, Screamer’s remains a hidden treasure for anyone exploring Brooklyn’s vibrant food scene. It’s a celebration of flavors that proves vegan pizza can be just as satisfying.
