Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
When the calendar flips to fall, some cravings show up right on schedule, and a good pot pie sits near the top of the list. In Arcadia, a small family restaurant has been building its whole reputation around that one dish for decades.
Families who grew up eating these pies now bring their own kids, and some people leave with dozens of pies packed for the freezer. Keep reading to find out where it is, what comes on the plate, and why so many people think the drive is worth it.
A Pie Shop Hiding in Plain Sight
Some restaurants chase trends, and some just keep making pies. Moffett’s Family Restaurant & Chicken Pie Shoppe belongs firmly in the second group.
The address is 1409 S Baldwin Ave, Arcadia, CA 91007, in the San Gabriel Valley of Southern California. It sits on a busy stretch of Baldwin Avenue, and it does not try to look fancy.
At its heart, it is a family restaurant serving classic American fare. The signature item is right there in the name, and the pot pie has carried this place through many years of business.
Guests can sit down for a full meal or grab pies to take home. Both options are popular, and plenty of people do a little of each.
The menu goes beyond pies, with breakfast, lunch, and dinner served every day. Still, most first-timers come for one reason, and the kitchen seems perfectly happy about that.
Think of it as a neighborhood spot that happens to have a specialty people will cross the county for. The pies did the advertising long before social media ever did.
Five Decades of Crust and Comfort
Back in 1975, this restaurant started its run, and it has been serving pies ever since. That is nearly fifty years of crust in a region where restaurants come and go quickly.
Over that time, the business has changed locations and owners. Longtime fans note that recipes have shifted a bit through the years too.
A recent chapter stands out. The restaurant was taken over by its longtime main chef, someone who already knew the kitchen inside and out.
Regulars say the things they love are still in place. The new team has even added fresh breakfast items and daily specials without throwing out the classics.
The owners describe themselves as a small business blessed with a strong team. It is also women owned, which adds another layer to its local story.
History here is personal for many families. One longtime fan grew up with a dad who worked at the nearby racetrack and brought these pies home after shifts.
Now that same person brings their own children. Few menus can claim to feed three generations of the same family.
The Star of the Show
Chicken pot pie is the headliner, and it appears in more conversations about this place than anything else on the menu. It is the reason the sign says Chicken Pie Shoppe.
These are not the deep casserole versions some people expect. The pies here are formed more like hand pies, closer in shape to an empanada.
Inside, the filling leans on a thick gravy and chicken. Guests can usually choose white meat or dark meat, and dark meat has a loyal following.
The flaky crust holds everything together neatly. Extra gravy often gets ladled over the top, along with the mashed potatoes beside it.
Opinions do vary, which is fair for any dish with this much history. Some longtime fans feel recent batches have run salty, while others call the current pie as good as ever.
Many first-timers describe it as a grown-up version of the frozen pot pies they knew as kids. That comparison is meant as a compliment.
Fall is a natural time to try one. A pie with gravy just fits the season, and this kitchen has had decades of practice.
Beyond Chicken: Beef and Tri Tip Pies
Chicken may get top billing, but the supporting cast deserves a curtain call. Beef pie has its own fan club, and some guests actually prefer it.
One popular move is ordering two different pies as a dinner. That way, nobody has to make the hard choice between beef and chicken.
A tri tip pot pie also shows up on the menu. Fans describe the flavors as excellent and very different from the chicken version.
Indecision is practically encouraged here. Adding a second pie to a dinner order is a common habit, and leftovers rarely go to waste.
The beef pie with mashed potatoes, greens, and thick gravy has even won over a guest from the United Kingdom. That diner said it matched the pie and gravy back home.
That is high praise from a country that takes its pies seriously.
For anyone planning a return trip, this is the easiest way to keep things fresh. Rotate through the fillings and the visit never feels like a rerun.
The Full Dinner Lineup
Ordering the pot pie dinner is less like ordering a dish and more like signing up for a whole program. The lineup is generous.
It starts with soup or salad. Chicken noodle soup earns plenty of praise, and chicken barley sometimes appears as well.
The side salad can arrive topped with green bean salad. It is a quirky touch that some guests end up enjoying.
Next comes the house bread, often served as a mini loaf with soft butter. Many guests name the bread as a highlight of the whole meal.
The pie arrives with mashed potatoes and a vegetable of the day, such as green beans, corn, or carrots. Gravy ties the plate together.
The mashed potatoes divide opinion. Some call them smooth, while others skip them next time, so ordering gravy on the side is a handy option.
Then there is dessert, which is included with the dinner. Bread pudding and rice pudding are both common picks.
Plenty of diners leave with a to-go box. Pacing is a skill worth practicing before the final course.
Sweet Pies and Pudding Finales
Savory pies built the reputation, but the dessert case has its own loyal crowd. Fruit pies are a big part of the to-go business.
Cherry, peach, and apple appear often in orders. Mini sizes make it easy to grab several flavors at once.
Rhubarb pie also makes the list, which is a pleasant surprise for fans of that old-fashioned flavor. It is not something every restaurant offers.
Apple pie a la mode is a favorite way to end a meal. The apple pie also comes with a hefty amount of crust, which crust lovers appreciate.
Bread pudding is the dessert people mention most with the dinner. Rice pudding also has passionate supporters.
Ice cream rounds out the options, with mint chocolate chip getting a nod.
A common regret among first-timers is not buying extra fruit pies for later. Consider this a friendly warning to bring a bigger bag.
A Menu With Range
Pies may be the reason for the trip, but the menu stretches much further. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner all have plenty of choices.
Breakfast fans point to biscuits and gravy and hotcakes. Some say the hotcakes taste just like the ones from their childhood.
Lunch brings classic diner sandwiches. A beef dip with fries, a traditional club, and a turkey sandwich on sourdough all get mentions.
Burgers are covered too, including a bacon burger. Crispy onion rings and steak fries round out the sides.
There is also a surprising German streak, with schnitzel on the menu. Breaded chicken breast is another option that earns praise.
Chile verde makes an appearance as well. It comes with a large buttered flour tortilla and a house-made green salsa.
Daily specials keep regulars guessing. A few visits could easily be spent exploring before ever ordering the same thing twice.
Time Capsule Atmosphere
Nostalgia is practically on the menu. The dining room has a retro feel that many people describe as a time capsule.
Some say it has 1960s diner energy, while others see 1970s character. Either way, it feels like a place that has stayed true to itself.
The mood is cozy, quaint, and homey. Guests often compare it to spots they visited with grandparents as kids.
Seasonal decorations add some fun. In fall, a Halloween skeleton has been known to occupy a seat, serving as a very quiet dining companion.
The crowd tends to include many longtime locals, including plenty of retirees. Still, families and younger diners show up too, and the clientele spans all ages.
Cleanliness gets regular praise. Tables are kept in order, and staff can be seen tidying booths during service.
This is a good fit for families, comfort food lovers, and anyone who enjoys old-school dining rooms. Trendy it is not, and that is exactly the point.
Friendly Faces and Freezer Hauls
Ask people what they remember most, and the staff often comes up first. The team is known for being warm, upbeat, and quick.
Coffee cups stay full and water glasses rarely run dry. Food tends to arrive promptly.
Servers are happy to share recommendations when asked. First-timers often lean on that advice and walk away pleased.
The owners clearly care about their guests. They respond to feedback personally and thank people for supporting a small business.
Takeout is a huge part of the story. Pies sell to go, and some families buy them by the dozen to freeze for busy nights.
A family meal deal is also available. It makes feeding a whole household at home much easier.
The pies hold up well away from the restaurant too. If there is no time to sit, grab a box and go.
Planning the Pie Run
Good news for road trippers: the hours are easy to remember. The restaurant is open every day of the week from 8 AM to 8 PM.
That schedule works for breakfast, a late lunch, or an early dinner. Weekends and weekdays follow the same hours.
Expect to spend roughly 20 to 30 dollars per person. Many guests feel the dinner portions offer a lot of food for the money, though a few think prices run a little high.
Reservations are not taken. Plenty of parking makes arrival simple.
Arcadia is an easy trip from much of the Los Angeles area. Even guests coming from farther away find the stop worthwhile when combined with other plans nearby.
Overall, this is a beloved local spot with a long track record. Not every dish will win every heart, but the pies, the people, and the history make a strong case.
Come hungry this fall, order a pie, and leave a little room in the freezer. Some traditions are worth driving for.
