Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Choosing the right running shoe can feel like picking a favorite child. Both ASICS and New Balance have loyal fans who swear their brand is best. We decided to settle the debate by testing ten amazing shoes from both companies for an entire week, running through different terrains and conditions. Here are the ten winners that stood out from the pack.
1. ASICS Women’s NOVABLAST 4 Running Shoe
Ever felt like you were bouncing on clouds while running? That’s exactly what these shoes deliver. The trampoline-inspired design isn’t just a gimmick; it genuinely makes each step feel springy and fun.
Women who tested these loved how the engineered woven upper hugged their feet without feeling tight. The FF BLAST PLUS ECO cushioning uses about 20% bio-based materials, so you’re helping the planet while you pound the pavement. Plus, the tongue stays put thanks to the gusseted wing design.
Whether you’re training for a race or just enjoy morning jogs, these shoes add an element of joy to every run. They’re perfect for runners who want performance without sacrificing personality.
2. ASICS Men’s Gel-Nimbus 26 Running Shoes
Comfort meets sustainability in this impressive package. The Gel-Nimbus 26 wraps your foot in an engineered knit upper that feels like a gentle hug. At least 75% of the main upper material comes from recycled content, making these shoes an eco-conscious choice.
PureGEL technology provides lightweight cushioning that makes landings feel softer than ever. The FF BLAST PLUS ECO technology doesn’t just absorb impact; it actually helps create a more responsive toe-off. Even the sockliner uses solution dyeing, which cuts water usage by 33%.
After a full week of testing, runners reported less foot fatigue at the end of long runs. These shoes prove you don’t have to choose between environmental responsibility and top-notch performance.
3. ASICS Women’s Gel-Kayano 31 Running Shoes
Stability runners, rejoice! The Gel-Kayano 31 introduces the 4D GUIDANCE SYSTEM that adapts to your stride pattern. This isn’t your grandmother’s stability shoe; it provides support without feeling clunky or restrictive.
The combination of FF BLAST PLUS ECO cushioning and PureGEL technology creates an incredibly smooth ride. Women who typically struggle with overpronation found these shoes helped them maintain better balance throughout their runs. The engineered mesh upper keeps feet cool even during humid morning sessions.
Distance training becomes surprisingly comfortable when your shoes work with your natural movement. The external back heel counter adds stability without rubbing or causing blisters, something testers really appreciated during longer runs.
4. New Balance Men’s Fresh Foam X 860 V14
Sometimes the best innovations come from perfecting the basics. The 860 V14 focuses on delivering exceptional cushioning without unnecessary bells and whistles. The Fresh Foam X midsole provides what New Balance calls their most cushioned experience yet.
Road runners appreciated how lightweight these shoes felt despite their generous padding. The durable rubber outsole gripped pavement confidently, even when conditions got wet. The adjustable lace closure might sound simple, but it allows for a truly customized fit.
With an 8mm drop and synthetic materials that breathe well, these shoes handle everything from easy recovery runs to tempo workouts. They’re proof that you don’t need flashy features when the fundamentals are done right.
5. New Balance Women’s FuelCell Rebel V4 Shoes
Rebel by name, rebel by nature. These shoes challenge what you think an everyday trainer should be. The FuelCell technology creates a propulsive feeling that makes you want to pick up the pace, even on days you planned to take it easy.
The streamlined mesh upper adds race-inspired style to a versatile design. Women loved how these shoes transitioned seamlessly from long steady runs to spontaneous speed sessions. Geometric midsole design extends wider and stacks higher than previous versions, offering better stability.
Fun sublimated graphics give these shoes personality that stands out in any running group. The gusseted tongue with no-sew overlays prevents irritation during extended wear. These shoes remind you that training should be enjoyable, not just effective.
6. New Balance Men’s FuelCell Supercomp Trainer V3
Marathon training demands serious footwear. The Supercomp Trainer V3 answers that call with FuelCell foam containing approximately 3% bio-based content. This isn’t just marketing speak; testers noticed real propulsion with every stride.
The Energy Arc system pairs a carbon fiber plate with strategic midsole voids, creating stored energy that gets returned as forward motion. The angular midsole design cuts unnecessary weight without sacrificing support. Superior traction from the specialized outsole inspired confidence on various surfaces.
With a 4mm drop, these shoes encourage a more natural running form. Men training for half and full marathons found these delivered consistent comfort mile after mile. They’re built specifically for the long haul.
7. ASICS Unisex METASPEED Sky 3 Running Shoe
Race day demands race shoes. The METASPEED Sky 3 is engineered for competitive runners who count every second. The MOTION WRAP 2.0 upper improves breathability while maintaining the locked-in feel serious runners need.
FF TURBO PLUS cushioning provides impressive compression that translates to energy savings over long distances. The curved sole design helps conserve energy with each step, while the carbon plate guides your foot through its natural motion pattern. ASICSGRIP outsole rubber offers advanced grip for various terrains.
These shoes aren’t for casual joggers; they’re for athletes chasing personal records. Testers found them responsive and fast, perfect for tempo runs and race situations. When every second matters, these shoes help you find those extra moments.
8. New Balance Men’s FuelCell Supercomp Elite V4 Running Shoes
When seconds really do count, this is your weapon. The Elite V4 combines FuelCell foam with a thinner carbon fiber plate for superior energy return in a remarkably lightweight package. This is New Balance’s answer to the super shoe revolution.
The Energy Arc system increases stored energy and delivers higher total energy return than previous models. FantomFit upper provides ultra-light bonded support that doesn’t weigh you down. The lightweight airy mesh upper keeps feet cool even when you’re pushing hard.
With a 4mm drop and lace-up closure, these shoes feel dialed in from the first step. Race day testers reported feeling faster and more efficient. These aren’t training shoes; they’re your secret advantage when the starting gun fires.
9. New Balance Men’s Fresh Foam X Hierro V8 Trail Running Shoes
Roads are overrated. The Hierro V8 takes Fresh Foam X cushioning off-road with a Vibram outsole that laughs at challenging terrain. Trail runners need protection and traction, and these shoes deliver both without feeling heavy or clunky.
The micro-traction lug pattern grips roots, rocks, and muddy sections with confidence. The breathable yet protected upper construction shields feet from trail debris while allowing airflow. Testers loved how the cushioning absorbed impact on technical descents.
Fresh Foam X provides the most cushioned experience New Balance offers, which matters when trails get rough. Whether you’re exploring new paths or racing through familiar woods, these shoes handle whatever nature throws at you. Trail running just got more comfortable.
10. ASICS Women’s Gel-Venture 10 Running Shoes
Adventure calls for versatile footwear. The Gel-Venture 10 features a waterproof upper that blocks moisture, keeping feet dry when conditions turn wet. The upgraded midsole combines AMPLIFOAM cushioning with increased stack height for better comfort.
GEL technology in the rearfoot improves impact absorption, creating a softer feeling at footstrike. The mesh upper enhances breathability, preventing overheating on warm days. The trail-specific outsole pattern adapts to both roads and trails, improving grip on various surfaces.
Women appreciated how these shoes transitioned easily from neighborhood streets to park trails. The solution dyeing process used for the sockliner reduces water usage by 33% and carbon emissions by 45%. These shoes prove versatility and sustainability can coexist beautifully.
