Discover the charm and authenticity of Amish country dining with our curated list of restaurants that offer traditional Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine. Each establishment promises a delightful journey into the heart of Amish culinary traditions, served with warmth and a sense of history. From legendary buffets to cozy family-run eateries, this guide highlights the best spots to savor genuine Amish flavors.
1. Miller’s Smorgasbord
Founded in 1929, Miller’s Smorgasbord has become a culinary legend in Ronks, PA. This buffet-style restaurant offers a generous spread of Pennsylvania Dutch comfort food. Patrons can feast on homestyle favorites like roast chicken, mashed potatoes, buttered noodles, and the intriguing scrapple. Adding to its acclaim, Miller’s was ranked #3 buffet in the U.S. by USA Today in 2024. The dining experience is enhanced by a warm, rustic ambiance, creating a perfect setting for families and food enthusiasts alike. Its rich history and dedication to quality make Miller’s a must-visit destination.
2. Dienner’s Country Restaurant
Nestled in Soudersburg, PA, Dienner’s Country Restaurant is cherished for its cozy atmosphere and hearty portions. This eatery offers both a buffet and à la carte options, featuring Amish classics like meatloaf, rotisserie chicken, and the beloved shoo-fly pie. Visitors praise its down-home atmosphere and generous servings, making it a favorite among locals and tourists. The warm, inviting setting makes every dining experience feel like a homecoming, complemented by the restaurant’s commitment to serving authentic, comforting dishes that highlight the best of Amish culinary traditions.
3. Yoder’s Restaurant & Buffet
Yoder’s Restaurant & Buffet in New Holland, PA, is famed for its consistently excellent offerings, especially its fried chicken. This popular buffet also boasts pepper cabbage, homemade bread, apple butter, and decadent pies. Known for its classic Amish dishes and friendly, simple ambiance, Yoder’s provides a taste of home with every visit. The relaxed atmosphere and dedication to quality service invite guests to savor each dish slowly. Whether a local or a visitor, the experience at Yoder’s promises to be both fulfilling and delightful, capturing the essence of Amish dining.
4. Katie’s Kitchen
Located in Strasburg, PA, Katie’s Kitchen offers a delightful dive into Amish culinary traditions. This family-run restaurant specializes in hearty breakfasts, lunches, and dinners, featuring dishes like home-style chicken and meatloaf. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, Katie’s truly embodies the spirit of Amish hospitality. The restaurant’s roots in authentic Amish cooking make every meal a comforting experience, whether you’re enjoying a warm breakfast or a savory dinner. Each visit to Katie’s Kitchen feels like stepping into a beloved family gathering, enriched by home-cooked flavors and genuine warmth.
5. Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen
In Holmes County, OH, Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen stands out with its vibrant red-roofed dining room and classic Amish dishes. Diners can enjoy mashed potatoes, noodles, roasts, and schnitz pie in a setting that exudes local charm. Celebrated for its flavorful dishes and picturesque location in Ohio’s rolling hills, Mrs. Yoder’s offers more than just a meal—it’s a culinary journey into Amish culture. The restaurant combines traditional recipes with a welcoming environment, making it a cherished spot for both locals and visitors seeking authentic Amish dining experiences.
6. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant
Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant in Berlin, OH, is a charming small-town diner known for its oversized pancakes and community feel. This beloved eatery serves authentic Amish dishes such as dandelion gravy over potatoes, providing a taste of genuine home-cooked goodness. The restaurant’s inviting environment, combined with its commitment to quality, makes it a local favorite. Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast or a hearty lunch, Boyd & Wurthmann offers a friendly atmosphere that encourages conversation and connection. It’s a place where every diner is treated like family.
7. Local Amish‑run Family Restaurants
In Holmes County, OH, several local Amish-run family restaurants offer a true taste of tradition. These eateries serve dishes like trail bologna sandwiches, date pudding, and soup dumplings, embodying generational recipes served fresh daily. The relaxed, welcoming setting of these establishments invites diners to enjoy meals in a genuine Amish environment. Each restaurant provides a unique dining experience, steeped in history and culture, allowing visitors to savor the rich flavors and traditions of Amish cooking. It’s a culinary exploration where the legacy of Amish cuisine is celebrated with every bite.
8. Shady Maple Smorgasbord
Located in Blue Ball, PA, Shady Maple Smorgasbord is renowned as the largest buffet in the country. Offering an extensive selection of authentic Pennsylvania Dutch dishes, the buffet includes fried chicken, buttered noodles, and homemade ice cream. The grandeur of Shady Maple’s dining hall, combined with its dedication to quality and variety, makes it a standout dining destination. Guests can indulge in a wide array of flavors, experiencing the richness of Amish culinary traditions in a single visit. The bustling atmosphere and generous offerings ensure a memorable dining experience.
9. Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery
Der Dutchman Restaurant & Bakery in Walnut Creek, OH, is known for its broasted chicken and homemade noodles. This eatery offers a buffet-style dining experience with a variety of traditional Amish dishes, complemented by an extensive salad bar. The warm, inviting atmosphere of Der Dutchman makes it a preferred choice for families and groups looking to enjoy a hearty meal. The restaurant’s commitment to preserving traditional recipes ensures that every dish is a flavorful delight. Whether for a casual dinner or a special occasion, Der Dutchman provides a genuine taste of Amish culture.
10. Hometown Kitchen
Situated in Quarryville, PA, Hometown Kitchen is valued for its homemade bread and tender Amish-style roast beef. This restaurant offers a family-style dining experience, providing an opportunity to savor authentic Amish flavors without the usual crowds. Known for its relaxed ambiance, Hometown Kitchen allows guests to enjoy their meals in comfort and peace. The dedication to home-cooked quality and traditional recipes ensures a delightful culinary experience. Whether you’re a local or a traveler, Hometown Kitchen’s inviting atmosphere and delicious offerings make it a worthwhile stop in Amish country.
