When you’re craving a sub that packs more punch than anything Subway could offer, turn to these local legends. From coast to coast, these 20 sub shops deliver flavor, quality, and a whole lot of heart.
1. Denaro’s Deli – Dumont, NJ
Denaro’s Deli in Dumont, NJ, is a beacon of Italian flavor. Known for their gigantic “Super” sub, this deli combines tradition with taste.
Walking into Denaro’s, you’re greeted by the comforting aroma of cured meats and freshly baked goods. This isn’t just a meal; it’s a feast for the senses. The deli’s cozy, bustling ambiance adds to its charm, making each visit a delightful experience.
Denaro’s Deli represents the heart of New Jersey’s culinary spirit, offering a taste that’s both nostalgic and satisfying.
2. La Casa Formoso – Northvale, NJ
La Casa Formoso in Northvale, NJ, is where sub lovers’ dreams come true. Known for their Chicken Cutlet Supreme, this place takes subs to the next level. Imagine biting into tender chicken cutlets, layered with fresh mozzarella and savory prosciutto, all wrapped in a fresh, crusty roll.
The moment you walk in, the scent of Italian herbs and grilled meats greets you, promising a meal you won’t forget. The deli atmosphere, filled with laughter and friendly banter, makes every visit enjoyable.
What sets La Casa Formoso apart is their dedication to quality and authenticity, ensuring that every sub is made with love and precision. It’s a must-visit spot on any sub lover’s list.
3. Luigi’s Meats – Wood Ridge, NJ
At Luigi’s Meats in Wood Ridge, NJ, old-school charm meets culinary excellence. Known for their soppressata sub, this spot captures the essence of traditional Italian cooking.
Entering Luigi’s feels like stepping into a time capsule, with its vintage decor and the aroma of cured meats wafting through the air. It’s a celebration of flavors, with every sub crafted to perfection by skilled hands.
What makes Luigi’s Meats special is their commitment to using only the finest ingredients, ensuring each sandwich is a true delicacy. This is a sub shop that honors tradition while delighting the palate.
4. Mangialardo’s “G” Man – Washington, DC
Mangialardo’s “G” Man in Washington, DC, is a sub shop that has captured the hearts of locals for decades. Known for its iconic sub, the “G” Man, each bite is a harmonious blend of classic cold cuts layered on a crispy roll. This sub is more than a meal; it’s an experience.
Walking into Mangialardo’s, you’re greeted by the aroma of freshly baked bread and the hustle and bustle of a beloved neighborhood eatery. The nostalgic decor adds to its charm, evoking memories of days gone by.
What sets Mangialardo’s apart is their dedication to tradition and quality, ensuring every sub is crafted with precision and love. It’s a must-try for any sub enthusiast visiting DC.
5. Soko Butcher’s Philly Cheesesteak – Washington, DC
Soko Butcher’s in Washington, DC, offers a Philly Cheesesteak experience that stands apart. Featuring prime rib as the star, this cheesesteak is a sublime indulgence for any meat lover. Each bite delivers a satisfying blend of rich cheese enveloping tender slices of prime rib, served on a freshly baked roll.
The atmosphere at Soko Butcher’s is hip and inviting, drawing foodies and locals alike. The sounds of sizzling meats and friendly chatter create an ambiance that makes every visit memorable.
What makes this cheesesteak remarkable is the quality of ingredients and the skill of the chefs who prepare it. Soko Butcher’s is redefining what a cheesesteak can be, offering a taste sensation that’s hard to beat.
6. White House Subs – Atlantic City, NJ
Since 1946, White House Subs has been an Atlantic City staple, drawing sub lovers from all over. The secret? Bread so crusty and meats so generously piled that every bite is a testament to Italian-American culinary craftsmanship. Stepping into White House Subs feels like stepping back in time, where the past meets the present in a delicious dance.
The walls, adorned with photos of celebrities and loyal patrons, tell the story of a sub shop that’s as much a part of the community as the boardwalk itself.
If there’s one thing that sets White House Subs apart, it’s their unwavering commitment to quality and tradition. This isn’t just a sub; it’s a slice of history.
7. Rustic Cuban @ Colada Shop – Washington, DC
The Rustic Cuban at Colada Shop in Washington, DC, is a sandwich that transports you straight to Havana. With layers of roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, and tangy pickles pressed between Cuban bread, it’s a culinary journey in every bite.
Colada Shop’s vibrant atmosphere, reminiscent of a bustling Cuban café, sets the stage for this flavorful experience. The aroma of fresh coffee and sizzling meats fills the air, creating a lively and inviting environment.
What makes the Rustic Cuban stand out is the authenticity and passion that goes into every sandwich. With each bite, you experience a taste of Cuba, lovingly crafted to deliver a memorable dining experience.
8. White Hog @ 2Fifty BBQ – Washington, DC
The White Hog at 2Fifty BBQ in Washington, DC, is where Southern BBQ meets deli sandwich in a delightful fusion. This isn’t just a sandwich; it’s a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate.
2Fifty BBQ’s rustic setting, filled with the enticing aroma of smoked meats, enhances the experience, making each visit a culinary adventure. The chatter of satisfied patrons and the clink of glasses add to the vibrant atmosphere.
What sets the White Hog apart is the innovative blend of flavors and textures, transforming a humble sandwich into a gourmet delight. It’s a must-try for barbecue aficionados and sandwich lovers alike.
9. Bub & Pop’s Chicken Parm – Washington, DC
Bub & Pop’s in Washington, DC, offers a Chicken Parm sub that borders on the divine. Picture crispy chicken cutlets smothered in marinara sauce and melted cheese, all wrapped in a warm, crusty roll. This is comfort food at its finest, delivering flavors that warm the heart and soul.
The cozy, intimate setting of Bub & Pop’s enhances the experience, making each meal feel like a cherished family gathering. The smell of home-cooked meals and the friendly atmosphere create a welcoming vibe.
What makes Bub & Pop’s Chicken Parm special is the love and care put into each sandwich, ensuring every bite is a taste of culinary perfection. It’s a sub that must not be missed when in DC.
10. Artisan Meat Share – Chapel Hill, NC
Artisan Meat Share in Chapel Hill, NC, is where charcuterie and sandwiches collide in a delightful way. This isn’t just a sandwich; it’s an art form.
The chic, modern deli setting adds to the experience, with sleek decor and a friendly, knowledgeable staff eager to guide you through the menu.
What sets Artisan Meat Share apart is their dedication to sourcing the finest ingredients, ensuring every sandwich is a masterpiece. It’s a haven for food lovers, offering a taste of elegance and sophistication in every bite. A must-visit for those seeking a refined sandwich experience.
11. DiBella’s Old Fashioned Subs – Rochester, NY
DiBella’s Old Fashioned Subs in Rochester, NY, is a nostalgic journey into the world of classic deli delights. Known for their fresh-baked bread and traditional deli meats, every sub is a nod to the past with a flair for the present.
Walking into DiBella’s feels like stepping into a beloved neighborhood deli, filled with the comforting aroma of baking bread and the bustle of a busy kitchen. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes each visit a cherished moment.
What makes DiBella’s special is their commitment to quality and tradition, ensuring every sub is crafted to perfection. It’s a place where the past and present meet in delicious harmony, offering a taste of nostalgia with every bite.
12. Erbert & Gerbert’s – Midwest (WI, MN, etc.)
Erbert & Gerbert’s, scattered throughout the Midwest, is where creativity meets culinary delight. Known for their unique bread cut and playful sandwich names, each sub is a delightful surprise waiting to be discovered.
The lively atmosphere and quirky decor add to the charm, making each visit an adventure. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that brings joy with every bite.
What sets Erbert & Gerbert’s apart is their commitment to innovation and fun, ensuring every sub is not just delicious but also a conversation starter. It’s a place where sandwiches are more than just food; they’re a journey into a world of flavor and imagination.
13. Milio’s Sandwiches – Midwest (WI, MN, IA)
Milio’s Sandwiches, a Midwest gem, offers a sub experience that’s as fresh as it gets. With bread baked every four hours, the taste and texture are second to none, providing the perfect canvas for their delicious subs.
The bustling atmosphere, filled with the sounds of laughter and the smell of fresh baking, creates an inviting environment that keeps customers coming back.
What makes Milio’s stand out is their dedication to freshness and quality, ensuring every sub is a delightful blend of flavor and texture. It’s a sandwich experience that brings the essence of the Midwest to life, offering a taste that’s both comforting and satisfying.
14. Cousins Subs – Wisconsin & Indiana
Cousins Subs, with locations in Wisconsin and Indiana, is a Midwest favorite known for their “Better Bread” promise. Each sub is a celebration of fresh ingredients and meticulous preparation, resulting in a sandwich that’s both hearty and flavorful.
The inviting atmosphere, with friendly staff and a community vibe, makes every visit a pleasant experience. It’s a place where the art of sandwich-making is taken seriously, ensuring every bite is a delight.
What makes Cousins Subs special is their dedication to quality and innovation, offering a sub experience that’s both familiar and fresh. It’s a taste of the Midwest that’s sure to satisfy any sandwich lover’s cravings.
15. Tubby’s – Metro Detroit, MI
Tubby’s in Metro Detroit, MI, is where grilled subs and sweet treats come together in perfect harmony. Known for their hearty, flavorful subs, each bite is a taste of Detroit comfort food at its finest.
The retro-style diner setting, with its cozy booths and nostalgic decor, adds to the charm, making each visit a trip down memory lane.
What sets Tubby’s apart is their dedication to flavor and tradition, ensuring every sub and dessert is crafted with care. It’s a place where food and memories are made, offering a taste of nostalgia and satisfaction with every bite. A must-visit for anyone seeking a true taste of Detroit.
16. RU Hungry – New Brunswick, NJ
RU Hungry in New Brunswick, NJ, is a college town legend, famous for their “Fat Sandwich” creations.
The vibrant, energetic atmosphere is fueled by the university community, making it a lively spot for students and locals alike. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a rite of passage for anyone in the area.
What makes RU Hungry special is their dedication to creativity and indulgence, ensuring every sandwich is a culinary adventure. It’s a place where fun and flavor meet, offering a unique dining experience that’s hard to forget.
17. 2Fifty BBQ & Bub & Pop’s – DC
At the intersection of 2Fifty BBQ and Bub & Pop’s in DC, a sub masterpiece is born.
The unique ambiance at both locations adds to the experience, with the smell of smoked meats and the welcoming vibe of a community eatery. It’s a journey through flavor that’s both familiar and new.
What makes this fusion special is the collaboration of two beloved DC spots, bringing their best to the table in a delicious sub. It’s a testament to the creativity and passion for food that defines the DC food scene.
18. Colada Shop & Soko Butcher – DC
Colada Shop and Soko Butcher in Washington, DC, offer a sub experience that’s both offbeat and unforgettable. By blending Cuban flavors with artisanal butcher offerings, each sub is a delicious exploration of culinary creativity.
The trendy, vibrant settings at both locations enhance the experience, inviting food lovers to savor each unique bite. It’s a journey through flavor that’s both exotic and comforting.
What sets this duo apart is their commitment to quality and innovation, ensuring every sub is a delightful surprise. It’s a taste of DC’s diverse food scene, offering a sub experience that’s as memorable as it is delicious.
19. Artisan Meat Share – NC (again!)
Returning to Artisan Meat Share in NC, where pork belly and porchetta take center stage in this delectable sub creation. Each bite is a savory delight, with tender meats and rich flavors creating a taste sensation that’s hard to resist.
The stylish deli setting adds to the experience, with its modern decor and friendly atmosphere making each visit a pleasure. It’s a celebration of culinary excellence that’s both refined and satisfying.
What makes Artisan Meat Share worthy of a second mention is their unparalleled dedication to quality and flavor, ensuring every sub is a masterpiece. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly exceptional sandwich experience.
20. Luigi’s, Denaro’s, La Casa – NJ Trio
The legendary trio of Luigi’s, Denaro’s, and La Casa in North Jersey are the vanguards of sub excellence. Each deli offers its unique specialty, from soppressata to the “Super” sub, crafting a taste of Italy in every bite.
The bustling atmospheres, filled with the aroma of Italian spices and freshly baked bread, create a welcoming environment for all. It’s a celebration of Italian heritage and culinary skill that’s both authentic and delightful.
What sets this trio apart is their unwavering commitment to tradition and quality, ensuring every sub is a delicious journey to Italy. It’s a must-experience for anyone seeking the best of North Jersey’s sub offerings.
