Grab A Fork Because The Cinnamon Rolls At Walnut Creek Cheese In Ohio’s Amish Country Are Enormous

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Some Holmes County stops are quick errands, and some turn a planned ten-minute visit into an entire afternoon with a loaded cart and a bakery box riding shotgun. Tucked into the rolling hills of Walnut Creek, Ohio, one market has earned a loyal crowd of families and road-trippers who come back for its baked goods, deli counter, bulk aisles, and a kitchen gadget wall that seems to go on forever.

The headline treat is a cinnamon roll big enough that a fork makes good sense, but the bakery case is only the opening act. Keep reading for the full layout, the upstairs cafe, the parking advice locals wish someone had shared, and the hours that matter before you make the drive.

A Big Store on State Route 39

A Big Store on State Route 39
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

The address to plug into the GPS is 2641 OH-39, Walnut Creek, OH 44687, right in the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country in Holmes County.

The business is Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, and while the name puts cheese first, the building holds far more than a cheese counter.

Officially it is listed as a grocery store. In practice, it works more like a supermarket, bakery, deli, bulk food shop, ice cream stop, cafe, and gift shop all sharing one roof.

That mix explains why the place keeps a stellar reputation, holding 4.7 stars across more than 2,100 public ratings.

The store is easy to locate along the main road, and the lot is large. Shoppers coming from nearby Berlin often swing through on the way out of town, treating it as the final stop of an Amish Country day.

It also helps that the market stays open all year, so a winter or fall trip works just as well as a summer one.

First-timers should expect more aisles than they planned for. The building is big enough that some folks compare it to a small mall, and that is not much of a stretch once the upstairs level enters the picture.

Old Traditions, Modern Shelves

Old Traditions, Modern Shelves
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Country markets in Holmes County often feel frozen in time, but this one plays a different game.

Walnut Creek Cheese blends classic Amish Country market traditions with polished, modern amenities. The result is a store that respects its roots while still offering wide aisles, an elevator, and a dining level upstairs.

Cleanliness comes up again and again as a strong point. The shelves stay tidy, and the decor gets attention too, with scenic displays set along the tops of the freezer cases throughout the building.

Those little touches turn a grocery run into something closer to a sightseeing stop.

There is also a practical balance in what fills the shelves. Plenty of local items sit next to the familiar brands found in most grocery stores, so a family can stock up on Amish-made goods and still grab everyday basics in one trip.

That combination matters for locals who live nearby and for out-of-towners staying in a cabin or rental for the weekend.

The store’s products even travel beyond Ohio. Some shops in neighboring states carry Walnut Creek Cheese items, and longtime fans sometimes plan an Amish Country trip partly to see the source in person.

Not bad for a place whose name suggests one simple counter.

The Cinnamon Roll Situation

The Cinnamon Roll Situation
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Here is the reason to bring a fork. The bakery section is the single most talked-about part of the store, and the cinnamon rolls are the headliner that earns this article its title.

They are large enough that eating one by hand in the car becomes a questionable plan.

Baked goods top the list of what people mention about Walnut Creek Cheese, by a wide margin. The bakery case carries homemade items across the board, and the word homemade is doing real work here.

Pastries, breads, and other treats rotate through, so the lineup on a Tuesday may not match the lineup on a Saturday.

A smart move is to visit the bakery early in the trip and decide right then. Popular items can move quickly on busy days, especially on weekends when the whole region fills up with day-trippers.

Families often split one oversized roll at the cafe upstairs, which stretches both the budget and the stomach space.

Bakery boxes also make easy gifts for whoever stayed home. Just be honest about how many made it back to Columbus or Cleveland intact.

Call it a sweet problem to have, and one best solved with a plate, a fork, and no particular hurry.

Where the Cheese Name Comes In

Where the Cheese Name Comes In
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

A store called Walnut Creek Cheese had better deliver at the deli, and it does.

The deli counter draws steady praise for its large selection of lunch meats and cheeses. Regular shoppers often come specifically for this counter, filling up for the week before heading home.

Price is part of the appeal. Some deli items here can cost about half of what shoppers pay at their home grocery stores, which is a welcome surprise in a tourist-heavy area.

Not every item will be a bargain, of course. The overall store is not a discount operation, but the deli is where many people find their best value.

Staff at the counter get high marks for being friendly and helpful. On crowded days that patience goes a long way, since the line can stretch while folks decide between slicing options.

A tip for road-trippers: bring a cooler. Deli purchases hold up much better on a long drive back to Dayton or Toledo with ice packs in the trunk.

Plenty of families build an entire picnic or a week of school lunches from this one stop. It is hard to argue with that kind of practical payoff from a single counter.

A Meat Department With a Following

A Meat Department With a Following
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Some shoppers admit they never leave without a stop at the meat department, and that habit says plenty.

Walnut Creek Cheese runs its own meat counter alongside the deli. Fresh meats, packaged favorites, and jerky are common picks for people stocking a freezer or bringing home a taste of Holmes County.

Breakfast meats get special loyalty. Bacon and sausage from this store show up on many shopping lists, and since the headline already opened the door to breakfast pastries, they pair naturally with a weekend morning back home.

The quality of meats, cheeses, and dairy is a recurring point of praise.

Online and shipped orders are an option for some products, though experiences with shipping are more mixed than in-store shopping. Picking items up in person gives the most control over what goes home.

For families, the meat case can be a smart value play. Buying a few larger packages while in Amish Country can cut down on weekday grocery runs later.

Planning ahead pays off here as well. A cooler in the back seat turns this department from a quick browse into a real stock-up stop, and that is exactly how the regulars treat it.

Bins, Bags, and the Bulk Aisle

Bins, Bags, and the Bulk Aisle
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Serious home bakers tend to disappear into this part of the store for a while.

Bulk items rank as the second most mentioned feature at Walnut Creek Cheese, right after the bakery. Shelves hold dry goods packed in practical sizes, making it easy to restock the pantry in a single swoop.

Bulk spices are a quiet favorite. Buying them in larger bags often stretches a budget further than the tiny jars at chain stores, especially for families who cook from scratch.

Jams, jellies, and apple butter also earn attention nearby, and they make easy gifts.

Some regulars treat the bulk section as the main reason to visit. Cheese and bulk foods are their target, and the rest of the store becomes a bonus lap.

Prices across the store are generally described as fair and comparable to the area. A few items may feel steep, so it helps to compare and choose rather than toss everything into the cart.

A reusable bag or a sturdy box makes the trip home easier. Bulk shopping adds up fast, and nobody wants a split bag of flour across the back seat of the minivan.

Produce From Down the Road

Produce From Down the Road
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Farm to table is not just a slogan in Holmes County, where actual farms sit a short buggy ride away.

The produce section at Walnut Creek Cheese leans on that closeness. Shopping here supports local farmers, a point many regulars mention with real pride.

Seasonal fruit draws attention when it arrives. During summer, ripe peaches and cherries have been standouts, and the lineup changes as the months roll on.

A fall visit will look different from a July visit, which keeps repeat trips interesting.

Like any grocery department, produce can vary. Checking items carefully before buying is a sensible habit, since not every piece will be perfect.

That small step is worth it for anyone driving a couple of hours to get here.

The produce aisle also pairs neatly with the rest of the store. A basket of local fruit, a jar of apple butter, and a loaf from the bakery make a simple Amish Country care package.

For families teaching kids where food comes from, the location adds a nice lesson. The fields outside the windows on the drive in are part of the story on the shelves.

Nearly 200 Feet of Gadgets

Nearly 200 Feet of Gadgets
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Kitchen drawers across Ohio owe a lot to one particular wall.

Across from the grocery side, Walnut Creek Cheese runs a kitchen gadget display that stretches close to 200 feet. Peelers, baking tools, storage helpers, and utensils that nobody knew they needed fill the hooks from end to end.

Kitchen gadgets rank among the most talked-about features of the whole store. For home cooks, it can be the highlight of the visit, edging out even the bakery for some.

Browsing takes time, so budget extra minutes here.

The gadget wall also explains why the place feels bigger than a typical grocery store. It is a full shopping destination on its own, the kind of section that turns a quick stop into a long one.

Gift hunters do well in this aisle too. Small tools make easy stocking stuffers, and fall is a smart time to get a head start on holiday lists.

Kids may wander here while parents browse cheese, so it helps to agree on a meeting spot. In a store this size, a plan prevents a game of hide and seek near the whisks.

Leave a little room in the budget. This wall has a way of finding it.

Gifts, Decor, and Things You Won’t Find Elsewhere

Gifts, Decor, and Things You Won't Find Elsewhere
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Shopping lists usually go out the window once the gift area comes into view.

Walnut Creek Cheese includes a gift shop section along with home decor pieces. Rustic touches, seasonal items, and household goods round out the non-food side of the building.

The selection is often called unique. Some shoppers say they have found products here that they have not seen in any other store, which suits the insider spirit of a Holmes County trip.

Honesty helps, though. Mixed in with the local finds are some familiar items available almost anywhere, so it pays to look closely for the pieces with real Amish Country character.

Jams, jellies, and household goods pull double duty as gifts. A small bundle from this section works well as a hostess thank-you or a teacher present.

Seasonal shifts keep the area fresh. Visiting in the fall or ahead of the holidays usually means a different mix than in spring.

For anyone who likes to bring home something more lasting than a pastry, this is the corner to explore. Just remember the cart has to fit in the trunk later, and decor pieces can be surprisingly bulky.

Upstairs, Cart and All

Upstairs, Cart and All
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Most grocery stores do not invite shoppers to roll a full cart into an elevator and head upstairs for lunch. This one does.

The Upstairs Cafe sits on the second floor of Walnut Creek Cheese, reachable by stairs or by an elevator big enough for a shopping cart. That detail alone makes life easier for families and anyone with mobility needs.

The cafe serves quick, casual meals with daily options and a burger bar. Food comes out hot and fast, and prices are considered decent and fair for the area.

For a cinnamon roll with a fork, this is the obvious place to sit down.

Many travelers make the cafe their lunch stop during a day of Amish Country touring. It saves a second drive and a second parking hunt in a busy area.

One gap people point out is coffee. Anyone hoping for a specialty latte may want to plan a separate stop elsewhere.

An ice cream area on the main floor adds another reason for kids to behave in the gadget aisle. Between the cafe and the treats, the store can easily cover an entire meal break with no extra miles on the odometer.

Crowds, Carts, and the Parking Lot

Crowds, Carts, and the Parking Lot
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Popularity comes with a price, and here it is paid in elbow room.

Walnut Creek Cheese can get very busy, and crowded aisles sometimes make it hard to browse slowly. Even so, most people agree the store is worth the crowds.

First visits can feel overwhelming. The sheer number of departments means it helps to arrive with a loose plan, perhaps bakery first, deli second, gadgets last.

Weekdays tend to suit anyone who wants calmer aisles, though no time is guaranteed quiet.

Parking is plentiful in terms of spaces. Getting back out onto Route 39, however, can be tricky on busy days, and extra caution is wise when pulling onto the road.

Traffic control has been present on some occasions, which helps during peak times.

A few simple habits make the visit smoother. Keep kids close, agree on a meeting point, and leave extra time so the trip does not feel rushed.

Patience pays off here. The staff stays friendly even on packed days, and that steady attitude keeps the whole operation moving when the lot is full and the line at the deli wraps around.

Hours and Money Matters

Hours and Money Matters
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Timing matters most for anyone driving in from Columbus, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Dayton, or Toledo.

Walnut Creek Cheese is open Monday through Friday from 8 am to 6 pm. Saturday hours run a little earlier and shorter, from 7:30 am to 5 pm.

The store is closed on Sunday, which is common in Amish Country. Plan any weekend trip around that, since showing up on a Sunday ends in an empty parking lot.

Saturday’s early opening is handy for anyone who wants first pick at the bakery case.

As for cost, admission is free since it is a store, and spending is entirely up to the shopper. Prices are generally fair and in line with the area, though this is not a discount grocery.

Some items may feel a bit steep, while certain deli prices come in well below big-city stores. Comparing as you shop keeps the total reasonable.

The market is open all year, so it works as a fall drive, a winter stock-up, or a spring outing. Pair it with a stop in nearby Berlin for a full Holmes County day.

Check the official website before going, just in case hours shift around holidays.

Worth the Drive, Fork Included

Worth the Drive, Fork Included
© Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, Walnut Creek, OH

Every Ohio road trip needs one stop that justifies the gas money, and this market makes a convincing case.

Walnut Creek Cheese brings together a bakery, deli, meat counter, bulk aisle, produce section, gadget wall, gift shop, ice cream area, and upstairs cafe. Few places in Holmes County pack that much under a single roof.

It suits families who want a practical stock-up, couples on an Amish Country weekend, and home cooks who love a good gadget hunt. Groups can split up and still find something worth their time.

Crowds and a busy parking exit are the tradeoffs.

Those small hassles rarely stop people from coming back. Many shoppers say they visit every time they are in town, and some wish they lived close enough to go weekly.

The best approach is simple. Arrive early on a weekday or Saturday morning, bring a cooler, grab a cinnamon roll, and claim a table upstairs.

Then take the long way home through the hills. The fork, by the way, is not optional.

Neither is a second bakery box for the folks back home who will absolutely ask what you brought them.

Publish Date: November 19, 2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Brand_Element_1.png

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER &
RECEIVE A FAMILY VACATION PLANNING KIT!

We3Travel.com will use the information you provide on this form to send you newsletters. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting [email protected]. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

fam-book
Scroll to Top