Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Route 23 in Sussex County mostly carries commuters, lake traffic, and folks heading toward the hills of northwest New Jersey. Tucked along that stretch, though, sits a family-owned bakery where the shelves lean Dutch and the regulars have been loyal for decades.
Some families say it has been their go-to spot for 40 years. The lineup runs from windmill cookies and almond tarts to cronuts that people buy by the dozen.
There is even a fish fry truck that rolls in on certain Fridays, which is not something most bakeries can claim. The hours are simple, the prices are friendly, and the trip makes an easy weekend outing for families and couples.
Keep reading to learn what to order, when to go, and why so many Jersey locals treat this place like a small trip to Europe without leaving the county.
A Dutch Bakery on Route 23

Holland American Bakery sits at 246 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461, in the northwest corner of New Jersey. It is a family-owned bakery with a strong Dutch streak running through its shelves.
The location makes it an easy stop for anyone driving through Sussex County. Route 23 is a main road in this part of the state, so the bakery fits neatly into a weekend loop through the area.
The shop is not a fancy café or a trendy dessert bar. It is a classic hometown bakery that makes cakes, cookies, pastries, donuts, and breakfast sandwiches.
What sets it apart is the mix of old-world Dutch treats and familiar American favorites. Windmill cookies share space with cupcakes, and almond tarts sit near the cronuts.
Families from around the county have been coming here for years. Some say they first found it more than a decade ago, while others count their visits in decades.
That kind of loyalty is hard to earn and harder to keep. The bakery seems to have managed both, which is a good sign before you even reach the counter.
So the first question is simple. What exactly makes a Dutch bakery in Sussex County worth the drive?
Decades of Hometown Loyalty

Forty years is a long time to stick with one bakery. Yet some local families say this has been their go-to place for that long.
Others describe coming here for decades and finding the quality steady through the years. That steady track record is the backbone of the bakery’s reputation.
It holds a 4.8-star average across more than 700 Google ratings. For a busy small-town shop, that is a very solid number.
Newer fans keep showing up too. Some first-timers stop in once and plan their next visit before they even leave the parking lot.
The pull seems to come from a mix of things. Homemade quality, friendly faces behind the counter, and prices that feel fair all come up again and again.
One longtime fan even urged people to stop buying occasion cakes from the supermarket. That is a bold statement, but it shows how strongly locals feel about the place.
Bakeries like this one become part of family routines. Birthdays, holidays, and Saturday mornings all start to include a stop on Route 23.
And once a bakery becomes tradition, it rarely loses its spot on the calendar.
Windmill Cookies and Butter Classics

Cookies are the most talked-about item at this bakery, ahead of everything else. That says a lot in a shop that also sells cronuts.
Windmill cookies are a big part of the Dutch identity here. These classic Dutch cookies have such a following that one former customer admitted the main thing they would miss is the windmill cookies.
Jan Hagel cookies also appear on the shelves. These are another traditional Dutch cookie, and they give the case a true old-country feel.
Here is a useful tip straight from the bakery. The owners have explained that they do not use preservatives in their products.
Because of that, cookies can soften in humid weather. The bakery suggests putting them in the freezer, where they crisp back up.
That small detail tells you something about how the baking is done. Fewer additives mean a shorter shelf life, so plan to enjoy them soon or store them well.
A box of cookies is also an easy gift. Bring one to a family gathering and you may be asked where it came from before the coffee is poured.
Cookie lovers, consider this your first stop.
Dutch Treats Beyond the Cookie Jar

Dutch treats are part of the reason this bakery feels like a short European detour. The selection goes past cookies into tarts and pastries with a strong Holland connection.
Almond tarts are one of the standouts. They come up often among the pastries regulars mention by name.
Danish pastries also have a place in the lineup. Eclairs show up as well, adding a little French flair to the Dutch mix.
The bakery has also carried cheeses at the counter. That fits the European theme, since cheese and bread are everyday staples in Dutch homes.
For families, this section of the case is a fun way to try something new. Kids who know donuts and cupcakes can point at a tart or a Dutch cookie and taste a little bit of another culture.
Couples on a weekend drive can make a game of it too. Pick one Dutch treat each and compare notes on the ride home.
The labels and names might be unfamiliar to some shoppers. The staff behind the counter can help with that, so asking questions is part of the experience.
Just be careful. One Dutch pastry has a way of turning into three.
The Cronut Craze

Some people come for the Dutch side. Many others come for the cronuts, and they rarely buy just one.
The cronut is a cross between a croissant and a donut. At this bakery, it has become one of the most mentioned items of all.
Flavors include glazed, cinnamon sugar, maple, and chocolate. Maple seems to be a crowd favorite, with glazed close behind.
One longtime regular gives simple advice. Do not leave without a dozen.
Fans describe them as flaky and very hard to stop eating. Even a self-described lover of Italian pastries admitted the cronuts were the real star here.
A quick coffee and a cronut also make a nice short stop. That combo works well for a mid-morning break on a drive through Sussex County.
If cronuts are your main goal, earlier in the day is a smart plan. Popular items at busy bakeries can sell out, so arriving early gives you the best shot at your favorite flavor.
Fair warning for anyone counting calories. This is one place where a cheat day feels like part of the plan.
Old-Fashioned Donuts and Crumb Cake

Not every great bakery item needs a fancy name. Sometimes an old-fashioned donut does the job just fine.
Donuts get plenty of attention at this shop. The old-fashioned style is a favorite for people who like a classic.
Crumb cake has its own fan club too. Some people hear about it from friends and make the drive just to try a piece.
That can be a gamble on a busy day. One couple got the last small piece, and it vanished before anyone could share.
Croissants are another quiet hit. Even people who have never set foot in the shop have been won over by a chocolate-covered croissant brought in by someone else.
There is also an apple treat that earns praise from newcomers. The shelves change, so it is worth taking a slow look before ordering.
These everyday items are what keep locals coming back each week. Cronuts may grab headlines, but donuts and crumb cake build habits.
A mixed box covers all bases. Grab a few classics and a few new things, then let the family vote.
Breakfast Sandwiches Worth the Early Alarm

A bakery that opens at 6 AM knows its customers. Early risers come here for more than sweets.
Breakfast sandwiches are a quiet favorite. People mention them right alongside the pastries, which says a lot.
An egg and cheese on a poppy seed roll is one order that gets high praise. A visitor from New York City was impressed enough to plan regular return trips.
Fresh rolls make the difference here. When a bakery makes its own bread, the sandwich gets a strong head start.
Sandwiches are made to order, so there may be a short wait. That time often turns into a friendly chat with the staff.
For commuters on Route 23, this is an easy way to start the day. For families, it can be the first stop of a weekend outing in Sussex County.
Pair a sandwich with coffee and a pastry for a full breakfast. It is a simple, budget-friendly way to fuel up.
Morning people, this one is for you.
Custom Cakes for Life’s Big Moments

When a cake plan falls apart, quick help matters. One family learned that when their original cake maker was hurt days before a first birthday.
They called this bakery on a Tuesday and still got a half sheet cake and a smash cake in time. The design matched exactly what they wanted.
Sheet cakes for baby showers have also won fans. A raspberry filling is one choice that party guests enjoy.
Fresh cakes and cupcakes are regular parts of the menu. Many families trust the bakery for birthdays, showers, and holidays.
Not every order goes perfectly. A few customers have had issues, such as getting a different frosting or cake than they ordered.
The bakery has invited unhappy customers to bring cakes back and talk it over. Still, it helps to confirm your flavor, filling, and frosting clearly when ordering.
Online ordering is available as well. Some customers have ordered that way and found it quick and smooth.
Give yourself time when you can. A little planning helps the big day go sweetly.
Friday Fish Fry Truck

Here is a surprise for first-timers. A bakery in Sussex County also runs a fish fry food truck.
The truck serves fish on Fridays. Some couples look forward to it every year.
It has been especially tied to Lent. During that season, the truck has served fish every Friday until Easter.
The bakery has also called the fish and chip truck fun on Friday nights. Schedules can shift, so check ahead before planning around it.
Fans say the food is priced very reasonably. That makes it a nice option for families who want an easy dinner.
Each meal has come with a Bible verse. That small touch reflects the faith of the family behind the business.
The truck adds a different reason to visit. You can grab dinner and pick up dessert in the same stop.
Friday nights just got a little more interesting on Route 23.
Faith Behind the Counter

Some businesses keep their values quiet. This one shares them openly.
Holland American Bakery is a Christian bakery. The owners have said they enjoy showing their faith through their work.
That shows up in small ways. The Bible verses that come with the Friday fish meals are one example.
Many customers appreciate this side of the bakery. Some list it as a bonus reason they keep coming back.
For others, it simply adds to the personal feel of the shop. It reminds people that real families run this place.
The faith element does not take over the experience. It sits alongside the baking and the friendly service.
In a world of chain stores, this kind of personal touch stands out. It is part of what makes the bakery feel rooted in its community.
Values and pastries, served side by side.
Smiles at the Counter

Names matter at a small-town bakery. Customers often remember the people who helped them by first name.
Staff members are often described as kind and welcoming. Many people mention being greeted with a smile.
One newcomer called a staff member a vibrant presence at the front of the shop. Another described a different worker as lovely.
Service is not always perfect. A longtime customer once felt ignored during a visit and hoped things would improve.
Other notes mention a few mix-ups with special orders. Like any busy shop, there are good days and harder ones.
Overall, though, the warm welcome is a big part of the appeal. It is a large reason families keep making the trip.
Do not be shy about asking questions. The staff can explain the Dutch items and help you pick something new.
A friendly chat can be as memorable as the treats.
Outdoor Seats and Family Fit

Need a spot to sit? Head outside.
The bakery has a seating area outdoors. Some people mention that the only seats they saw were outside.
Plan for that on cold or rainy days. Many families simply take their treats to go.
On a nice day, the outdoor area is perfect for a quick snack. A coffee and cronut at a table makes for a relaxed break.
The bakery works for many types of trips. Families can let kids pick a cookie or cupcake, while couples can share a few pastries on a date drive.
Price is part of the appeal. Many people say prices are very reasonable, which helps when feeding a whole family.
Special order cakes can cost more, and one customer felt a cake was expensive. Everyday treats remain the budget-friendly choice.
Grab a box, find a table, and enjoy the slow pace.
Hours, Freshness, and Smart Planning

Timing is everything here. The bakery keeps a clear weekly schedule.
It is open Tuesday through Saturday from 6 AM to 6 PM. It is closed on Sunday and Monday.
That means no Sunday morning runs. Plan your weekend trip for Saturday instead.
Hours can change, especially around holidays. Check the bakery’s website before you go.
Freshness tips are worth knowing too. The bakery does not use preservatives, so bread can spoil faster than store-bought loaves.
The owners suggest freezing bread if you will not eat it right away. Pull it out as needed and it stays ready for later.
That advice matters for people driving in from far away. A cooler or freezer plan helps if you stock up.
Bakeries can sell out of popular items later in the day. Coming early gives you the widest choice.
A little planning keeps the trip easy.
Worth the Detour Down Route 23

Not every road trip needs a plane ticket. Sometimes a bakery box does the job.
Holland American Bakery offers a taste of Dutch tradition in rural Sussex County. Windmill cookies, almond tarts, and Danish share shelves with cronuts and donuts.
The family-owned spirit is easy to feel. Friendly staff, open faith, and decades of loyal customers give it real character.
It is not flawless. A few special orders have missed the mark, and seating is limited to the outdoors.
Still, the strong ratings and decades of return trips speak clearly. Locals keep coming back for good reasons.
For families, it is an affordable weekend treat. For couples, it is a sweet stop on a scenic drive.
Go on a Saturday morning, grab a dozen cronuts, and add a few Dutch cookies. You may find yourself planning the next trip on the way home.
Europe can wait. Sussex has cookies.

