Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Some sandwiches are lunch, and some are a road trip with rye bread on both ends. In Cleveland, one small deli serves a Reuben stacked so tall that plenty of people split it and still carry half home.
It runs only on weekdays, closes by mid-afternoon, and draws lines that can stretch inside the door. Folks drive in from Columbus, from other states, and even reroute long trips just to grab one.
The prices are not small, and neither are the portions, which is exactly the point. Keep reading to find out where this place is, what to order, when to show up, and how to make the most of your visit without getting caught off guard at the register.
A Corned Beef Landmark on St. Clair

Cleveland has plenty of sandwich counters, but only one calls itself the home of the biggest and best corned beef sandwich in Ohio. That bold claim belongs to Slyman’s Restaurant and Deli, found at 3106 St Clair Ave NE, Cleveland, OH 44114.
The spot sits just east of downtown, close to the expressway. That makes it an easy hop on and off the highway for anyone rolling in from Columbus, Akron, or Toledo.
The building is no glossy showpiece. The neighborhood around it is gritty, and the dining room is small, so expectations should stay realistic about the setting.
What happens inside is a different story. Slyman’s is a retro breakfast and lunch mainstay that specializes in corned beef, and the menu sticks close to deli classics.
The Reuben is a big part of that reputation. Corned beef, pastrami, rye bread, and serious portion sizes come up again and again whenever people talk about this place.
Out-of-towners often arrive after being told flat out that they need to eat here while in Cleveland. Once the first sandwich lands, the reason tends to become clear pretty fast.
A Family Name With a Loyal Following

Family-owned restaurants have a way of turning customers into regulars, and regulars into evangelists. Slyman’s fits that pattern neatly.
Plenty of people mention feeling good about supporting a local, family-run business. Even those who grumble about the bill tend to add that they are glad to spend their money somewhere with roots.
The staff carries a lot of that warmth. Counter workers ask where guests are from and whether it is their first visit, and first-timers get a playful welcome into the club.
That friendliness extends to pickup orders, too. The team is known for staying kind and quick even when the line is long and the phones keep ringing.
Loyalty here runs deep. One former Clevelander who has lived in Columbus for over three decades still makes the trip back every few months, loading up on corned beef sandwiches and Reubens to last until the next visit.
Fans from Georgia have hauled half a dozen sandwiches home for relatives. Others have planned whole driving routes around a stop on St. Clair.
That kind of devotion is not built by marketing. It comes from years of handing the same massive sandwich across the same counter, done right every time.
The Reuben That Steals the Show

Tall enough to need a game plan, the Reuben at Slyman’s is the sandwich that makes other Reubens look shy. It arrives stacked high with corned beef on rye, and it often gets split between two people.
The corned beef is the backbone. It is tender and moist, and the rye bread usually comes toasted.
Here is a useful tip for picky eaters. The kitchen builds the sandwich its own way, so condiments like thousand island or mustard may not match personal preference.
The fix is simple. Ask for sauces on the side and add them at the table.
Pastrami lovers have an option too. A pastrami Reuben is available for those who want to swap the star meat.
Diners from other states have compared it with famous delis in New York and Detroit. Some walk away convinced Cleveland wins the matchup, while others just smile and keep their verdict to themselves.
Either way, the Reuben has earned its place on the short list of reasons to drive across Ohio for lunch. One sandwich, two lunches, zero regrets.
Corned Beef, Pastrami and The Icon

Corned beef is the headliner here, and the numbers back it up. It is by far the most talked-about item at Slyman’s.
The classic corned beef sandwich comes on rye or a Kaiser roll. Seeded and non-seeded rye are both part of the conversation, so ask if one matters to you.
Pastrami has its own fan club. Some call the pastrami on toasted rye with Swiss the best sandwich of any kind they have eaten, while others still pledge loyalty to corned beef.
Can’t decide? A half corned beef, half pastrami option settles the debate without choosing sides.
Then there is The Icon. This one stacks corned beef, pastrami, turkey, and Swiss on rye, and horseradish, thousand island, and mustard can be added.
Roast beef rounds out the lineup for anyone wanting something different. On the side, potato salad, coleslaw, pickles, fries, and fried mushrooms all get kind words.
The overall message is clear. Whichever meat ends up on the rye, it will be piled high enough to need a takeout box.
Breakfast Before the Lunch Rush

Early birds get more than a shorter wait at Slyman’s. Doors open at 7 AM, and breakfast is part of the deal.
Corned beef hash is the obvious morning move. It turns the deli’s signature meat into a hearty plate that has its own following.
Potato pancakes also come up often among regulars. They are one of the more popular items beyond the sandwiches.
Hearty breakfast offerings in general are among the favorites. Coffee gets a thumbs up too, which matters when the day starts this early.
There is a practical angle here as well. Lines grow as lunchtime approaches, so arriving in the morning can mean a calmer visit.
Of course, nobody says a Reuben is off limits before noon. The deli serves its classics throughout its hours, so a breakfast run can easily end with a sandwich packed for later.
For road-trippers leaving Columbus or Cincinnati at dawn, a morning stop here makes for a strong first chapter. The rest of the day can figure itself out.
Small Room, Big Lines, Fast Counter

Lines are part of the Slyman’s ritual. On many days, the wait starts inside the door and moves steadily toward the counter.
The good news is that the kitchen works fast. Takeout orders can be ready in just a few minutes, and dine-in plates tend to hit the table quickly.
Phoning ahead is another smart play. A call-in order placed ten minutes out can be ready for pickup at the door.
Seating is limited, and the dining room is small. Some people have found dining in less available than before, so takeout may be the more reliable route.
The atmosphere is authentic and unfussy. There are plenty of staff behind the counter, and the energy feels more busy diner than quiet café.
Families are welcome, and the setting works fine for kids. Just plan for close quarters during peak hours.
Merch fans should keep an eye out for Slyman’s T-shirts. They make a handy souvenir for anyone who wants to show off that they survived the line and the sandwich.
What to Know About Hours, Cost and Parking

Timing matters more than usual here. Slyman’s is open Monday through Friday from 7 AM to 2:30 PM and closed on Saturday and Sunday.
That schedule catches people off guard. Weekend road trips will need a different plan, and arriving close to closing time can feel rushed.
Now for the money talk. These sandwiches are not cheap, with a corned beef sandwich or Reuben often running around $25.
Prices are not posted on the board. That means the total can come as a surprise, so it helps to ask before ordering.
Two sandwiches with a side and a drink can approach $50. The upside is that one sandwich can easily feed two people, which softens the bill considerably.
Parking takes a bit of attention. Some find free parking nearby, while others mention on-street spots only, so give yourself a few extra minutes.
Highway access is the bright side. The deli sits right next to the expressway, so getting in and out of the area is quick.
Worth the Drive, Worth the Wait

So, does one sandwich justify a drive across Ohio? For thousands of happy eaters, the answer keeps coming back yes.
Slyman’s has built a 4.7-star standing across more than 4,400 opinions. That kind of consistency is hard to fake.
The value math works best with a buddy. Split one Reuben, add a side, and both people often still leave with extra.
Solo diners can do just as well. Half the sandwich becomes dinner, and nobody complains about that.
The neighborhood is rough around the edges and the prices are high. Both are worth knowing before the trip, not reasons to skip it.
Best plan for families and road-trippers is simple. Go on a weekday morning, call ahead if the line looks long, and ask about sauces and prices at the counter.
After that, it is just you and a Reuben that may ruin every other sandwich in your future. Consider yourself warned, and maybe pack a cooler for the ride home.

