Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Highway 1 on the Sonoma Coast has a habit of making people hungry right when there is nothing around for miles. Then a weathered old building shows up beside the road, and cars start pulling over like it is a planned stop.
Inside, a small bakery turns out fresh bread and sandwiches that travelers keep talking about long after they get home. The shelves still hold toothbrushes and snacks, and antiques sit on display just for looking.
It is the kind of old California stop that many people thought had faded away. Some folks find it by luck, nearly drive past, then turn around.
Others plan entire coastal trips around it. Keep reading to learn where it is, what sandwiches people rave about, when to arrive before the good stuff sells out, and a few smart tips for getting back on the highway safely.
A Roadside Store at 32000 CA-1
Out on a quiet stretch of coastline, the Stewarts Point Store sits at 32000 CA-1, Stewarts Point, CA 95480, in Sonoma County, California, United States.
It is listed as a convenience store, but that label barely covers it. The building is old, the setting is rural, and the main business inside is a bakery called Two Fish Baking.
The store sits just off Route 1, not far from Sea Ranch. That makes it an easy place to stop for anyone traveling the coast in either direction.
Plenty of parking surrounds the building, which helps on busy days. Locals and Highway 1 travelers mix together here, and both groups seem to treat it as a regular stop rather than a one-time discovery.
There is also a practical reason the location matters. Drivers coming over to Highway 1 from Lake Sonoma face roughly 20 to 39 miles of winding roads, and this is the first place along that route to find food.
After that many curves, a store with fresh bread and coffee feels like a small reward. It is a spot worth marking on the map before the trip even starts.
Old Timey Charm, Kept on Purpose
Some places get renovated until nothing old is left. Not here.
The store holds onto its old school look, and people often describe it as a cute, old timey general store. Another common word for the style is shabby chic, which fits the mix of worn wood and vintage pieces.
Antiques are on display throughout the space. They are not for sale, so they work more like a small free exhibit of the past.
One standout is a vintage antique ice box cooler. It is the sort of object most people have only seen in old photos, and it tends to stop shoppers in their tracks.
The decor adds personality without feeling staged. It suits a building that has clearly been around a long time and still serves the same basic job of feeding people on the road.
For Californians who miss the small stores that used to dot the coast, this place can feel like a memory you can still visit. That alone makes the stop worth a few extra minutes.
Two Fish Baking Behind the Counter
Here is the secret that explains the crowds: Two Fish Baking is the primary business inside the store.
The bakery’s own website is listed for the shop, which shows how closely the two are tied. The name pops up again and again when people talk about why they stop.
Fresh bread is a big draw. Various types of fresh made bread are offered during the week, and plenty of travelers leave with a whole loaf for later.
Bread here is also made on the spot, which is part of why the sandwiches hold such a strong place in people’s memories. The rolls come from the same ovens.
Some items, like calzones, are made offsite by Two Fish. Either way, the baking operation shapes almost everything on the menu.
Longtime regulars who come to the coast now and then say having the bakery here makes the stop feel necessary rather than optional. Prepared meals and meats are also available, so a picnic or dinner plan can come together in one place.
Sandwiches With Names Worth Remembering
Sandwiches are the single most talked-about item at this store, and it is easy to see why the headline points here.
The menu includes options with memorable names, such as The Hog and The Pilgrim. Other choices have included a Mississippi pot roast sandwich, a meatball sandwich, and an Italian hero.
That Italian hero has earned high praise, with some calling it the best they have ever had. The fresh baked roll and quality ingredients get most of the credit.
Opinions are not all the same, which is fair. The Pilgrim, a turkey sandwich, has struck at least some eaters as underwhelming and short on balance.
A quick tip comes from experience. The Mississippi pot roast includes horseradish, and it is a strong one, so read the ingredients first if heat is not your thing.
Asking for a sauce on the side is a simple fix. With sandwiches made daily, there is usually a reason to come back and try a different one next time.
Breakfast and the Famous Early Buns
Early birds get the buns, quite literally.
Breakfast is served along with the daily sandwiches. Breakfast pastries, breakfast sandwiches, and a generously portioned breakfast burrito have all made happy travelers out of people stopping in the morning.
The sticky buns are a favorite and often called the best item on the menu. The catch is that they usually run out shortly after opening.
That makes timing important. Arriving close to the 7:30 a.m. opening is the best way to get one of the hot buns before they disappear.
Not every pastry wins everyone over. A cinnamon sugar morning bun has landed as nothing special for some, so the sticky bun seems to be the safer bet.
Breakfast here also works well for anyone heading out early along the coast. A pastry and a warm drink can carry a driver through a long stretch of quiet highway, and the store is one of the few places nearby to get both.
Coffee Counter Comforts
A long coastal drive almost always needs a coffee break, and the store is ready for that.
Coffee comes up often, along with cappuccinos, lattes, and hot chocolate. The cappuccinos in particular have earned some strong praise.
Oat milk is available for anyone who prefers a dairy-free option. That small detail matters on a remote stretch of road where choices are limited.
Results can vary a little from cup to cup. At least one oat milk cappuccino came out a bit too hot, though it was still considered pretty good overall.
Coffee pairs naturally with the bakery items, and many people grab both before heading back to the car. Some have also enjoyed pie with their coffee over the years.
The coffee stop also gives drivers a chance to stretch, look around at the antiques, and reset before the next set of curves. Fifteen minutes here can make the rest of the drive much easier.
Specials, Soups, and Surprises
Beyond the usual lineup, the menu likes to keep people guessing.
Specials appear from time to time, including a pozole special. A chicken noodle soup has also won fans, especially on cold days along the coast.
Calzones from Two Fish Bakery are another option worth looking for. They are made offsite and brought in, giving the menu some extra variety.
Cookies and other desserts round things out. Over the years, warm meals and desserts have been part of what makes this small market feel bigger than its size.
There is also an old-fashioned treat from the store’s past: the Boston Cooler, made with ginger ale and ice cream. It was recommended years ago, so it may not always be available today.
Since specials change, it helps to check the board or ask at the counter. A little curiosity at the register can lead to a lunch that was not on the plan.
Market Shelves for the Road
Forgot something? There is a decent chance the shelves can help.
The convenience section carries a nice selection of items. Basics like toothbrushes and hand wipes are stocked for travelers who left something behind.
Grocery staples show up too. Some shoppers have stopped specifically for mayo and fresh bread for dinner plans at a nearby rental.
For fun, there are old time sodas and retro candy. Those small treats fit the store’s nostalgic feel and make good car snacks.
Knickknacks are part of the mix as well. The selection is small, but it is well chosen for people far from a big town.
Beverages cover plenty of ground, from soft drinks to other bottled options. Prepared meals and meats also make it possible to stock up for a few days on the coast.
Prices are considered decent for what you get, especially given how isolated the location is. Exact costs can change, so expect some variation.
Benches, Breezes, and a Coastal Pause
Seating is limited, but nobody seems to mind.
There is a bench to eat at inside the store. Outside, several more benches give people a spot to enjoy a sandwich before getting back on the road.
The scenery around the store is a nice bonus, especially on a mild day. The coast is right there, and a short break feels well spent.
The overall atmosphere is friendly and casual. Staff are often described as nice and helpful, and hospitality has been part of the store’s reputation for years.
Service is not perfect every time. There is no clear signage showing which register to use, which has caused confusion during busy moments, so asking early can save time.
The space suits road trippers, couples on coastal vacations, and families who need a quick break. Locals stop in too, which keeps the place from feeling like a tourist trap.
Hours That Reward an Early Start
Plan around the calendar, or risk a closed door.
The store is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. On Wednesday, Thursday, Saturday, and Sunday, it is open from 7:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.
Friday runs a little longer, from 7:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. Hours can change, so it is smart to call ahead before a long drive.
Timing matters even during open hours. Food can sell out early, and during high season most items may be gone by around 1 p.m. on a Sunday.
Arriving near closing often means a slim selection of baked goods. Morning is clearly the sweet spot for the full lineup.
Restrooms are available, but the bathroom uses a passcode. Ask at the counter if you need it.
A simple plan works best: arrive early, grab breakfast or a sandwich, and keep moving up or down the coast with a full stomach.
Getting Back on Highway 1 Safely
Pulling off the highway is the easy part.
The store sits just off Route 1 with plenty of parking, so getting in is simple. Getting back on takes more care.
Visibility at the exit is poor. Traffic can move fast, and the lines of sight are limited in both directions.
Take a moment, look twice, and wait for a clear gap. Patience here is better than rushing back onto the road.
Many drivers almost pass the store entirely and have to turn around. Slowing down as you approach the area makes it easier to spot and safer to reach.
Drivers coming from Lake Sonoma should expect a long, winding route before reaching the coast. Leaving with a snack and drink can make the next part of the trip more comfortable.
With a little caution, the stop fits smoothly into any Highway 1 drive. Safe driving keeps the good memories intact.
Worth the Turnaround
Some stops are just a break. This one tends to become a tradition.
The store holds a 4.8-star average across more than 100 opinions, which says a lot for a small building on a quiet coast. Sandwiches lead the praise, with fresh bread and baked goods close behind.
It is not flawless. A sandwich may miss the mark, a pastry may feel ordinary, and busy lines can get confusing.
Still, the overall picture is clear. Good food, old charm, helpful staff, and a useful little market make it easy to recommend.
People who stop once on a whim often return on purpose. For some, it becomes a must on every trip up the coast.
Go early, check the days, and leave room in the car for a loaf of bread. The drive home may be long, but the sandwich will likely stick in your mind longer.
