Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Some shops in downtown Petoskey are quick stops. You grab what you came for and head back out to the lake.
Then there is the bookstore that quietly swallows your whole afternoon and sends you home with full arms and a lighter wallet. From the sidewalk it looks modest, but there is a second level hiding below the main floor, and plenty of first-timers never even find it.
Inside are staff picks that have turned non-readers into fans, puzzles stacked for snowy weekends, records, stickers, and a card wall that has made people forget they came for books at all. It is the kind of place Northern Michigan readers brag about to friends downstate.
Keep reading to learn where it is, what makes it special, and how to plan a visit that leaves time for both floors.
A Lake Street Bookshop With Northern Michigan Roots
Northern Michigan has plenty of shops that cater to summer crowds, but this one has earned a year-round following. McLean and Eakin Booksellers sits at 307 E Lake St, Petoskey, MI 49770, right in the heart of downtown.
Petoskey is a Lake Michigan town on Little Traverse Bay, and Lake Street is one of its main shopping strips. That puts the store within easy reach of anyone already strolling the downtown blocks.
The shop is an independent bookstore, and that matters to the people who love it. There is no corporate playbook here, just a store shaped by the people who run it and the community that keeps coming back.
Locals treat it as a regular stop, while travelers often mark it as a must on any Petoskey itinerary. Plenty of folks who make a habit of visiting a local bookstore wherever they go count this one among their favorites.
The store holds a 4.9-star standing across more than 380 Google entries, which is a remarkable number for any business. Words like charming, welcoming, and thoughtfully curated come up again and again.
Still, the address only tells part of the story. The real surprise is waiting once you get through the door.
Bigger Than It Looks
Here is the twist that catches nearly everyone. The store is much bigger than it appears from the outside.
Books and other goods are spread across two floors, with a large portion of the shop tucked downstairs. The street-level room alone could keep a reader busy for a good while.
That is exactly the trap. Some first-timers get so absorbed in the upstairs selection that they leave without ever discovering the lower level.
So here is the single most useful tip in this article: go downstairs. The History and Sci-fi sections live down there, along with a small used book section that bargain hunters will want to check.
The layout also earns quiet praise for how easy it is to browse. Shelves are arranged in a way that feels uncluttered and well organized, so wandering never turns into a hunt.
A bookstore with hidden depths is a fitting thing to find in a town full of old buildings and long stories. Give yourself extra time, because the second floor tends to double any plan you made.
Booksellers Who Read Your Mind
A man who had not read a book in years walked in with his family and walked out with a reading list. The owner and her husband suggested several titles based on his interests, and one of them, Dark Matter, got him hooked again.
Stories like that are why friendly staff is by far the most talked-about trait of this shop. It comes up more than any other detail.
Another shopper asked for help choosing books for a husband who struggled to stay interested in anything. A bookseller at the downstairs counter walked her to the shelves, picked out three titles, and he went on to read more from all three authors.
The team works together to find what people want. Booksellers here are passionate, and their suggestions have been called some of the best books certain families have ever read.
That kind of matchmaking is hard to get from an algorithm. Bring a vague idea, a favorite author, or nothing at all, and ask.
Odds are you will leave with something you did not know you were looking for.
Staff Picks and Special Editions
Curated is a word that gets tossed around a lot. In this case, it actually fits.
The selection feels hand-chosen rather than ordered off a generic list. Staff picks are a recurring highlight, giving browsers a shortcut to books the team genuinely stands behind.
Collectors have something to cheer about too. The shop carries special editions from the UK, which can be tricky to track down on this side of the Atlantic.
That is a nice bit of Michigan pride. You do not need a ticket to London to find those editions when Lake Street has them on the shelf.
Diversity in the selection is another strength. Readers point to a wide range of voices and genres, with something for just about every taste.
Author selection is also a frequent topic, a sign that the store keeps up with both bestsellers and lesser-known names. Fiction lovers, history buffs, and sci-fi fans all have their corners.
Tip for collectors: ask what special editions are currently in stock, since inventory like that tends to move.
A Children’s Section Worth the Detour
Grandparents, take note. The children’s area here is vast and nicely arranged.
Young readers get real space rather than a single shelf in a corner. Picture books, middle-grade novels, and activity books all have a home.
Activity books make easy gifts for grandkids, and they are a smart pick for long car rides back home across the state. The kid section is mentioned often enough that families clearly plan around it.
Graphic novels are part of the mix as well. That is good news for kids who like stories with pictures and for adults who never outgrew them.
A bookstore that welcomes children helps raise the next generation of readers. Northern Michigan families seem to appreciate having that resource right downtown.
Let the kids pick one book on their own. It might turn into the first page of a lifelong habit.
Puzzles, Board Games, and Cozy Weekend Supplies
Michigan winters are long, and this shop seems to know it. Puzzles are among the most mentioned extras on the shelves.
Plenty of shoppers leave with a stack of books and a puzzle tucked under one arm. It is an easy way to stock up for a cabin weekend or a snowy evening at home.
Board games show up here too. Families looking for something to do after the beach closes for the season can find options without a separate trip.
These items round out the store nicely. A book is a solo pleasure, while a puzzle or game pulls the whole household to the same table.
They also make dependable gifts for the person who already owns every book they want. Hosts, grandparents, and cabin owners all have reasons to browse this corner.
Plan to leave a little room in the car.
The Card Wall, Stickers, and Records
One traveler driving through town spotted the shop, pulled over on a hunch, and walked out with about ten cards and zero books. The card selection has been called the most beautiful anywhere.
That is quite a claim, but the giftable side of this store earns that kind of loyalty. Notebooks, stickers, and cards fill out plenty of space between the shelves.
Records are part of the lineup too. A bookstore with vinyl in the mix is a fun surprise for music fans tagging along with readers.
Together, these extras give the shop a whole vibe that goes beyond books. Everything seems carefully chosen, from the smallest sticker to the larger gift items.
They are handy for last-minute birthdays, thank-you notes, or small souvenirs from a trip up north. A card from a Petoskey shop says a little more than one from a gas station.
Budget a few minutes here, even if books are the main mission.
Author Events That Draw a Crowd
Some bookstores host the occasional reading. This one has pulled off big events.
A signing with author Matt Dinniman, known for the Dungeon Crawler Carl series, turned into a huge gathering. Fans praised how smoothly the whole thing ran and how organized and helpful the staff remained.
That kind of event is a big deal for a town the size of Petoskey. It means Northern Michigan readers can meet popular writers without driving to a major city.
The store runs many other events too, and people who live farther away often say they wish they could attend more of them. Readings and signings help turn a shop into a gathering place.
Event schedules change, so check the store’s website at mcleanandeakin.com before planning a trip around one. Popular signings can draw long lines.
Catching an author in person might be the best reason yet to head north.
Hours and Tips for Planning Your Visit
Good news for flexible schedules. The store is open seven days a week.
Monday through Saturday, doors open at 10 AM and close at 7 PM. Sunday hours are shorter, from 11 AM to 5 PM.
Those evening hours on weekdays make it easy to stop in after dinner downtown or after a day on the water. Sunday visitors should arrive earlier to leave time for both floors.
Here are a few quick tips for a smooth trip:
Allow at least an hour, since many people end up browsing far longer than planned. Head downstairs before you check out.
Ask for recommendations at either counter, since the staff clearly enjoy that part of the job. Check the website for upcoming events.
The store is open on holidays at times, including a Memorial Day visit that went off without a hitch. Still, confirm holiday hours before making a special drive.
A little planning goes a long way toward a relaxed afternoon here.
Why Petoskey Readers Keep Coming Back
Plenty of shoppers say they would buy far more books if they lived closer. That might be the most honest praise a store can get.
McLean and Eakin offers what readers hope for in an independent shop. There is a two-story layout that rewards curiosity, booksellers with sharp instincts, and extras that make gift shopping simple.
Prices on event days have even been described as surprisingly low. For many, a stop here is a highlight of any Petoskey trip.
It also fits a certain Michigan pride. You do not need to visit a famous bookstore in a far-off city when a shop this well loved sits on Lake Street.
Families, collectors, puzzle fans, and readers looking for their next favorite book will all find a reason to stay. Lapsed readers may even rediscover the habit.
Go in for one book if you like. Just know the clock tends to move faster once you reach the bottom of those stairs.
