Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Some road trips are planned around museums or scenic overlooks. This one is planned around a bakery counter.
Deep in Holmes County, there is a farm stop where cinnamon rolls come out so large they make a grown adult’s hand look small, and the line to grab one can stretch long on busy days. The bakery is only the start, though.
The same property has goats perched on a barn roof, buggy rides, kettle corn popped over an open fire, and a petting area packed with animals. Many treats on the bakery counter have been priced around a dollar, which makes the drive from Columbus or Cleveland a lot easier to justify.
Keep reading to find out where this place sits, what to eat first, which day it stays closed, and how to plan a full family outing around one oversized pastry.
A Farm Stop on State Route 557
The address to plug into the GPS is 5452 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654, in the heart of Ohio Amish Country.
Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery sits in Holmes County, a region famous for back roads, farm fields, and family-run shops. It works as a bakery, a food market, a craft shop, and a petting farm all rolled into one property.
The listing calls it a quaint food market with house-baked Amish goods, crafts, seasonal produce, and a petting zoo. That short line undersells it a bit.
Families often spend a large chunk of the day here, moving from the bakery to the barns to the leather shop and back again for another snack. The property is run by Amish folks, which shapes everything from the recipes to the pace of the place.
For Ohio road-trippers, the location is part of the appeal. The route winds through farm country, and plenty of regulars say the country drive is worth every penny spent on fuel.
It also pairs well with a bigger Amish Country day, since quite a few other local businesses are close by. Still, most people find this stop can easily fill a morning on its own, and the bakery is usually the first door they head for.
Three Generations Behind the Recipes
Recipes here are not pulled from a trendy cookbook. The family behind the farm describes its baked goods as made with third-generation recipes, handed down and still baked daily.
That daily baking shows up in small ways. Early arrivals often find breads still warm inside their packages, fresh from the morning ovens.
The farm has grown a lot over the years, and longtime fans have watched it turn into a major stop in Holmes County. The petting zoo expansion gets much of the credit, but the bakery stayed at the center of it all.
Personal touches pop up throughout the property. One of the horses in the petting area, named Jet, was the family’s own horse for years before retiring there at 18 years old.
Details like that make the farm feel less like an attraction and more like a working family operation that happens to welcome thousands of guests. The staff wear name tags, and management responds directly when someone raises a concern.
It is a homegrown story, and it explains why so many families treat the farm as a yearly tradition rather than a one-time stop. Now, about those rolls.
Cinnamon Rolls That Need Two Hands
Size is the headline here, and it is not an exaggeration. The cinnamon rolls at Hershberger’s are a frequent topic of conversation, and they come out big enough to dwarf a palm.
Big portions seem to be a house habit. The doughnuts get the same kind of attention, praised as much for their size as their freshness.
Planning tip: arrive close to the 8 AM opening if a fresh batch matters to you. Bakery items are made daily, and early birds get first pick before the counter gets crowded.
The bakery line can grow long, especially on fall weekends. Having a game plan helps, so decide before reaching the counter how many rolls are for the car ride and how many are going home.
These rolls also travel reasonably well, which makes them a handy souvenir for anyone who stayed home. A box on the kitchen counter tends to disappear fast.
Many treats at the bakery counter have been sold for around $1, though prices can change, so check at the counter. Either way, a roll the size of a dinner plate counts as solid value in any Ohio town.
Fry Pies, Cream Sticks and the Rest of the Counter
Cinnamon rolls may earn the headline, but fry pies are the most talked-about item on the counter. Some fans call them the best they have had anywhere, along with the dinner rolls.
The lineup keeps going from there. Donuts, cream sticks, pies, and breads all compete for space in the bakery cases.
Getting out of the bakery section without a full bag is a known challenge. Plenty of families walk in for one item and leave with a box of everything.
A smart approach is to split items and sample a little of several things. That way the whole group gets a taste of the classics without overloading.
Homemade ice cream also makes an appearance, and it rounds out a warm afternoon nicely. The cider slushy, including a peach version, is another favorite worth trying.
Just outside, kettle corn is popped in a kettle over an open fire. It is one of the most popular snacks on the property, and a bag makes a fine companion for the drive home.
Goats on the Roof and a Barnyard Crowd
Look up when arriving at the petting area. Goats on the barn roof are one of the most recognizable sights at the farm.
The petting zoo is the single most mentioned feature of the whole property. Multiple barns and outdoor pens hold cows, sheep, goats, rabbits, horses, hens, parakeets, llamas, and more.
Guests can pet and feed many of the animals, which keeps little ones busy for a long stretch. Baby animals are often part of the mix.
A few showstoppers are on display rather than in the petting pens. Peacocks and Texas bulls add a surprise element to the stroll.
The animals get to roam freely after visiting hours, a detail that shows how much care goes into them. The area is well maintained, and it keeps growing.
Teens enjoy it too, not just toddlers. Families with kids spread from age 9 to 17 have had a great time feeding the animals together.
One caution: these are real animals, and a pony bite has been reported. Keep fingers clear of stalls and supervise younger kids closely, since a petting area still calls for common sense.
Buggy Rides and Pony Trots
Few things say Amish Country like a horse-drawn buggy, and the farm offers rides for anyone curious about the experience.
Drivers get plenty of praise for being friendly. A buggy team known as Lady and Larry comes highly recommended.
Riding options also go beyond the buggy. Big horse rides are available for adults and kids, while small pony rides suit the youngest guests.
In fall, a pumpkin patch ride takes families out to pick their own pumpkins. It is a seasonal bonus that pairs well with a bakery run.
Ride availability and costs can vary by season, so ask on-site before promising the kids a specific ride. Weekends may bring longer waits.
These rides give the visit a slower rhythm, which is a welcome change from a typical road trip stop. Many families save one for last, right before heading back to the car with their bakery boxes.
A Market Stocked Like a Country Pantry
Beyond baked goods, the market works like a well-stocked country pantry. Shelves hold jams, jellies, canned pears, beets, and other jarred goods.
Bulk spices, soup starters, noodles, and grocery staples fill out the aisles. Meats, cheeses, eggs, and candy are also on hand.
Fresh produce is a major draw, and the store stays organized and clean. Seasonal fruit gets particular attention.
Samples of homemade items are often available, which helps with decision-making. Prices are widely considered fair for the quality.
Fall brings a big selection of mums and pumpkins. Pumpkins can show up as early as August, so cooler-month trips have plenty to browse.
Some couples make the trip twice a year just to restock their kitchens. A cooler in the trunk is a smart addition for anyone planning to haul home meats or cheeses.
Leather Goods Made on Site
Not every souvenir needs to be edible. A separate building on the property holds wood and leather products, and the leather shop has a strong following.
Many goods are made in-house or locally. Guests sometimes get to watch a craftswoman making wallets on site.
Wallets, knives, and knife sets are among the items people take home. The craftsmanship and attention to detail get consistent praise.
The gift shop adds textiles, wooden toys, holiday gifts, and treats for pets. Toys for kids make it easy to keep everyone happy.
For holiday shoppers, this is a handy stop to knock out a few gifts with a homemade touch. A leather wallet lasts a lot longer than a cinnamon roll, after all.
Hours, Parking and the Sunday Rule
Timing matters more than most people expect. Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery is open Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 5 PM, and closed on Sundays.
That Sunday closure trips up plenty of weekend planners, so build the trip around a Saturday or a weekday. Weekdays may offer a calmer pace.
Parking is plentiful, even when the property is busy. A food trailer on site serves breakfast, burgers, and more for anyone needing a real meal.
Restrooms are the main weak spot. Facilities include a basic bathroom and portable toilets, and management has said upgrades are planned.
Service at the registers can be hit or miss on busy days. Most staff are friendly, though, and management invites direct feedback.
Bring a few dollars in small bills for quick bakery purchases. The phone and website can confirm seasonal details before heading out.
Worth the Drive Through Holmes County
So, does it pass the worth-the-drive test? For families who want food, farm animals, and small-town Amish charm in one stop, the answer leans strongly toward yes.
The farm holds a 4.8-star average across nearly 5,000 ratings, a strong signal for a place this busy. Most people leave planning their next trip.
It suits young kids, teens, couples stocking a pantry, and anyone hunting for handmade gifts. Fall adds pumpkins, mums, and a pick-your-own patch.
Arrive early, skip Sundays, and budget extra time for the bakery line. Expect to leave with more than planned.
The cinnamon rolls may be what gets everyone in the car. The goats on the roof, the buggy rides, and the kettle corn are what bring them back next season.
