Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
A small carry-out window on the west side of Indianapolis has fish lovers driving in from other towns, and some of them come back the very next day. The line between a quick bite and a real home-style dinner gets blurry here.
Regulars talk about hot plates, friendly voices at the window, and sides that people remember. Here is a closer look at the spot, what it serves, and how to plan a stop without any surprises.
A Soul Food Stop on North Harding Street
Harding street fish&chicken sits at 2435 N Harding St, Indianapolis, IN 46208, United States, on the west side of the city. It is listed as a soul food restaurant, and the setup leans toward carry-out rather than a long sit-down meal.
Fish is the headline here. Perch, catfish, and other fish plates show up again and again in what regulars talk about, along with shrimp and chicken wings.
For Hoosiers who like finding small, no-frills places in their own backyard, this one fits the bill. It does not need fancy signs or a big dining room to earn a following, because the plates carry the reputation.
One note on the name: the headline above mentions chicken, and chicken wings do appear in what people order here. Fish, though, is what the crowd keeps coming back to, so expect both to share the spotlight.
The rest of this story covers the history, the menu favorites, the service at the window, and the practical details for planning a trip.
Why Fish Fans Cross County Lines
Some diners drive in from Bloomington just to eat here, and they say the trip was worth it. A few have even doubled back the next day, which is about as strong an endorsement as a fish plate can get.
The pull comes from a simple idea. People have been hunting for old-school fried fish, and this counter delivers it with a cornmeal coating that fans call cooked just right.
Regulars describe the fish as crispy outside and flaky inside. Others point out that it does not arrive greasy, which matters when a plate has to travel home.
Word of mouth seems to do most of the work. One person suggests it to another, and soon a friend from out of town is parked on Harding Street asking what to order first.
That kind of loyalty is hard to buy and easy to lose, so it says something that people still talk about it with such excitement.
Perch and Catfish, the Plate Leaders
Perch gets more mentions than anything else on the menu, and catfish is right behind it. Both are fried in an old-school cornmeal style that fans praise as crunchy and fresh.
A catfish dinner is described as coming with two pieces, fries, and coleslaw. The portions are called generous for the price, which keeps the value talk going among regulars.
Shrimp and other fish are also on the menu, so a group order can cover a lot of ground. One party of friends ordered about ten items and said every one of them hit the mark.
The fish arrives hot, and several people note that it tastes fresh rather than tired. That matters at a carry-out counter where turnover keeps things moving.
For first-timers, the safest bet is to follow the crowd. Ask for the perch or the catfish and see which side of the debate you land on.
Fried Green Tomatoes Steal the Spotlight
Ask around and the side dish that gets the loudest cheers is the fried green tomatoes. They collect more mentions than almost anything else on the menu, apart from the perch.
People say the seasoning is spot on. Words like perfectly seasoned and out of this world pop up often, even from folks who came in for fish.
They are cooked well too, which is no small feat with a tomato slice. The coating stays in place and the slice holds together long enough to reach the table.
A few regulars say they go back mostly for these. That is quite a compliment at a place with fish this well liked.
Order a plate for the table and watch how quickly it disappears. Sharing is polite, but nobody blames you for guarding the last slice.
Spaghetti, Slaw, and the Supporting Cast
Sides at this counter get real attention. Spaghetti appears in a number of comments, and people call it flavorful and really good.
The slaw has a sweet taste, according to one regular, and another says it is just right. Fries are described as fresh, a small detail that rounds out a plate.
Wings also draw praise. One customer called them a standout, and another heard good things about the burger but did not get to try it.
This is the kind of menu where a few extra items can turn a plain fish order into a full spread. People who ordered widely say the variety held up.
For a first visit, pair your main with at least one side that is not fries. That is where several regulars say the surprises are hiding.
Peach Cobbler to Close the Meal
Dessert is not an afterthought here. Peach cobbler gets repeated praise, and diners who tried it often bring it up right after the fish.
One regular summed it up with a quick burst of delight, calling it so good. Another listed it among the items that made a takeout order feel like a home-cooked spread.
It pairs naturally with a heavy fried plate, and many people add it to the order without thinking twice. The portion travels well, so it can wait until you are back at home.
If you are feeding a group, order an extra one. Cobbler tends to vanish faster than expected once the foil comes off.
Hours may vary, so check before you go if dessert is the main goal of your trip.
The Voice at the Window
A good plate gets people through the door, but a friendly voice at the window brings them back. Several regulars single out the person taking orders as upbeat, professional, and warm.
One customer placed an order by phone and was struck by how easy the call felt. When she arrived to pick up, the staff member remembered her name and greeted her with a smile.
Others say the crew seems happy to be there, and that the place is clean with food information easy to read. Those small touches add up for people who care about customer service.
Fresh, hot food in around eight to ten minutes is a typical timeline mentioned by one regular. Wait times can stretch longer on busy days, especially Fridays.
A friendly welcome goes a long way at a carry-out counter, and this one seems to have that part down.
A Carry-Out Spot With Smart Packing
This is built for carry-out, and one regular found that out the best way. The perch dinner was not soggy at home because holes had been poked in the top of the container.
That small step keeps the crust crisp on the ride, and the person who noticed it wondered why every restaurant does not do the same.
One customer with a three-star experience felt the food was decent but not special, and said it is designed for carry-out meals. The owner responded graciously and invited that person back to ask for her directly.
Most feedback leans warmly positive, and a few people said they loved the music playing while they waited. It makes the short wait feel lively.
For the best results, plan on eating soon after pickup, or head straight home with your order.
Hours, Orders, and a Soft Verdict
Plan around the schedule. The listed hours are Tuesday through Thursday from 12 to 6:30 PM, Friday from 12 to 7 PM, and Saturday afternoons until 5 PM.
The spot is closed Sunday and Monday, and hours may vary, so check before you go.
Calling ahead is a common tip, especially on Fridays and weekends. A phone order helps cut the wait when the line is longer.
The owner has noted that the restaurant is open Tuesday through Saturday and that past closures were due to vacations. That clears up a worry some people had in earlier years.
A few fans wish the doors stayed open later, since getting off work before closing can be tight on Fridays.
As a final word, this is a friendly, fresh, no-frills stop on the west side that fish lovers keep talking about. It earns a spot on any Indiana day-trip list for people who like their dinners hot and honest.
