Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Somewhere in Cincinnati, a shop lets you set your own price for paint, beads, yarn, and printmaking ink. That is not a typo, and it is not a gimmick.
The shelves are filled with donated art and craft supplies that might otherwise end up in a landfill, and the people running the place check that the markers still work before they go out. Teachers, students, hobbyists, and working artists all shop here, and some happily drive more than an hour to do it.
Keep reading to learn where it is, how the pay-what-you-can system actually works, what you can find on the shelves, and the hours you need to know before you make the trip.
A Craft Thrift Shop on Main Street
Cincinnati has plenty of shops, but very few work like Indigo Hippo. The store sits at 1334 Main St, Cincinnati, OH 45202, in the Over-the-Rhine neighborhood.
It is listed as an art supply store, yet regulars know it better as a craft thrift shop. The idea is simple.
People donate the art and craft materials they no longer need, and those materials get a second life with someone new.
Many shoppers say they had never heard of an arts and crafts thrift store before their first visit. That surprise is part of the fun.
The location makes it easy to fold a stop into a day in OTR. Staff have even been known to suggest places to eat nearby for out-of-town guests.
For Ohio road-trippers from Dayton or Columbus, the shop works well as an indoor stop on a cooler weekend. A downtown outing pairs nicely with a few minutes of browsing.
The store keeps a steady 4.8-star standing across more than 300 opinions, which says a lot for a place built on secondhand goods. Not bad for a hippo that runs on donations.
The Story Behind Second-Chance Supplies
Every craft closet hides a half-used box of something. Indigo Hippo was built around that truth.
The shop collects donated materials and puts them back on shelves for the next creative person. Shoppers call it a place where crafters unite, swapping goods they no longer need through donation.
That reuse mission matters to the people who come back again and again. Keeping usable supplies out of the landfill is a big part of the appeal.
It also changes how small projects feel. Some shoppers buy holiday cards and wrapping paper here each year, and they like knowing their gifts start with reused materials.
Donors get something out of it too. Handing off dusty supplies means those ideas can settle into the hands of someone who sees new potential in them.
For anyone trying to live with less waste, the shop has earned a reputation as craft thrift heaven. It is proof that leftover glitter can still find a purpose.
How Pay What You Can Really Works
Naming your own price sounds easy until you are standing at the counter. Plenty of first-timers feel a little nervous about it.
Indigo Hippo makes the process simpler than expected. Items are color coded by a suggested price range, so shoppers have a helpful guide.
From there, you pay what you are able to pay. The pay-what-you-can scale is a big reason art feels accessible to everyone here.
Students on tight budgets benefit the most. Some regulars say they wish the shop had existed during their student years and are glad to support it now that they can.
There is one exception worth knowing. Pieces made by local artists carry set prices, though shoppers describe them as reasonable.
Deals can get even better at times. One past sale took 60 percent off art and household paper supplies.
The system runs on trust and generosity. Pay a little more when you can, and the next person benefits.
Shelves Full of Surprises
A pasta machine turned up on the shelves once. That should tell you how wide the range can be.
The inventory covers nearly every type of art or craft. Shoppers find chalk pastels, stickers, buttons, zippers, stamps, bells, yarn, and hanging equipment.
Beads are a favorite. Some out-of-town regulars make the shop a required stop whenever they visit Cincinnati, mostly for the bead selection.
Printmakers do well here too. Ink and carving tools have been found for far less than the cost of new ones.
Watercolors, holiday decorations, and kids kits also show up. Because everything comes from donations, the mix changes from visit to visit.
That turnover is the real thrill. One trip might yield a crafty tree for a single dollar, and the next might reveal something nobody expected to need.
Smaller Quantities, Smarter Shopping
Sometimes a project needs three sheets of paper, not three hundred. Big box stores rarely see it that way.
Indigo Hippo fills that gap nicely. Shoppers can grab a handful of markers or a small stack of construction paper without buying a whole pack.
Quality is not left to chance either. The staff make sure supplies work before they hit the shelves.
That check matters with secondhand goods. Shoppers mention that their purchases, from ink to markers, have worked as expected.
Parents can pick up exactly what a school project calls for. Hobbyists can test a new craft without a big upfront cost.
Home projects benefit as well. Small odds and ends for household fixes often show up among the art supplies.
The result is less clutter at home and less waste overall. Buying only what you need turns out to be a pretty crafty idea.
A Space That Sparks Ideas
Not everyone who walks through the door calls themselves an artist. Many still leave with a new idea.
The shop has a way of inspiring browsers. A simple loop through the space can be enough to plan your next project.
Art made by others is displayed in the store, which adds to that creative pull. Seeing what local makers have done gives shoppers fresh direction.
The space is compact. Some describe it as a little cramped, but that is because it is packed with supplies.
Hours can slip away easily here. Shoppers often say they wish they could stay longer and look at every single item.
Calm music plays in the background, adding to the relaxed pace. It is the kind of place where browsing feels like part of the hobby.
Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
Helpful staff come up again and again when people talk about this shop. That kind of steady praise is hard to earn.
The team is known as kind, respectful, and friendly. They answer questions and help shoppers find what they need.
Visitors from out of town appreciate the extra help. Neighborhood tips, including nearby places to eat, are part of the welcome.
There is also a way to get more involved. The shop has offered volunteer opportunities for people who want to help out.
That community spirit fits the mission. A store built on donations naturally attracts people who like to give back.
Teachers, parents, and craft lovers all seem to feel at home. Good people make a small shop feel big.
Donating, Hours, and Planning a Visit
Timing is everything with this shop. Indigo Hippo keeps a short schedule.
The store is open Wednesday through Saturday from 12 PM to 6 PM. It is closed Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday.
Plan around those days if you are driving in from Columbus, Dayton, or farther. Showing up on a Monday would be a craft-astrophe.
Bringing donations is part of the experience for many regulars. The drop-off process is described as easy.
Gather unused paper, beads, yarn, or tools before you go. Your extras can help another maker start something new.
Families should note that kids items and kits are often available. Teachers looking for class project supplies will find it useful too.
More details are available at indigohippo.org. A quick check before leaving home can save a wasted trip.
Worth the Drive for Makers
Some shops feel like errands. This one feels more like a treasure hunt with a purpose.
Indigo Hippo brings together low cost, less waste, and a strong community feel. That mix is hard to find anywhere in Ohio.
It suits teachers stretching a classroom budget. It suits students, parents, and hobbyists curious about a new craft.
Working artists find value too, especially for printmaking tools, beads, and paper goods. Gift wrappers can stock up for the holidays.
The pay-what-you-can model keeps the door open to everyone. Color-coded suggestions make it simple, even for first-timers.
Plan a Wednesday through Saturday afternoon, bring a box of donations, and leave time to browse. Cincinnati locals may be surprised they waited this long.
Small shop, big heart, and endless leftover possibilities. That is a creative trip worth taking.
