Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Remember when picking a board game meant wandering real shelves and asking someone who had actually played it? That kind of toy shopping is still alive in Illinois, from Chicago’s Lincoln Avenue to Main Street in Galena and a strip in Sterling.
The eight independent shops below stock wooden toys, puzzles, STEM kits, and stacks of family games you rarely spot in chain store aisles. Some offer free gift wrapping, one lets you rent games before you buy, and a few are easy to pair with a walk through a classic downtown.
Many of these games cost less than a family movie night and get played for years instead of two hours. If you have grandkids to spoil or a game night that needs fresh life, these stores make a fun weekend outing.
Save this list for the next birthday, and send it to the friend who still owns a dog-eared copy of Clue.
1. Timeless Toys, Chicago, IL

Lincoln Square already has an old-world streetscape, so a shop that calls itself an old-time toy store fits right in. Timeless Toys sits at 4749 N Lincoln Ave, a short stroll from the neighborhood’s walkable plaza.
The shelves lean retro. Expect wooden toys, puppets, creative playthings, outdoor games, and books, along with educational board games, family activities, and puzzles.
What keeps it interesting is the mix. Modern toys picked for fun and learning share space with classics that grandparents will recognize from their own childhoods, which makes it a natural stop for a three-generation shopping trip.
Staff are known for steering shoppers toward the right gift, a real perk when you are staring at a wall of games and need one for a seven-year-old. Hours run 10 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday and 10 AM to 4 PM Sunday.
I would aim for a weekday morning. Saturday afternoons get busy, while Monday and Wednesday mornings tend to be the quietest.
2. Geppetto’s Toy Box, Oak Park, IL

Named after the woodcarver who built Pinocchio, Geppetto’s Toy Box leans hard into back-to-basics wooden toys. The European-style shop sits at 730 Lake St in downtown Oak Park.
Beyond the wooden pieces, you will find puzzles, books, music, tabletop games, and brainteasers. The selection skips fleeting plastic fads in favor of toys that could easily become hand-me-downs.
Ages run from infant to tween, so one stop can cover a baby shower and a fifth grader’s birthday party. The care in choosing quality products shows on every shelf.
Oak Park’s historic, walkable downtown makes this an easy add-on to a family afternoon. Curbside and in-store pickup are both available if you want to call ahead.
Hours are 10 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM to 4 PM Sunday. Sundays and Tuesdays are typically calmer than Mondays and Fridays.
3. Building Blocks Toy Store, Chicago, IL

Free gift wrapping is a small thing until you are running late for a party. Building Blocks Toy Store on Lincoln Avenue in Lakeview offers it on the house.
The brand list reads like a parent’s wish list. Brio trains, Hape wooden sets, Magna-Tiles, Fat Brain toys, Bruder vehicles, and Lego share space with craft kits, bubbles, plushies, and plenty of books.
Board games and strategy games get serious shelf space here, alongside STEM kits for curious kids. It is the kind of place to find toys a little different from what shows up at big box stores.
The shop has a classic neighborhood vibe with notably friendly staff. Weekend hours start early at 9:30 AM, closing at 6 PM Saturday and 5 PM Sunday.
Weekdays run 10 AM to 6 PM. Tuesday and Thursday mornings are usually quieter than Saturday.
4. Galena Kids – Toy Store & Learning Center, Galena, IL

Over fifty board games line the shelves at this Main Street shop, which is a lot of game night for a town of fewer than 3,500 people. Galena Kids opened in fall 2020 at 313 S Main St.
The store carries more than thirty carefully chosen brands. A large part of the floor is devoted to hundreds of STEAM toys and games, plus educational fidget toys and an arts and crafts section from more than six companies.
Little ones are covered too, with infant and toddler sections that include daily necessities. The focus is on durable, screen-free toys kids actually play with.
Free gift wrapping and canvas bags come with qualified purchases, and free street parking helps on a busy weekend. Pair it with a stroll past Galena’s preserved red-brick storefronts for an easy day trip.
Hours are 10 AM to 5 PM most days, stretching to 6 PM on Friday and Saturday.
5. MOORE Toys & Gadgets, Wheaton, IL

Here is a money-saving trick more toy stores should copy. MOORE Toys & Gadgets lets you rent games to try before you buy.
That alone makes it a smart stop for families tired of buying a pricey game that ends up gathering dust. The shelves also hold Lego, puzzles, fidget toys, crafting kits, and plenty of little gadgets you will not find elsewhere.
Kids get to interact, too. Lots of toys are set out for hands-on play, so the visit doubles as an outing rather than a quick errand.
The shop sits at 107 E Front St in downtown Wheaton, right by the train depot. Friendly staff help match games to ages and interests, and there is a gender-neutral restroom.
Open 10 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM to 5 PM Sunday.
6. Little Lincoln’s Toy Shop, Springfield, IL

Springfield has no shortage of Lincoln landmarks, but this one is built for kids. Little Lincoln’s Toy Shop is a locally owned store at 3001 W White Oaks Dr.
Expect high-quality classic toys, traditional wooden figures, and heirloom-style gift sets. Family board games, brain games, and interactive puzzles round out the shelves.
The selection is packed with unique treasures you will not find in big box stores. Complimentary gift wrapping makes it easy to grab a present on the way to a party.
Practical touches help parents. There is a free parking lot, changing tables, and kid-friendly activities.
I would save this stop for after a morning of capital sightseeing. Hours are 10 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday and 11 AM to 5 PM Sunday.
7. My Special Toy Store, Downers Grove, IL

Friday nights get a bonus hour or two in Downers Grove. My Special Toy Store stays open until 8 PM on Fridays, handy for a last-minute game night pickup.
Educational toys and games are the specialty. Wooden play pieces and developmental toddler toys sit alongside a solid board game shelf and a good stock of books.
The store is small but full, with a wide range for all ages. Many items are ones national chains rarely carry.
You will find it at 5137 Main St in the heart of the downtown district, so it works well with a walk around town. Curbside pickup is available, and there is a gender-neutral restroom.
Other hours are 11 AM to 6 PM Monday through Thursday, 10 AM to 6 PM Saturday, and 11 AM to 4 PM Sunday.
8. The Toy Store, Sterling, IL

Sometimes the plainest name hides the most fun. The Toy Store in Sterling opened in June 2022 and is family owned.
Inside, the range is wide. Board games, dolls, classic building sets, plushies, science kits, magic tricks, and arts and crafts supplies all encourage imaginative play.
For a Rock River community of around 15,000, it offers a welcome alternative to big box aisles. Kid-friendly activities and a free parking lot make the trip simple.
Check the schedule before driving over. The shop is closed Sunday and Monday, open noon to 6 PM Tuesday through Friday, and 10 AM to 2 PM Saturday.
Find it at 2900 E Lincolnway, Suite 15b.

