Maine is renowned for its delectable lobster rolls, from trendy urban eateries to charming seaside shacks. This list ranks five iconic lobster rolls across the state, from the creative Highroller Lobster Co. to the unbeatable Luke’s Lobster at Portland Harborfront. Whether you prefer your lobster with mayo or butter, these spots offer a taste of Maine’s finest seafood, set against the backdrop of picturesque waterfronts or bustling cityscapes. Join us as we explore the distinctive flavors and atmospheres that make each of these destinations a must-visit for any seafood lover.
1. Highroller Lobster Co. (Portland)
At the heart of Portland, Highroller Lobster Co. presents a modern twist on the classic lobster roll. Known for its creativity, this spot serves Maine-style rolls where lobster is generously tossed in mayo, adding flair with unique toppings. The urban vibe is palpable, though some find the mayo overshadowing the lobster’s natural sweetness. Despite its innovative approach, it lacks the quaint charm of seaside shacks, but it’s a hit among city dwellers seeking a trendy seafood experience.
2. Portland Lobster Company (Portland Waterfront)
Perched right on the Portland waterfront, the Portland Lobster Company offers an authentic New England experience. Its Connecticut-style roll, warm and buttery, is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The setting is idyllic, with waterfront seating and the salty sea breeze enhancing the experience. However, some patrons note a slight rubbery texture in the lobster compared to the top contenders. While the atmosphere is unmatched, the roll’s texture keeps it from clinching the top spot.
3. Bite Into Maine (Munjoy Hill & Fort Williams)
Bite Into Maine delivers a satisfying Maine-style roll with rich portions and balanced flavors, presented aesthetically with scallions. The buttery bun complements the mayo-dressed lobster, making it a delight for the senses. Situated at Munjoy Hill and Fort Williams, the locations offer scenic views but lack the authentic seaside ambiance of waterfront competitors. The roll shines in its portion and flavor balance, yet some might miss the classic coastal charm.
4. Cousins Maine Lobster (Fort Williams Food Truck)
Cousins Maine Lobster brings the classic Maine-style roll to the forefront with its simplicity and big flavors. Served from a food truck at the picturesque Fort Williams, near the iconic Portland Head Light, it’s both affordable and beloved. Patrons appreciate the freshness of the lobster, simply dressed in mayo to let the natural flavors shine. The scenic location adds to its charm, making it a must-visit for those seeking a quintessential Maine lobster roll experience.
5. Luke’s Lobster (Portland Harborfront)
At the pinnacle of our list, Luke’s Lobster offers an exemplary Maine-style roll, renowned for its generous lobster meat and perfect seasoning. Located on the Portland Harborfront, the setting provides breathtaking harbor views, elevating the dining experience. Although it’s the priciest option at $39, many consider it worth every penny for the quality and taste. Luke’s deftly combines superior lobster, impeccable flavor, and a stunning location, earning its top spot.
